best grilling steak
intro
Perfectly seared, juicy grilled ribeye with a crisp salty crust, smoky charcoal aroma, and tender pink medium-rare center, the iconic centerpiece of any summer cookout.
Ingredients
Steps
Temper Steaks Before Cooking
Remove steaks from the refrigerator 45 minutes before grilling, pat completely dry on all sides with the faded indigo linen towel, and place on the center maple cutting board. Cold steaks seize on hot grates and cook unevenly, so ensure meat feels cool but not ice-cold to the touch, with no damp surface moisture remaining.
Season Steaks Generously
Drizzle 2 teaspoons extra-virgin olive oil over the steaks, rubbing lightly to coat all sides including the fat cap edges. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon flaky sea salt and 1.5 teaspoons coarsely ground black pepper evenly over every surface of the steaks. Press seasoning gently into the meat so it adheres rather than falling off when moved; the surface should have no bare patches of visible meat.
Preheat Grill to High
Light charcoal in the kettle grill 20 minutes before cooking, letting it burn until coals are covered in a thin layer of pale gray ash, reaching a grate surface temperature of 500–550°F (260–290°C). Use the wall-hung brass-bristle grill brush to scrape grates clean, then wipe lightly with an oiled paper towel to prevent sticking. Test heat by sprinkling a drop of water on grates: it should evaporate completely within 1–2 seconds.
Sear Steaks Over Coals
Use the stainless steel grill tongs to place steaks directly on hot grill grates, positioned diagonally across the grates for even grill marks. Sear for 3 full minutes without moving or pressing down on the steaks (pressing squeezes out flavorful juices), then rotate each steak 45 degrees on the same side to create cross-hatch marks, and sear for an additional 2 minutes.
Cook to Desired Doneness
Flip steaks with the tongs, then lightly crush the garlic cloves and add them to the grill grates along with the butter, rosemary, and thyme next to the steaks to create aromatic, herb-infused smoke. Cook for an additional 3–5 minutes, checking internal temperature with the digital instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the steak (away from fat or bone): pull steaks at 125°F (52°C) for medium-rare, 135°F (57°C) for medium. The butter will sizzle and melt, coating the steaks in rich aroma as it cooks.
Rest Steaks Before Slicing
Use the tongs to transfer cooked steaks back to the maple cutting board, loosely tent with a sheet of aluminum foil pulled from the roll behind the mixing bowl, and let rest for 8–10 minutes. Resting allows muscle fibers to relax and reabsorb juices, so every bite is juicy rather than having liquid run across the plate when sliced. Expect 3–5°F of carryover cooking during this time, which raises the final internal temperature.
Slice Against the Grain
After resting, use the 8-inch chef knife to slice steaks against the grain into 1/2-inch thick slices. Slicing against the grain shortens long, tough muscle fibers, making each bite tender rather than chewy. For medium-rare, the center of each slice should be soft rosy pink, with a thin band of fully cooked brown meat leading to the dark, crisp seared crust.
Plate and Serve Hot
Arrange sliced steak in a loose, overlapping fan on the top speckled cream stoneware dinner plate from the stack, spoon any collected juices from the cutting board over the top, and add a small pat of reserved herb butter from the black ramekin if desired. Serve immediately while warm.
Tips
2.Skip the lighter fluid when lighting charcoal: it leaves a harsh, chemical aftertaste that sticks to the meat and masks the beef’s natural flavor. Use a chimney starter for clean, even heat that lets the steak and smoky charcoal flavor shine.
3.Never cut into steak immediately after grilling: the high heat pushes all juices to the center of the meat, and slicing right away causes those juices to run out onto the plate, leaving you with dry, bland steak. The 8–10 minute rest is non-negotiable for juicy results.

OMG, made this for our Sunday family dinner last night and everyone was raving! The crust was perfect, the 12 minute cook time was spot on for my charcoal grill, even my super picky teen said it was better than the steakhouse downtown. Total game changer, will be my go-to ribeye recipe from now on!
Wait, has anyone tried this with a cast iron sear after grilling? I usually do that for extra crust but wasn’t sure if it would mess up the charcoal flavor here. Also, does the cook time hold for 1.5 inch thick ribeyes?
Made this for my husband’s birthday cookout and he said it’s the best steak I’ve ever made! SO good, I was worried charcoal grilling would be tricky since I usually use gas, but the instructions were super straightforward even for a medium-skill recipe. My kids even ate every last bite, no complaints!
Tried this last night and the cook time felt way off? My steaks were 1.25 inches, I had my charcoal grill at the temp the recipe said, but after 12 minutes they were well done instead of medium rare. Bummed because the flavor was great, just overcooked.
Made these for a potluck with my neighbors last weekend and everyone was asking for the recipe! The charcoal flavor is so deep, I didn’t even need fancy steak sauce — just a little flaky salt and pepper like the recipe says, and it was perfect. 10/10, no notes.
Wait, can you prep these steaks ahead of time? Like, salt them the night before like I do with brisket? I want to make these for my meal prep for the week but don’t want to mess up the texture.
Cooked these up after a day out on the boat last weekend, paired with some grilled corn and baked potatoes. Absolute perfection, the charcoal gave it that classic summer cookout vibe I was craving. Even my buddy who swears by gas grills admitted it was the best steak he’d had all summer.
Is there a trick to getting the crosshatch grill marks like in the photos? I can never get mine to look that nice, they always end up uneven even when I oil the grates.
Has anyone added a little garlic butter to the top of these while they rest? I usually do that for my grilled steaks but wasn’t sure if it would overpower the nice charcoal flavor this recipe is going for.
12 minutes cook time is no joke! I was skeptical because my usual ribeye cook takes closer to 20, but I followed the instructions exactly, got my coals white hot, and it came out perfect medium rare with that gorgeous pink center. Game. Changer. No more guessing if my steak is done, this timing works.
I’ve never used a charcoal grill before, I was super intimidated even though this is medium difficulty, but the step by step instructions made it so easy! My first ever charcoal grilled steak came out juicy, flavorful, no burnt edges. I’m so proud of myself, my roommate couldn’t believe it was my first try.
We raise our own beef out here, so I’m super picky about how ribeyes are cooked. This recipe let the actual flavor of the beef shine through instead of piling on a bunch of heavy seasonings. The charcoal smoke added just the right amount of depth, my whole crew went back for seconds (and thirds for my teenage son).
Wait, do you have to use ribeye for this? I have a couple of New York strips in the fridge I need to use up, would the same cook time and method work for those too?
Made these for our extended family dinner last Sunday, we had 8 people over and everyone raved. I had a tiny bit leftover and sliced it thin for cheesesteaks the next day, and it was even better? 10/10, will be making this all summer long for every cookout.
Pro tip for everyone: add a small chunk of hickory wood to your coals right before you put the steaks on. It adds a tiny extra smoky kick that takes this recipe from great to out of this world. I did it last weekend and my guests thought I catered the steaks from a fancy BBQ joint.