Brooklyn Cocktail
intro
A smooth, sophisticated rye whiskey cousin to the Manhattan, with nutty maraschino, dry vermouth, and bitter orange notes, served up with a luxe cherry garnish for elegant sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill Serving Coupe
Place the clear crystal coupe glass on the counter to the right of the oak coaster, fill it to the brim with ice water, and set aside to chill for 3 minutes while you prep the cocktail. A cold glass ensures the drink stays at optimal serving temperature (40°F/4°C) longer without over-diluting after straining.
Measure Cocktail Ingredients
Set the heavy weighted crystal mixing glass in the center of the work area. Using the double-sided stainless steel jigger, measure and pour 2oz (60ml) rye whiskey, 1oz (30ml) dry vermouth, 0.25oz (7.5ml) maraschino liqueur, and 0.25oz (7.5ml) Amer Picon into the mixing glass. Hold the jigger at eye level to ensure measurements are exact for balanced flavor, as even a small excess of maraschino can overpower the delicate rye notes.
Add Ice to Mixer
Add 4 large, solid ice cubes to the mixing glass with the measured spirits. Large ice cubes melt slower than crushed ice, giving you precise control over dilution as you stir, resulting in a crystal-clear drink instead of a cloudy, over-diluted one. Avoid dropping ice from a height to prevent splashing spirit out of the glass.
Stir to Proper Chill
Insert the long-handled twisted stainless steel bar spoon into the mixing glass, holding the spoon between your thumb and forefinger. Stir slowly and steadily for 20-25 seconds, gliding the spoon along the inside edge of the glass rather than agitating the ice aggressively. The drink is ready when the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty to the touch, and the liquid has dropped to 40°F/4°C, with roughly 20% dilution from the melting ice.
Strain Into Chilled Coupe
Discard the ice water from the chilled coupe glass, giving it a quick shake to remove any remaining pooled water, and set the empty frosty glass back on the honey-toned oak coaster center front. Place the matte black Hawthorne strainer over the top of the mixing glass, holding it firmly in place with your index finger. Slowly pour the chilled cocktail through the strainer into the coupe, leaving all ice and ice shards behind in the mixing glass. Pour steadily to avoid splashing, filling the coupe to exactly 2/3 of its capacity.
Add Cherry Garnish
Use the small polished stainless steel bar tongs to pick up one plump brandied cherry from the shallow clear glass prep dish. Thread the cherry onto the thin gold cocktail pick, and lay the pick across the rim of the coupe so the cherry rests just above the drink surface. Avoid dropping the cherry directly into the drink for a cleaner, more elegant presentation. Serve immediately.
Tips
2.If you can’t find Amer Picon (the bitter French orange liqueur traditional to this recipe), substitute 1/8oz (3.75ml) dry orange curacao mixed with 1/8oz (3.75ml) Angostura bitters to replicate its signature bitter-citrus depth without throwing off the drink’s delicate balance.
3.Skip bright neon-red sundae maraschino cherries for garnish: Use high-quality brandied or Luxardo cherries, as their deep, tart-sweet, nutty fruit flavor complements the rye and maraschino liqueur far better than artificially colored, overly sweet grocery store cherries.

OMG I made this for my girls' night last night and everyone was begging for the recipe! It’s so smooth, not too sweet, perfect sipping cocktail. I didn’t even have to run to the liquor store for weird fancy ingredients, which is a total win. SO good, will be on my regular rotation for sure.
Game changer for my weekly poker night with the guys. We usually just crack beers, but I whipped these up before everyone showed up and half the group asked for seconds before we even dealt the first hand. Super easy to mix in a big batch too, no fussy steps. 10/10.
I made these for my husband’s birthday dinner party over the weekend and they were such a hit! Even my sister who only drinks sweet wine loved it. I garnished with a maraschino cherry and a little orange twist, looked so fancy for zero effort. Will absolutely make again.
As a born and raised Brooklyn guy, I’m pretty picky about my Brooklyn cocktails, and this recipe nails it. Perfect balance of rye, vermouth, maraschino, that little hint of Amer Picon? *Chef’s kiss.* Way better than the watered down version they serve at half the bars in my neighborhood, tbh.
Made these for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and they went faster than the queso! I set up a little self-serve station with all the garnishes and people were customizing their own all night. Super easy recipe, no fancy tools needed, even if you don’t have a cocktail shaker you can stir it in a mason jar. 10/10. Only knocked a star off because I wish the recipe noted how much ice to use per serving, I overdid it the first couple glasses.
Made this for my at-home date night with my partner last night and it felt like we were at a fancy speakeasy without paying $18 a drink! We paired it with charcuterie and it was the perfect pre-dinner sipper. So easy to throw together after work, no prep time at all.
I’ve been making Brooklyn cocktails for 40 years and this is hands down the best ratio I’ve ever tried. Not too boozy, not too sweet, perfectly balanced. I’ll be passing this recipe along to all my kids for sure.
Perfect for when I’m cramming for finals and need a little treat after a long study session. Takes like 2 minutes to make, uses stuff I already keep on my bar cart, tastes way fancier than the effort it takes. Will be making this all semester.
Made these for our Memorial Day BBQ and even the beer-only guys were asking for refills! I was worried it would be too fancy for a casual backyard cookout but it was totally a crowd pleaser. Next time I’ll make a double batch, we ran out way too fast.
I made a non-alcoholic version of this for my sober friend at our book club and she said it was the best mocktail she’s ever had! I swapped the rye for non-alc whiskey, used zero-proof vermouth, and added a little extra cherry syrup, it worked perfectly. Love that the recipe is easy to adapt! Only knocking a star because I wish there was a noted non-alcoholic swap in the recipe itself, but it was super easy to figure out!
I work at a small craft cocktail bar in Chicago and I tested this recipe during my shift last week to see if it was menu-worthy, and my regulars loved it! The ratio is spot on, no adjustments needed, super quick to pour during a rush. Might add it to our fall menu this year.
I pre-mixed a batch of these in a water bottle (don’t judge) for our post-hike hang last weekend and it was the perfect reward after 6 miles up a mountain. Cold, smooth, just strong enough to take the edge off sore legs. 10/10, trail-tested and approved.
Just moved into my first apartment and this was the first cocktail I made for our housewarming party! Everyone was impressed that I could make a ‘fancy’ cocktail, little do they know it took me 3 minutes total per drink. Total ego boost, thanks for the easy recipe!
This was good! I’m used to super sweet cocktails so I added an extra splash of maraschino liqueur to mine and it was perfect for my taste. If you like fruity, sweeter drinks, definitely tweak it to your preference, the base recipe is super solid.
Tried this last night after seeing it pop up on my feed and wow, instant classic. I had all the ingredients on hand already so I didn’t even have to make a liquor store run. The little bit of Amer Picon really makes it stand out from a regular Manhattan, obsessed.
It was okay? I think I messed up the ratios because mine came out way too strong for my liking, I probably added too much rye. I’ll try again next time with a jigger to measure properly, I was just free pouring so that’s on me. The flavor was good when I added a little extra vermouth to even it out.
I made these for our boozy brunch last Sunday instead of mimosas for a change and it was such a fun switch up! Paired so well with our bagel spread and eggs benedict. Everyone kept saying it felt like a fancy NYC brunch right in our dining room. Will definitely be a brunch rotation staple.
Perfect cold weather cocktail! We made these while we put up our Christmas tree last weekend (yes, I know it’s early, don’t @ me) and it was so cozy sipping one while hanging ornaments. Warm, spicy, not too heavy, just right for a chilly night in.