brandy old fashioned sweet
intro
The iconic Wisconsin supper club staple: smooth brandy muddled with sweet cherry and orange, balanced with bitters, served frosty over crushed ice for a cozy, sippable classic.
Ingredients
Steps
Add Muddle Ingredients
Place 1 maraschino cherry, 1 thin orange wedge, 1 tsp reserved maraschino cherry syrup, 0.5 tsp simple syrup (if using for extra sweetness), and 2 dashes of Angostura bitters directly into the bottom of the 12oz crystal rocks glass. Arrange the fruit so it sits flat against the thick glass base to make muddling easier and more even.
Gently Muddle Fruit
Pick up the honey oak muddler from its cork coaster. Press down gently on the fruit and syrup mixture 4-5 times, twisting slightly with each press, to release orange peel oils and cherry juice. Take care not to crush the white orange pith, which will add unpleasant bitter, soapy flavor to the drink. Stop when the fruit breaks down into soft, fragrant pulp and the syrup turns a bright reddish-orange color, then set the muddler back on its coaster.
Measure and Add Brandy
Use the double-sided brushed stainless steel jigger to measure exactly 2oz (60ml) of brandy from the glass decanter. Pour the measured amber brandy directly into the rocks glass over the muddled fruit base. Give the mixture one slow, partial stir with the twisted steel bar spoon to lightly combine the brandy with the fruit syrup.
Fill Glass with Ice
Use the small brushed stainless steel ice scoop to add crushed ice from the steel ice bucket to the rocks glass, mounding the ice slightly 1/2 inch above the glass rim. Pack the ice gently so it is firm enough to hold garnishes in place, but loose enough that liquid can circulate freely when stirred. A few loose ice crumbs on the counter are normal and expected.
Top with Soda and Stir
Rinse and dry the jigger quickly, then measure 1oz (30ml) of chilled lemon-lime soda. Pour the soda over the crushed ice. Insert the twisted stainless steel bar spoon all the way to the bottom of the glass, then stir slowly for 10 seconds to fully chill the drink and evenly mix the brandy, fruit, and soda. Stop stirring when the outside of the glass feels frosty cold to the touch, and faint condensation begins to form on the crystal surface.
Add Finishing Garnish
Skewer the remaining 2 maraschino cherries and a thin, curled strip of orange peel (cut from the second orange wedge) on a small 4-inch wooden pick. Rest the pick across the top of the mounded ice, tucking one edge of the orange peel against the glass rim to release a hint of citrus aroma. Add a short paper straw if desired, for easy sipping without disrupting the garnish.
Tips
2.Stick to crushed ice: Crushed ice chills the drink in seconds, adds just the right amount of slow dilution to balance the strong brandy, and creates the signature frosty mounded top of a Wisconsin-style old fashioned. Large cubed ice dilutes too slowly and will leave your drink overly strong.
3.Customize sweetness to taste: The classic sweet version uses cherry syrup and lemon-lime soda, but if you prefer a less sweet profile, omit the extra simple syrup and swap half the lemon-lime soda for plain club soda to keep the bright fizz without added sugar.

OMG, I’ve been searching for a perfect brandy old fashioned sweet recipe that tastes just like the ones we get at supper clubs up north! This is SO spot on. I made a batch for my husband’s birthday cookout last weekend and every single guest asked for the recipe. Game changer for our backyard get-togethers!
Wait, I don’t have any bitters at home right now — can I skip them or will it totally ruin the drink? I’m making these for my roommate’s house party tonight and don’t have time to run to the store!
Brought these to our Packers watch party tailgate last Sunday and everyone went crazy for them. Way easier than hauling a bunch of beer, and I pre-mixed the brandy, simple syrup, and bitters in a mason jar ahead of time so all I had to do was pour over ice and add a cherry and orange slice. Will be making these all football season for sure.
Made this for mine and my partner’s at-home date night last night and we both loved it! I was worried it would be too sweet since I usually go for dry cocktails, but the balance is perfect. We paired it with cheese curds as an appetizer and it felt like a fancy night out without the bar tab.
This is exactly how my dad used to make brandy old fashioneds when I was a kid (obviously I didn’t drink them then, I just got to eat the garnish cherries!). Tasted like pure nostalgia when I mixed one up last night. I did muddle a little extra orange in mine because that’s how dad did it, and it was perfect.
I brought a pitcher of these to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and it was gone in 20 minutes flat. People were coming back for seconds before they even finished their first plate of food. 10/10, will absolutely be making this again for every block party from now on.
Tried this last night after work and wow, way simpler than the old fashioned recipes I’ve been messing with that use whiskey. The brandy makes it so much smoother. My only note is I used homemade simple syrup instead of store bought and it worked great.
Our book club rotates who brings drinks each month, and I was so nervous to make these because half the group says they hate sweet cocktails. But every single person had two! Even my friend who only drinks dry red wine said it was delicious. I will say I added a splash of soda water to a couple people’s who asked for it, and that worked great too.
My wife grew up in Wisconsin and has been begging me to learn how to make a proper brandy old fashioned sweet for months. I followed this recipe exactly for our first married Friday night in, and she said it tasted just like the ones her grandpa makes. Massive husband points unlocked, 10/10 recipe.
Testing cocktail recipes for our annual Christmas party, and this is going straight to the menu. It’s easy, it’s classic, and it doesn’t require a million fancy ingredients that I’ll never use again. I’m even thinking of setting up a little garnish station with orange slices, cherries, and cinnamon sticks for people to customize their own.
Okay, I made these for our family dinner last Sunday and even my 72 year old dad who swears no one makes an old fashioned as good as his local dive bar said this was perfect. That is the highest possible praise I could ever give a cocktail recipe. I did use a good quality brandy like the recipe suggested, don’t skimp on that folks!
I don’t make a lot of cocktails at home because most recipes feel super intimidating with fancy tools and weird ingredients, but this was so easy! I didn’t even have a muddler, I just used the back of a wooden spoon to mash the orange and cherry a little, and it turned out great. Will be making this after work on Fridays from now on.
I’ve been a whiskey old fashioned purist for years, so I was skeptical about the brandy sweet version. My friend made me try one at a cookout and I was shocked how much I loved it. Followed this recipe last night and it was even better than the one I had at the cookout. I might be converted.
I’ve been making brandy old fashioneds sweet for over 50 years, and this recipe is almost exactly the one I got from my own mother back in the 70s. The only thing I do different is add a tiny pinch of nutmeg on top for a little extra warmth. Perfect for cold winter nights by the fireplace.
Wait, can I make a big batch of this ahead of time for a game day party? I don’t want to be stuck making individual drinks the whole time when my team is playing. Would love to mix it all up the night before so it’s ready to pour over ice when people show up.
Made this for my small apartment get-together last night and it was a total hit. Even my friend who says she ‘doesn’t drink brown liquor’ had two of these. I was worried it would be too strong, but the sweet fruit and smooth brandy make it go down way too easy. 10/10, zero notes.
Took this recipe camping last weekend and it was perfect! I pre-portioned the brandy, syrup, and bitters in individual mason jars so all I had to do at the campsite was add ice, a cherry, and an orange slice. No fancy tools needed, no mess, and everyone at the campground kept stopping by to ask what we were drinking.