best bourbon cocktails
intro
Four iconic, perfectly balanced bourbon cocktails highlighting rich caramel, oak, and vanilla notes, ideal for slow sipping with good company at cool autumn gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill Serving Glassware
Place 2 heavy-base clear rocks glasses and 2 hammered copper julep cups in the freezer 10 minutes before mixing to chill thoroughly. For quick chilling, fill glasses with ice water while prepping ingredients, dumping water right before pouring drinks. Chilled glassware keeps cocktails cold longer without excessive dilution that mutes bourbon’s rich caramel and oak notes.
Prep Fresh Garnishes
Pull the orange, lemons, and lime from the reclaimed oak fruit bowl to the honey oak cutting board. Use the 3-inch paring knife to cut one 2-inch wide orange peel twist (avoid cutting into the bitter white pith), 2 thin lemon wheels, and 1 thin lime wheel. Pluck 6 small mint sprigs from the potted terracotta mint plant, set aside in one cream ceramic ramekin. Skewer 2 bourbon cherries on a short wooden pick for the Whiskey Sour garnish. Stir remaining granulated sugar with 1 tbsp warm water to make simple syrup for the sour, set aside in a second ramekin.
Stir Old Fashioned
Add 1 tsp granulated sugar, 2 dashes of aromatic bitters, and 1 tsp water to the clear glass mixing glass. Stir gently with the twisted-handle bar spoon to dissolve the sugar completely, then add 2oz bourbon and 1 cup cubed ice. Stir slowly and steadily for 30 seconds, running the spoon along the inside edge of the glass, until the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty to the touch and the liquid is chilled to approximately 40°F, with about 20% dilution from melting ice.
Muddle Mint for Juleps
Retrieve both chilled copper julep cups from the freezer. Add 4 fresh mint leaves, 1 tsp granulated sugar, and 1 tsp water to each cup. Use the hickory wood muddler to gently press the mint leaves 5 times per cup—do not grind or over-muddle, as this breaks leaf stems and releases bitter chlorophyll that ruins the bright mint flavor. The goal is to bruise leaves just enough to release aromatic essential oils.
Shake Whiskey Sour
Add 1oz fresh squeezed lemon juice, the pre-made simple syrup, 1 whole pasteurized egg white, and 2oz bourbon to the matte stainless steel cocktail shaker. Do not add ice yet: seal the shaker tightly and shake hard for 15 seconds (this dry shake emulsifies the egg white into a thick, stable froth without diluting the drink). Pop the shaker seal to release pressure, then add 1 cup cubed ice, reseal, and shake for another 15 seconds until the outside of the shaker is frosty and too cold to hold comfortably.
Strain and Pour Drinks
Dump ice water from the two chilled rocks glasses. Place one large clear ice cube in the first glass, hold the Hawthorne strainer over the mixing glass, and strain the chilled Old Fashioned slowly over the ice. Fill both julep cups to the brim with crushed ice, pour 2oz bourbon over each cup’s muddled mint base, and stir briefly with the bar spoon to combine. Hold the Hawthorne strainer over the cocktail shaker and strain the Whiskey Sour into the second rocks glass, holding the shaker close to the glass to preserve the egg white foam.
Add Finishing Garnishes
Express the orange twist over the Old Fashioned by holding it 2 inches above the drink and squeezing gently to release citrus oils over the surface, then rest the twist on the glass rim. Top each julep with an extra small mound of crushed ice, tuck a full mint sprig into the ice, and dust lightly with powdered sugar for a classic frosted look. Set the skewered bourbon cherry on the rim of the Whiskey Sour, dash 2 drops of aromatic bitters onto the egg white foam, and place a thin lemon wheel on the rim. Serve immediately.
Tips
2.Never over-muddle mint for juleps: pressing too hard or grinding leaves against the cup bottom releases bitter chlorophyll from stems and leaf veins, resulting in an astringent, grassy taste instead of the bright, cool mint aroma that defines a great julep.
3.Use pasteurized eggs for Whiskey Sours if serving to pregnant guests, children, or immunocompromised people: the dry shake emulsifies the egg white into velvety foam without cooking it, and pasteurization eliminates foodborne illness risk without changing the drink’s flavor or texture.

