basic cocktail
intro
The iconic American Old Fashioned is the foundational basic cocktail: smooth, balanced, gently sweet with bright citrus notes, perfect for slow, cozy autumn sipping at home.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep sugar and bitters
Scoop 1 teaspoon of granulated sugar from the matte white pinch bowl into the bottom of the 16oz crystal mixing glass. Add 3 full dashes of aromatic bitters directly onto the sugar, followed by 1 teaspoon of filtered water from the small glass ramekin to help dissolve the sugar. Do not add ice at this stage, as cold temperatures will slow sugar dissolution and leave a grainy texture.
Muddle sugar gently
Grip the honey-toned oak muddler, and press and twist the sugar, bitters, and water mixture against the bottom of the mixing glass for 10-15 seconds, until the sugar is almost fully dissolved into a thick, fragrant dark syrup. Avoid aggressive grinding or muddling, as this can scratch the glass interior and does not speed up dissolution.
Add measured bourbon
Use the fixed double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure exactly 2oz (60ml) of bourbon whiskey, pouring it from the back-left bourbon bottle directly into the mixing glass on top of the dissolved sugar syrup. Return the jigger to its fixed position left of the mixing glass once poured.
Stir to chill drink
Retrieve one large 2-inch clear ice cube from the pale grey silicone ice tray, and add it to the mixing glass with the bourbon mixture. Hold the mixing glass steady with one hand, and use the twisted-handle stainless steel bar spoon to stir the mixture slowly in a smooth circular motion for 20-25 seconds, until the outside of the mixing glass feels noticeably cold to the touch and the liquid is diluted by roughly 20%. Do not shake, as this will cloud the drink and create a harsh, aerated texture.
Strain into rocks glass
Fit the fixed stainless steel Hawthorne strainer over the top of the mixing glass, pressing the coil tightly against the rim to trap ice. Hold the 10oz lowball rocks glass at a slight angle, and pour the chilled, diluted cocktail slowly through the strainer into the rocks glass. Return the mixing glass and strainer to their fixed positions once pouring is complete.
Add serving ice cube
Retrieve the second large 2-inch clear ice cube from the silicone ice tray, and lower it gently into the rocks glass with the strained cocktail. The ice should sit partially submerged in the amber liquid, keeping the drink cold for 15-20 minutes without rapid over-dilution.
Express orange peel oils
Use the fixed channel knife to cut a wide 2x5cm strip of peel from the whole fresh orange, taking care to avoid cutting too deep into the bitter white pith under the orange skin. Hold the peel 5cm above the drink surface, colored side facing down, and squeeze gently to twist the peel, releasing fine citrus oil mist over the drink. Rub the peel lightly along the rocks glass rim, then drape it over the glass edge.
Add cherry garnish
Skewer one plump brandied maraschino cherry from the glass apothecary jar on the thin stainless steel cocktail pick, and rest the pick across the top of the rocks glass so the cherry sits just above the ice cube. Avoid dropping the cherry directly into the drink unless preferred, as it will overly sweeten the first few sips.
Tips
2.Avoid cutting into the white pith when prepping orange peel garnish: the pith contains harsh, bitter compounds that will overpower the bright, sweet citrus aroma you want to express over the drink surface.
3.Stir, never shake, this cocktail: shaking aerates the whiskey and creates a cloudy, thin texture, while 20-25 seconds of slow stirring produces a silky, smooth mouthfeel and crystal-clear appearance that defines a well-made Old Fashioned.

OMG this is exactly the old fashioned recipe I’ve been searching for! I’ve messed up so many batches before that were way too sweet or too watery, but this ratio is perfect. Made it for my guys’ poker night last weekend and everyone asked for the recipe. SO good, I’ll never use another old fashioned recipe again!
Game changer! I was so intimidated to make classic cocktails for our holiday potluck because I thought they’d be super fussy, but this is so easy even I could pull it off. My husband said it tastes exactly like the old fashioneds we get at our favorite downtown speakeasy. 10/10, will be making these for every dinner party from now on!
First time ever making any cocktail at home and this was so simple! I was worried I’d mess it up since I don’t have any fancy bar tools, but I just muddled the sugar and bitters with a spoon and it turned out great. My roommate and I drank these while we watched the game last night, so good!
Made this for my anniversary dinner with my wife last night and she was obsessed! She’s always ordering old fashioneds when we go out, and she said this was better than most restaurant versions. Super straightforward, zero cook time which was perfect because I was already busy cooking the steak dinner. Will be a regular in our house date night rotation!
Made a big batch of these for my friend’s birthday party over the weekend and they went so fast! I pre-mixed the bourbon, bitters, and simple syrup ahead of time so I just had to pour over ice and add an orange peel when guests arrived. Total game day — er, party day — saver. No one was waiting around for drinks all night.
Solid, classic old fashioned recipe. I usually add a maraschino cherry as a little extra garnish because that’s how my grandpa used to make them, but the base ratio here is absolutely spot on. Tastes like nostalgia in a glass, no weird fancy add-ins that don’t belong. Perfect for sipping on the porch after a long work day.
Has anyone tried swapping the whiskey for a non-alcoholic bourbon alternative with this recipe? I’m hosting a game night with a few sober friends next week and want to make sure everyone can enjoy a nice fancy drink without the alcohol! The base recipe looks so good I feel like it would translate great.
Just whipped this up after a long day of running errands and wow, exactly what I needed. I used rye like I usually do, added a luxardo cherry, and it’s perfect. So easy to throw together even when you’re tired and don’t feel like putting in a ton of effort. 10/10, no notes.
Tried this last weekend when my buddies came over to watch the fights and everyone loved it. I thought I’d accidentally bought the wrong bitters at the store (grabbed aromatic instead of the orange I thought I needed) but it still turned out incredible. Even my friend who swears he ‘hates whiskey’ had two glasses! Wild.