bulleit cocktails
intro
Smooth, perfectly balanced Bulleit bourbon Old Fashioneds with warm caramel, bright citrus, and subtle spice, easy to make at home for casual gatherings with no fancy bar gear required.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Orange Garnishes
Place the whole navel orange on the small round honey oak cutting board. Use the Y-shaped stainless steel vegetable peeler to cut 4 long, 2cm-wide strips of orange peel, taking care to avoid cutting into the bitter white pith beneath the bright orange zest. Set the finished peels aside on the matte cream prep bowl. Cut 4 thin 5mm orange wedges from the remaining fruit for optional garnish, if desired.
Measure Bulleit Bourbon
Twist open the cap on the tapered bourbon bottle. Hold the double-sided stainless steel jigger over the open Boston shaker, and pour 60ml (2 fl oz) of Bulleit bourbon at a time, for a total of 240ml (8 fl oz), into the shaker. Pause between pours to let the jigger fully drain, to ensure accurate measurement for a balanced drink.
Add Syrup and Bitters
Pour 30ml (2 tbsp) of demerara simple syrup from its pour-spout bottle into the shaker with the measured bourbon. Add 8 total dashes of aromatic bitters (2 dashes per serving) directly into the liquid mixture. Do not add ice at this stage, as early ice melt will over-dilute the bourbon before it is properly chilled.
Stir Gently With Ice
Use the stainless steel ice tongs to transfer 4 large square ice cubes from the glass ice holder into the shaker with the bourbon mixture. Grip the twisted handle of the bar spoon between your thumb and forefinger, and stir the mixture slowly and smoothly for 20 full seconds, until the outside of the shaker feels frosty and cold to the touch. Stirring (rather than shaking) produces a silky, crystal-clear drink texture without aeration or cloudiness.
Strain Into Rocks Glasses
Fit the fine-mesh stainless steel cocktail strainer snugly over the opening of the shaker. Hold one lowball rocks glass at a 45-degree angle, and pour 60ml (2 fl oz) of the chilled bourbon mixture into each glass, pouring slowly down the side of the glass to avoid splashing. Add one fresh large square ice cube to each glass immediately after pouring, to keep the drink cold without rapid over-dilution.
Express Orange Peel
Take one reserved orange peel strip from the cream prep bowl, hold it between your thumb and forefinger, bright orange skin-side facing down, about 5cm above the surface of each drink. Squeeze the peel firmly to release a fine mist of citrus oil over the drink surface, then rub the peel along the outer rim of the glass before hooking it over the glass edge as garnish. This step adds bright, aromatic citrus top notes that balance the rich, oaky bourbon.
Add Final Garnishes
Skewer one plump brandied cherry on a thin 10cm wooden cocktail pick, and rest the pick across the rim of each glass. If using rosemary, lightly clap one 5cm rosemary sprig between your palms to release its aromatic oils, then tuck it next to the ice in the glass. Serve immediately, while the drink is perfectly chilled and condensation is just starting to form on the glass exterior.
Tips
2.Avoid cutting into the white pith when prepping orange peels: The pith has a harsh, bitter flavor that will transfer to your drink if included in the peel; stop peeling as soon as you see white under the bright orange zest for bright, sweet citrus aroma without bitterness.
3.Skip small crushed ice for serving: Large, dense 5cm square craft ice cubes melt 2–3 times slower than crushed or small cubed ice, keeping your cocktail cold for 20+ minutes without watering down Bulleit’s signature notes of caramel, oak, and subtle rye spice.

OMG, this is the exact Old Fashioned recipe my dad used to make for our annual backyard BBQs! I’ve been messing up the simple syrup ratio for YEARS and this nailed it. Used Bulleit like it says, garnished with a luxardo cherry and orange twist, and my entire friend group lost their minds at game night last weekend. Total game changer.
SO good. I made these for my husband’s birthday dinner party last night and every single guest asked for the recipe. I was worried it’d be fussy since craft cocktails feel intimidating, but it was so easy – zero cook time meant I got to hang out with everyone instead of mixing drinks in the kitchen all night. 10/10, will be my go-to Old Fashioned from now on.
Solid recipe! I’m a bourbon newbie so I appreciated how straightforward the steps were. Only note is I added a tiny extra splash of bitters because I love that warm, spicy flavor, but even following the recipe exactly it’s way better than the watery Old Fashioneds I get at my local bar. Made these for my roommate’s potluck pregame and everyone was impressed.
Took these on our weekend camping trip last week (pre-mixed the bourbon, bitters, and simple syrup in a mason jar ahead of time) and they were perfect around the campfire after a long hike. Who says you can’t have fancy cocktails when you’re sleeping in a tent? Will be meal prepping a batch for every camping trip from now on!
Made this for my at-home date night with my girlfriend last night and she said it was better than the $18 Old Fashioned we got at that fancy steakhouse for our anniversary. Who knew it was this easy? Skipped the fancy cherry since I only had regular maraschino ones on hand and it still slapped. 10/10, no notes.
I hosted a little holiday happy hour for my coworkers last month and served a big batch of these, and people are still talking about it! The recipe is so easy to scale for a crowd, which is a huge win when you’re hosting – I even made a zero-proof version with non-alcoholic bourbon for my teen kids and their friends who stopped by, and they thought it was fancy too. I added a little cinnamon stick garnish for a festive vibe and it was chef’s kiss. No more overpaying for weak cocktails at restaurants for me!
Really solid recipe! I’ve been experimenting with different bourbons for Old Fashioneds for years and Bulleit is such a solid pick for this – it’s got that nice high rye content that cuts through the sugar and bitters perfectly. My only knock is I wish the recipe mentioned how to make the simple syrup from scratch? I had a bottle pre-made but I can see newbies getting confused if they don’t have any on hand.