OMG wait, quick question about the whiskey sour—do you *have* to use egg white? I’m having a few friends over who are vegan, and I don’t want to leave them out of the cocktail roundup for our backyard BBQ this weekend!
Mint juleps are my go-to for Kentucky Derby watch parties every year, and this recipe is SO much better than the sad syrupy ones I used to make. The tip about muddling the mint *gently* so it doesn’t get bitter? Total game changer.
Made these for our weekly poker night with the guys and everyone was shocked I didn’t just buy pre-made mix. Old Fashioneds were smooth, not too sweet, went way too fast tbh. Only thing is I wish I’d bought a second bottle of bourbon lol
I’m a total cocktail newbie—will these still turn out okay if I don’t have a fancy muddler or shaker? I only have basic kitchen stuff and want to make these for my husband’s birthday dinner tomorrow!
Tried the whiskey sour last night for taco night and wow, it was SO good! I’ll never buy the sour mix from the liquor store again. That fresh lemon juice makes all the difference. My wife even asked for a second round before we finished dinner!
Do I need to use super expensive top-shelf bourbon for these? I’m on a tight budget for my housewarming party and don’t want to drop $50 a bottle if a mid-range option works just as well.
Made non-alcoholic versions for my teens to feel fancy at our family Sunday dinner and they loved them! Just swapped the bourbon for sparkling apple cider and adjusted the sugar a little, they felt so grown up sipping their “fancy drinks” with us.
I’ve been making Old Fashioneds the same way my dad taught me since the 90s, and I was skeptical this recipe would be better, but I caved and tried it last night. The tip about using a demerara sugar cube instead of simple syrup? *Chef’s kiss* Took me right back to being a kid sneaking sips of my dad’s drink at holiday parties.
Pre-batched a big jug of mint juleps for our group camping trip last weekend and they were gone in under an hour. Light, refreshing, not too heavy after a long day on the trails. 10/10 will be making these for every outdoor trip this summer.
Accidentally added way too much bitters to my first Old Fashioned attempt and panicked, but it was still so good! Can’t wait to try again tomorrow when I’m not rushing after work, I know it’ll be even better when I measure correctly.
Brought all three of these to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and I swear people were lined up at my cooler for refills. The whiskey sours were the crowd favorite by far, even with people who say they “don’t like bourbon”!
Quick question—how far in advance can I prep the mint for juleps? I’m hosting a Derby watch party this Saturday and want to get as much done ahead of time as possible so I’m not running around during the race.
Made Old Fashioneds for our football watch party last Sunday and they were the perfect pairing for wings and nachos. Way better than the beer we usually drink, my crew is already begging me to make them again for the next game.
Loved all three recipes, but I cut the sugar in the Old Fashioned by half because I don’t love super sweet drinks, and it was perfect for me! Super easy to adjust to taste without ruining the whole drink, which is my biggest fear with new cocktail recipes.
Made the mint julep and whiskey sour for my date night in with my partner last night, and they said it was better than the drinks we got at the fancy cocktail bar downtown for our anniversary. Total win, I looked like a professional bartender with zero effort.
Is it okay to skip the maraschino cherry garnish on the whiskey sour? I hate those neon red cherries from the grocery store and don’t have any fancy cocktail cherries on hand right now.
As someone who’s been drinking bourbon for 40+ years, I can confirm these are the real deal. No fussy frills, just classic, well-balanced drinks that let the bourbon be the star. My grandson asked for the recipe after he tried one at my birthday dinner last week, so that’s high praise.
I pre-batched a batch of Old Fashioneds on Sunday to have after work all week, and it’s the best decision I’ve made all month. No mixing after a long day, just pour over ice and relax. Game changer for my weeknight wind down routine.
We made all three cocktails for my best friend’s bourbon-themed bachelorette party last weekend, and they were such a hit! We even did a little taste test competition and the mint julep won by a landslide. 10/10, will be using these recipes for every girls’ night from now on.
I can barely make toast without burning it, so I was shocked how easy these were to pull off! Made the Old Fashioned for my dad for Father’s Day and he said it was better than the one he orders at his usual bar. I feel like a total mixologist now.