best cocktail
intro
The perfectly balanced classic Old Fashioned: smooth bourbon, bright citrus, subtle demerara sweetness, and aromatic bitters for a timeless, slow-sipping iconic cocktail.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill serving glasses
Using the stainless steel ice tongs, place one large 2-inch craft ice cube into each of the two crystal lowball glasses. Set glasses aside for 2 minutes to allow the ice to chill the thick glass base, which will prevent the cocktail from warming too quickly and over-diluting when poured. A faint layer of condensation will begin to form on the outside of the glasses as they chill, indicating they are ready to use.
Measure cocktail ingredients
Set the 16oz stainless steel mixing glass in the center of the work area. Using the double-sided jigger, measure 4oz of bourbon and pour into the mixing glass. Follow with 0.5oz of demerara simple syrup, then add 4 dashes of Angostura bitters directly to the liquid. Do not add ice yet, to avoid over-dilution before stirring.
Add ice for stirring
Using the ice tongs, add 4 large craft ice cubes to the mixing glass with the measured bourbon, syrup, and bitters. The ice should fill the mixing glass about 2/3 full, leaving enough room for the liquid to circulate freely as you stir.
Stir cocktail gently
Hold the twisted-handle bar spoon vertically, inserting it into the mixing glass so the back of the spoon rests against the interior glass wall. Stir slowly and steadily for 20-25 seconds, moving the ice in a smooth circular motion around the edge of the glass. Stop when the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty and cold to the touch; this will dilute the drink to the perfect balance (roughly 20% water content from melted ice) without making it watery. Do not shake, as this will cloud the drink and create unwanted ice shards.
Strain into prepared glasses
Place the Hawthorne strainer over the top of the frosty mixing glass, fitting the coil tightly against the glass rim to hold back ice. Hold one chilled lowball glass at a slight angle, and pour half of the mixed cocktail slowly over the large ice cube in the glass. Repeat with the second glass, dividing the liquid evenly between the two servings. The finished poured liquid should be perfectly clear, deep amber, with no floating ice shards.
Express citrus peel oil
Use the dark walnut citrus peeler to cut a wide 2-inch swath of orange peel from the whole navel orange, avoiding cutting too much bitter white pith (leave pith on the orange, only take the thin colored zest layer). Hold the peel 2-3 inches above each drink, colored side facing down, and give it a firm squeeze to release a fine mist of bright orange citrus oil over the drink surface. Rub the peel lightly along the rim of each glass to add extra aroma, then drape it over the glass edge.
Add cherry garnish
Skewer one plump luxardo cherry on a small stainless steel cocktail pick for each drink, resting the pick across the rim of each lowball glass so the cherry sits just above the drink surface. Do not drop the cherry directly into the drink, as this will leach too much sweet syrup into the cocktail and throw off the balance before you finish sipping.
Tips
2.Stick to the 8:1 spirit-to-syrup ratio (2oz bourbon to 1/4oz demerara syrup per serving): the Old Fashioned is a spirit-forward drink, and too much syrup will mask the bourbon’s caramel and vanilla notes, turning a balanced sipper into an overly sweet drink.
3.Never shake an Old Fashioned: shaking aerates the spirit and chips ice into tiny shards that cloud the drink and create a thin, watery mouthfeel. Slow, steady stirring for 20-25 seconds produces the perfectly clear, silky texture that makes this cocktail a timeless classic.

OMG this is hands down the PERFECT old fashioned recipe! I’ve been messing around with different ratios for years and always ended up with something too sweet or too watery from over-muddled fruit. Made a batch for my husband’s poker night last weekend and every single guy was asking for the recipe. Total game changer, will never use another old fashioned recipe again! SO good.
Super easy recipe for a solid classic old fashioned, no weird fancy ingredients which I love. I’ve been ordering these at bars for years and never tried making one at home because I thought it would be too fussy—turns out it takes, like, two minutes max! Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I added a tiny extra splash of bourbon because I like mine a little stronger, but that’s just personal preference. Great go-to for weeknight happy hours after work.
I made these for our family Sunday dinner last week to go with our steak and mashed potatoes, and my adult kids went absolutely nuts for them! My son said it tasted better than the old fashioneds he gets at the fancy steakhouse downtown. It was so simple to throw together even while I was juggling getting the rest of the meal on the table. Will definitely be adding this to our regular rotation for holidays and special dinners!