best old fashioned
intro
The timeless, perfectly balanced Old Fashioned blends smooth bourbon, warm sugar, aromatic bitters, and bright citrus for a slow-sipped, sophisticated cocktail ideal for cozy winter evenings.
Ingredients
Steps
Add sugar and bitters
Place the 10oz crystal lowball glass at center prep area. Drop 1 white sugar cube into the bottom of the glass, then add 3 dashes of aromatic bitters directly onto the sugar cube. Drizzle 1 teaspoon of filtered water over the cube to help it soften and dissolve. Do not add ice yet.
Muddle sugar gently
Hold the maple wood muddler in your dominant hand, press down on the softened sugar cube with gentle, twisting motions 4-5 times, just enough to crush the cube into a coarse, wet paste at the bottom of the glass. Do not over-muddle or grind aggressively—you only need to dissolve the sugar, not create a fine powder. The mixture should look like thick, dark golden syrup with no large sugar chunks remaining.
Measure and add bourbon
Pick up the stainless steel double jigger, measure exactly 2oz (60ml) of bourbon from the bottle, then pour it directly into the lowball glass over the muddled sugar paste. Give the mixture a single slow stir with the twisted bar spoon to combine the sugar paste with the bourbon, about 3 seconds of stirring. Do not add ice yet.
Add the craft ice
Use the stainless steel ice tongs to pick up one 2in square clear ice cube from the glass ice bucket, then lower it gently into the bourbon mixture. Dropping the ice from a height will cause splashing and dilute the drink too quickly, so lower it until it touches the liquid before releasing. The ice should sit partially submerged in the bourbon.
Stir to chill and dilute
Insert the twisted stainless steel bar spoon into the glass, holding it between your thumb and forefinger so the spoon bowl rests against the inside wall of the glass. Stir slowly and smoothly in a circular motion for exactly 20 seconds, until the outside of the glass feels cold to the touch and a faint layer of condensation forms. This chills the drink and adds just the right amount of dilution from the melting ice—do not shake, as this will cloud the bourbon and create a watery texture.
Express citrus oil
Hold the 2in orange peel swath (with all white pith trimmed off to avoid bitter flavor) between your thumb and forefinger, hold it 2 inches above the surface of the drink, with the outer orange peel side facing down toward the liquid. Squeeze the peel firmly to release a fine mist of citrus oil over the entire drink surface, then rub the peel lightly along the outer rim of the glass. Do not drop the peel into the drink unless you prefer extra citrus flavor.
Garnish and serve
Skewer one plump brandied cherry on a small gold cocktail pick, rest it across the top of the ice cube so the cherry sits half-submerged in the drink. Rest the expressed orange peel on the edge of the glass, curled slightly for visual appeal. Do not add extra fruit, soda, or syrup—this is the balanced, classic preparation.
Tips
2.Use one large 2in ice cube instead of crushed or small cubed ice: Large format ice melts 3-4 times slower than standard small ice cubes, so it chills the drink to the ideal temperature without over-diluting it, letting you sip slowly for 15-20 minutes without the drink becoming watery.
3.Trim all white pith from the orange peel before use: The soft white pith under the bright orange zest is intensely bitter; if squeezed or rubbed on the glass, it will add a harsh, unpleasant aftertaste that overpowers the warm sugar and smooth bourbon flavors.

OMG this is literally the perfect Old Fashioned! I’ve been messing up ratios for years and this one is spot on—no weird fussy ingredients, just exactly the classic flavor I was chasing. Made these for my husband’s birthday poker night and all the guys were asking for the recipe. Total game changer!
SO good. I’m a total cocktail newbie and this was so easy to throw together, no fancy equipment needed? Didn’t even need a fancy muddler, used the back of a wooden spoon like the tip said. Made one for me and my date last night and she said it was better than the ones we get at our favorite downtown speakeasy.
Really solid recipe! I swapped the regular sugar cube for a demerara one because that’s what I had on hand and it added a nice little caramel depth. Will definitely be making these again for our next backyard BBQ.
I’ve been making Old Fashioneds for 20+ years and I have to say, this ratio is dead on. So many recipes these days add weird stuff like muddled fruit or flavored syrups and totally ruin it. This is the real, no-nonsense classic. Bookmarked for good.
Just made this after work for happy hour on my fire escape and WOW. I used rye instead of bourbon because that’s what I had and it was chef’s kiss. So easy, zero cook time which is perfect for a weeknight pick-me-up after a long day of meetings.
Brought the ingredients for these up to our cabin last weekend and made them for the crew after a long day of hiking. Everyone raved! Super easy to make even with limited kitchen stuff up there, no mess, no fuss. 10/10.
Made a big batch of these for my monthly book club potluck (don’t worry, we had non-alcoholic options too!) and they were gone in 20 minutes. Everyone kept asking how I got them to taste exactly like the fancy restaurant versions. I felt like a total pro mixologist!
This was good but I felt like it was a little strong for my taste? I know that’s the point of an Old Fashioned but I added a splash more water and an extra ice cube and it was perfect for me. Not a bad recipe, just needs a little tweak for lightweights like me lol.
Just whipped this up to test before my holiday dinner party next week and oh my gosh, I’m already obsessed. This is going to be the signature drink for sure, I can already tell. Worth every penny to get the good bitters for it too, makes such a difference.
Tried so many Old Fashioned recipes online and they’re all either too sweet, too watery, or have random add-ins. This is the first one that tastes exactly like the one my grandpa used to make for Sunday dinners when I got old enough to have a sip. Total nostalgia bomb, in the best way.
Great base recipe! I added a tiny twist of orange peel over the top to express the oils like I saw a bartender do once, and it added such a nice bright aroma without muddling the whole fruit in. Would 100% recommend that little extra step.
Wait this is SO easy? I always thought Old Fashioneds were super complicated to make at home so I only ordered them at bars, but I had all the ingredients in my liquor cabinet already. Just made one and it’s better than the $16 one I got at a bar last weekend. Are you kidding me? Total game changer.
Made these for our neighborhood potluck over the weekend and people were coming back for seconds (and thirds, oops). I even made a zero-proof version for the non-drinkers with non-alcoholic bourbon and it worked perfectly with the same ratios! Super versatile.
I keep a little travel bar kit in my truck for camping trips and this recipe is now permanently written on the inside of the lid. No measuring needed once you get the ratio down, it’s foolproof. Made these around the campfire last trip and everyone was blown away. Will be making these for years.