Banana Split
intro
A nostalgic, loaded American diner treat with ripe bananas, three ice cream flavors, sweet syrups, whipped cream, and crunchy classic toppings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep dishes and bananas
First, chill 4 long glass banana split boats in the freezer for 5 minutes to slow ice cream melting during assembly. Peel 4 ripe but firm bananas, and slice each lengthwise down the middle into two equal long halves, taking care not to mash the soft fruit.
Whip fresh cream
In a pre-chilled medium mixing bowl, combine 1 cup (240ml) chilled heavy whipping cream, 2 tablespoons (15g) powdered sugar, and 1 teaspoon (5ml) vanilla extract. Whip with an electric hand mixer on medium speed for 2-3 minutes until soft, billowy peaks form; do not overwhip, as this will turn the cream grainy or form butter. Refrigerate the finished whipped cream until ready to use.
Arrange banana halves
Remove the chilled serving dishes from the freezer. For each dish, place two banana halves cut-side facing inward, one along each long edge of the boat, leaving a 2-inch wide trough down the center for ice cream. Press the bananas gently against the dish walls so they sit securely without sliding.
Add ice cream scoops
Dip a standard ice cream scoop in hot water and dry it between scoops to create smooth, round portions that release easily. Place three ½-cup (75g) scoops of ice cream in the center trough of each dish: position vanilla ice cream in the middle, chocolate ice cream on one end, and strawberry ice cream on the opposite end, totaling 1.5 cups (225g) of ice cream per serving.
Layer flavored toppings
For each serving, drizzle 1 tablespoon (15ml) of chocolate fudge syrup over the chocolate ice cream scoop, 1 tablespoon (15ml) of strawberry syrup over the strawberry ice cream scoop, and spoon 2 tablespoons (30g) of drained crushed pineapple over the vanilla ice cream scoop, distributing toppings evenly without mixing flavors.
Add final garnishes
Top each ice cream scoop with a 2-tablespoon (30g) dollop of chilled fresh whipped cream. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon (7.5g) of chopped roasted peanuts evenly across the three scoops per serving, then set 3 stem-on maraschino cherries, one centered on each whipped cream dollop. Serve immediately to avoid melted ice cream.
Tips
2.Warm chocolate fudge syrup for 10 seconds in the microwave on medium power before drizzling for a smooth, pourable consistency that coats ice cream evenly without clumping.
3.For a faster assembly, you can substitute store-bought canned whipped cream, but fresh homemade whipped cream delivers a richer, less sweet, more authentic flavor.

OMG, this was such a hit at our neighborhood potluck last weekend! I swapped the maraschino cherries for fresh dark sweet cherries and everyone was raving. SO good, totally tastes like the old soda fountain splits I got as a kid.
Super easy to throw together for a last minute movie night with my teen and his friends. 10 minute cook time? More like 5 minutes when you’re rushing! The kids devoured every last bite, no leftovers at all.
Game changer tip: toast the pecans a little before sprinkling them on top. Adds such a warm, nutty crunch that takes this classic split from good to unforgettable. Will be making this all summer long.
Wait, do you think I can use dairy-free vanilla ice cream for my lactose intolerant kiddo? I don’t want to mess up the classic vibe but need it to work for her.
Made this for my girlfriend’s birthday dessert and she said it was better than the banana split we got on our first date at the diner downtown. Total win for me, lmao.
This is exactly the banana split my grandma used to make after Sunday church dinners! The pineapple and strawberry toppings together? Pure nostalgia. I didn’t change a single thing, followed the recipe exactly.
Tried this last night but realized I forgot to get whipped cream last minute. Ended up using marshmallow fluff toasted with a kitchen torch and *chef’s kiss* it slapped. Will be doing that again on purpose next time.
My kids loved this so much they asked if we can have a banana split bar for their end-of-school party! Is there a way to prep parts of this ahead so I’m not scrambling the day of?
Wait, I feel like old-fashioned splits used that strawberry syrup that’s not the gloopy grocery store kind? Does this recipe work with store-bought topping or should I make it homemade? I don’t have a ton of extra time this week.
Made this for our family dinner dessert last night and my picky 7 year old who refuses all fruit ate the whole banana and asked for seconds! I added a little extra peanut butter drizzle because we’re a peanut butter obsessed household, no regrets.