best old fashioned mix
intro
This perfectly balanced old fashioned mix makes bar-quality cocktails at home, with rich bourbon, warm bitters, bright citrus, and smooth sweet depth, no fancy bar tools required.
Ingredients
Steps
Simmer Rich Simple Syrup
Combine ½ cup demerara sugar and ½ cup filtered water in the 1-quart stainless steel saucepan. Place over medium-low heat, stirring occasionally with the bar spoon, for 3-4 minutes until sugar is fully dissolved and the liquid is clear and pale golden, with no gritty sugar granules visible on the pan bottom. Do not bring to a rolling boil to avoid over-caramelizing the sugar. Remove from heat and let cool 10 minutes at room temperature.
Prep Orange Peel Strips
Place the whole navel orange on the honey-toned acacia cutting board. Use the 3-inch paring knife to cut 6 wide (1-inch) strips of orange peel, taking care to cut only the bright colored zest and avoid the bitter white pith beneath. Gently squeeze each peel strip over the cooled simple syrup to release bright citrus oils, then drop the strips into the syrup to infuse for 5 minutes.
Strain Infused Syrup
Place the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer over the top of the 16-oz clear glass mixing glass. Pour the orange-infused simple syrup through the strainer to catch the peel strips, pressing gently on the peels with the back of the bar spoon to extract all flavorful liquid, then set the used peels on the corner of the cutting board to discard later.
Combine Bitters and Syrup
Add 2 tablespoons Angostura aromatic bitters and 1 tablespoon orange bitters to the strained infused syrup in the mixing glass. Stir slowly with the twisted bar spoon for 15 seconds to fully combine, until the mixture is a uniform deep amber color with no lighter streaks of unblended syrup.
Blend in Bourbon
Pour 2 cups (480ml) of straight Kentucky bourbon into the mixing glass with the syrup and bitters base. Stir gently with the bar spoon for 20 seconds to fully integrate the ingredients, taking care not to stir too vigorously to avoid aerating the mix unnecessarily.
Bottle Finished Mix
Hold the twisted bar spoon against the lip of the mixing glass to act as a pour guide, then carefully pour the fully combined old fashioned mix into the 16-oz amber glass storage bottle. Seal tightly with the black phenolic cap. The mix will keep refrigerated for up to 1 month; no stirring is required before use.
Prep Clear Serving Ice
When ready to serve, place one 2-inch large clear ice cube into the heavy crystal ribbed rocks glass. The large cube melts slowly to prevent over-dilution while chilling the cocktail to the ideal serving temperature (40°F/4°C).
Pour and Garnish Drink
Pour 3 ounces (90ml) of the chilled old fashioned mix over the ice cube in the rocks glass. Twist a fresh 1-inch strip of orange peel over the glass to express citrus oils over the drink surface, rub the peel along the glass rim, then rest it on the edge of the glass. Skewer one brandied cherry on the gold cocktail pick, lay it across the ice, and serve immediately.
Tips
2.Use large 2-inch clear ice cubes for serving instead of small crushed or cubed ice, as they melt roughly 50% slower, keeping your cocktail properly chilled without over-diluting the rich bourbon and bitters flavor for 20+ minutes.
3.Never bring the demerara simple syrup to a rolling boil, as high heat will over-caramelize the sugar and add a burnt, heavy toffee note that overwhelms the delicate citrus and bitters; heat only over medium-low until sugar fully dissolves, then remove from heat immediately.

OMG this old fashioned mix is a total game changer! I used to spend forever muddling sugar and bitters every time my friends came over, and this takes 5 whole minutes to whip up? I made a batch last night for our weekly trivia night and everyone was asking for the recipe. SO good, way better than the store-bought stuff that tastes like fake cherry syrup. 10/10
Tried this for my husband’s birthday dinner last weekend, served it over big ice cubes with a twist of orange and a luxardo cherry, and it was perfect. The balance is spot on— not too sweet, just enough bitters kick. I even jarred a little extra to give to my dad as a little gift, he said it’s better than the old fashioneds he gets at his favorite country club. Will absolutely be keeping a jar of this mix in my fridge at all times from now on!
Super easy to make, even for a guy who usually just cracks open a beer at cookouts. I mixed this up for our backyard Labor Day potluck, set out bottles of bourbon and rye, and let people make their own drinks. Zero leftovers, people went crazy for it. My only tip? Don’t skip the little splash of orange zest oil like I almost did— it makes all the difference. Will be making this for every tailgate from now on!
Wait, quick question! How long does this mix stay good for in the fridge? I want to make a big batch ahead of my holiday party next month so I don’t have to mess with it the day of, but I don’t want it to go bad before then. Fingers crossed it lasts a couple weeks!
I was honestly skeptical a homemade mix could be this good, but wow. I’ve been paying $15 for a bottle of premium pre-made old fashioned mix from the liquor store for years, and this is cheaper, tastes better, and takes zero effort. My roommate and I went through half the batch in one night while we were watching football. No notes, perfect recipe.
Tried this for my first ever attempt at making old fashioneds last night, and I didn’t mess it up! That’s a win in my book. I did add a tiny extra splash of cherry syrup because I like my drinks a little sweeter, and it worked perfectly. My roommate said it was the best cocktail he’s ever had at home. Super easy for total beginners like me!
I’ve been making old fashioneds behind the bar for 42 years, and let me tell you, this mix is dead on. A lot of homemade mixes overcomplicate things with weird add-ins, but this sticks to the classic flavor profile, and the ratio is perfect. I taught my grandson to make this last weekend, and he’s already making them for his college friends. Great, no-fuss recipe.
Y’all, I brought this mix to our neighborhood block party last weekend, mixed up with a good bourbon, and I swear every single neighbor was stopping by my cooler asking where I got the mix. I even had one lady offer to pay me to make her a jar! It’s so simple I almost feel silly telling people how easy it is, but I’ve been sharing this recipe link with everyone. Game. Changer.
Made this for our Sunday football watch party, and it was a total hit. I will say, I messed up the first batch because I used too much bitters (oops, heavy hand), but the second batch was perfect. Tastes just like the old fashioneds I get at my favorite downtown cocktail bar, for a fraction of the price. Already got the ingredients to make another batch this weekend.