1.What makes classic Upper Midwest booyah different from regular beef or chicken stew?
▾
Great question! Unlike standard single-meat stews, booyah uses a slow-simmered mix of beef chuck and bone-in, skin-on chicken to build its signature layered, rich broth. It’s traditionally made in giant batches for community events, has a light, unthickened savory base, and leans into simple, seasonal local veggies instead of heavy, bold seasonings.
2.Do I really need both beef chuck and chicken thighs, or can I use just one type of meat?
▾
You can technically use just one, but you’ll miss the iconic cross-meat depth that defines booyah. If you have to pick one, go for bone-in chicken thighs for the richest broth, but I strongly recommend keeping both: they cook at complementary rates, with beef adding hearty savoriness and chicken bringing bright, juicy umami. Skip extra-lean cuts, they’ll dry out during the long simmer.
3.What size should I cut the beef chuck cubes for even, consistent cooking?
▾
Aim for uniform 1-inch (the 2.5cm noted in the recipe) cubes, trimmed of any extra-thick, hard fat chunks first. This size ensures the beef gets fall-apart tender in the same simmer time it takes chicken thighs to cook through and release their bone and skin flavor, without turning to mushy shreds before veggies are done. Pat cubes totally dry before searing for best browning.
4.Why does the recipe call for bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs instead of boneless, skinless?
▾
Bone-in, skin-on thighs are key for authentic booyah depth, honestly. The bones release gelatin that gives the broth that rich, silky mouthfeel without added thickeners, and the skin renders gentle, savory fat that boosts flavor way more than boneless, skinless cuts can. You can fish out skin and bones after cooking if you don’t want them in the finished stew, no problem.
5.Can I make booyah in a slow cooker instead of simmering it on the stovetop?
▾
Absolutely, that’s a super approachable home cook hack! Sear your beef and sauté onions and garlic first as directed, then add meat and hardy veggies to the slow cooker, cover with broth, and cook on LOW for 6 to 7 hours. Toss in softer, quick-cooking veggies the last 45 minutes so they don’t turn mushy, and pull chicken out to shred before serving.
6.What vegetables are traditional to add to Upper Midwest booyah?
▾
Classic booyah leans into hardy, cold-climate Upper Midwest produce, so you’ll commonly see diced carrots, celery, cubed russet potatoes, sweet corn, green beans, and sometimes cabbage or rutabaga. Stick to what’s in season locally if you can—early fall batches with fresh sweet corn and just-harvested potatoes taste exactly like the small-town firehouse booyah I grew up eating.
7.Why is booyah so often made in such giant, crowd-sized batches?
▾
Booyah is rooted in Upper Midwest communal gathering culture—think church potlucks, fire department fundraisers, harvest festivals, and post-high-school-game feeds. It’s designed to feed a crowd affordably, since cheaper, tough cuts of meat transform into something incredible with long, slow simmering, and it stretches easily with extra veggies and broth for last-minute drop-in guests.
8.Do I really need to sear the beef before adding it to the stew pot?
▾
I highly recommend it, even though it adds 10 minutes of prep time. Searing dry beef cubes in hot olive oil builds deep, toasty Maillard reaction flavor you can never get from boiling raw meat in broth. You don’t need a dark, hard crust—just a light golden brown on a couple sides per cube to add that rich, savory base that keeps broth from tasting flat.
9.How long does booyah need to simmer to get that perfect tender texture?
▾
Plan for a total stovetop simmer time of 2.5 to 3 hours over low heat, once you bring the pot to a gentle bubble. That’s enough time for beef to get pull-apart tender, chicken bones to release all their silky gelatin, and flavors to meld without meat turning stringy. Keep the lid slightly ajar to prevent a hard boil, which makes broth cloudy and meat tough.
10.Can I freeze leftover booyah, and how long will it stay good?
▾
Booyah freezes beautifully, which is another reason it’s such a beloved make-ahead meal. Let it cool completely first, then portion into airtight, freezer-safe containers with a half-inch of headspace for expansion, and it will keep for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight, then reheat gently on the stovetop—add a splash of extra broth if it thickens up as it chills.
11.What seasonings are traditional for booyah, so I don’t accidentally overspice it?
▾
Traditional booyah keeps seasonings really simple to let the meat and veggie flavors take center stage. Stick to kosher salt, fresh black pepper, a couple of bay leaves, and a pinch of dried thyme—skip heavy spice blends, fiery hot sauce, or bold herbs like rosemary that will overpower the delicate, savory broth. You can always add a dash of hot sauce at the table if you want a little kick.
12.Should I remove the chicken from the bone while it simmers, or wait until it’s fully cooked?
▾
Always let chicken thighs simmer fully with bones and skin in the broth first—that’s how you get that rich, silky broth texture. After about 2 hours of simmering, use tongs to pull thighs out, let them cool just enough to handle, strip meat off the bones, discard skin and bones, then shred the chicken and stir it back in for the last 30 minutes of cook time.
13.My finished stew has a greasy layer on top—how do I fix that easily?
▾
That’s totally normal from rendered chicken skin and beef fat, and super easy to fix, no fancy tools needed. If you’re making it ahead, chill the whole pot in the fridge overnight; the fat will solidify into a hard, opaque layer on top you can lift right off with a spoon before reheating. If serving right away, use a ladle to gently skim excess floating fat off the top for a cleaner, less heavy broth.
14.Is booyah supposed to be thick like chili, or more of a brothy stew?
▾
Authentic Upper Midwest booyah falls firmly on the brothy side, not thickened with flour or cornstarch like traditional beef stew or chili. The broth will have a light, silky body from chicken bone gelatin, but it shouldn’t coat your spoon like gravy. If yours feels too thin, let it simmer uncovered for 15 to 20 minutes to reduce slightly—no thickener needed to stay classic.
15.What are the best traditional sides to serve with booyah?
▾
Keep sides simple, just like the stew itself! The classic pairing is crusty buttered rye bread or saltine crackers to crumble on top, plus a side of tangy dill pickles or creamy coleslaw to cut through the rich, savory broth. You don’t need fancy sides—this is stick-to-your-ribs comfort food, so no-fuss, familiar pairings match that cozy, communal vibe perfectly.
16.Can I cook booyah over a campfire instead of on my kitchen stove?
▾
That’s actually how the earliest community booyahs were made, in giant cast-iron kettles over open fire! Just set your pot on a grill grate over low, steady campfire coals (not roaring flames) and adjust the pot height as needed to hold a gentle bubble. It will taste even better with that subtle smoky note from the fire, just like the old-fashioned fundraiser batches I remember as a kid.
OMG this tastes exactly like the booyah my grandma used to make for church potlucks back in Wisconsin! I made this for our family Sunday dinner and my kids went back for thirds—even my picky 7 year old who turns his nose up at any vegetable. The 3 hour cook time is totally worth it, the broth gets so deep and rich.
Game changer. I’ve tried 3 different booyah recipes online before this and they all tasted like basic vegetable stew with extra steps. This one nails the slow simmered meat and veggie balance, I brought it to my deer camp weekend and the guys ate the whole 12 quart pot in 20 minutes. Only tweak I made was adding a little extra cabbage because I love the texture.
Wait 3 hours cook time? I tried making this on a weeknight after work and it was way too time consuming for a Tuesday. Tasted great once it was finally done, but I’ll save this for weekends only from now on.
SO good! I made a big batch on Sunday for meal prep and it held up perfectly all week in the fridge, the flavors even got better after a day or two. I portioned it out with a side of crusty bread and it was the coziest work lunch all week. 10/10 will be making this all fall and winter.
I grew up eating booyah at the county fair every summer up in the UP, so I was skeptical a recipe online could get it right. Color me impressed! The mix of chicken, beef, and pork is exactly what I remember, none of that weird all-chicken shortcut stuff other recipes use. My grandkids asked when we’re making it again before they even finished their first bowl.
Brought this to our neighborhood block party last weekend and I cannot tell you how many people asked me for the recipe. I lost count! I set the big slow cooker out on the table and it was gone before the burgers even finished grilling. 100% my new go-to potluck dish from now on.
Full transparency, I had never even heard of booyah before I saw this recipe pop up, but I’m always down for a hearty stew so I gave it a shot. Y’all. Why did no one tell me about this sooner? It’s like the coziest, most flavorful hug in a bowl. I don’t have a giant stock pot so I halved the recipe and it still worked perfectly.
Made this for our post-soccer game team dinner last weekend and it was perfect for a bunch of hungry 12 year olds after playing in 40 degree drizzle. I set out a little bowl of hot sauce and shredded parm for people to top their bowls with, and even the kids who say they “hate soup” had two helpings. Total home run.
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I was worried I’d have to swap out a bunch of ingredients to make it work for my celiac daughter, but as long as you use gluten free beef broth it’s totally safe. Tasted incredible, no weird GF aftertaste or texture issues at all.
Made this over the campfire in my cast iron Dutch oven on my last camping trip like Chef Admin suggested in another comment, and it was unreal. Let it simmer for 3 hours while we hiked, and we came back to the best camp meal I’ve ever had. Even the local squirrels looked jealous.
I’ve been making booyah for over 50 years for our family’s annual Labor Day picnic, and I have to say this recipe is almost identical to my own! The only thing I do different is add a can of diced tomatoes with green chiles for a tiny little kick, but otherwise this is perfect. Great for new cooks who want to try a real Upper Midwest classic.
Made this in my dorm slow cooker with my roommates, we split the cost of the ingredients and it came out to like $3 per person for like 6 meals each. Absolute steal, and way better than the dining hall food. We added a bunch of extra potatoes because we’re carb monsters, would recommend.
As someone who grew up outside Green Bay and now lives in Austin where no one knows what booyah is, this recipe made me feel right at home. I brought a batch to work and my Texan coworkers were blown away, they kept asking if it was some kind of fancy chili. Had to break out the whole history lesson about booyah feeds back home.
Really solid stew base, but I added a whole diced jalapeño and a tablespoon of cayenne because I like my food with a serious kick. Turned out amazing, the heat pairs so well with the rich savory broth. If you’re a spice wimp like the recipe is written for, it’s still good, but don’t sleep on adding heat.
I was intimidated by the medium difficulty rating and 3 hour cook time, but it was actually way easier than I thought! Most of the time it’s just simmering on the stove, so I was able to fold laundry and help my kids with homework while it cooked. Turned out so flavorful, my husband asked if we can have it every Sunday from now on.