Buttermilk Pie
intro
Tangy, creamy, perfectly sweet old-fashioned Southern buttermilk pie, with flaky all-butter crust and delicate vanilla-nutmeg custard that melts on the tongue.
Ingredients
Steps
Fit Crust to Pie Dish
Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Unroll the chilled all-butter pie crust and gently lay it into the 9-inch matte cream ceramic pie dish, pressing it firmly against the bottom and up the fluted sides. Trim any overhanging crust to 1 inch beyond the dish rim, then tuck the excess under itself and crimp the edge evenly with your fingers. Prick the bottom of the crust all over with a fork 15-20 times to prevent air bubbles from lifting the crust during baking. Do not blind bake for this recipe.
Melt and Cool Butter
Place the unsalted butter in one of the small white ceramic ramekins and melt fully in the microwave (30-45 seconds on high), then set aside to cool for 5 minutes until lukewarm (not hot, as hot butter will cook eggs during mixing). While butter cools, zest the small lemon to yield 1 tsp of thin, bright yellow zest, taking care not to grate the bitter white pith beneath the peel.
Whisk Sugar and Eggs
Add the 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar and 3 room-temperature large eggs to the large glass mixing bowl. Using the matte stainless steel whisk, beat the eggs and sugar together for 1 minute until the mixture is pale lemon yellow, smooth, and slightly frothy, with no visible streaks of separate egg white remaining.
Mix Remaining Filling
Slowly pour the cooled melted butter into the egg-sugar mixture while whisking constantly to combine evenly. Add the 2 tbsp all-purpose flour, 1/4 tsp fine sea salt, 1 tsp lemon zest, 1 tbsp pure vanilla extract, and 1 cup room-temperature full-fat buttermilk. Whisk for 30 seconds until the filling is completely smooth, with no visible lumps of flour remaining. Do not over-whisk, as trapped air bubbles will cause the pie surface to crack as it bakes.
Pour Filling into Crust
Hold the silicone spatula against the rim of the mixing bowl as you pour the entire custard filling slowly into the crust-lined pie dish, using the spatula to guide the flow and prevent splashing. The filling should come to within 1/4 inch of the crimped crust edge; do not overfill, as the custard will puff slightly during baking. Grate a light, even layer of fresh nutmeg across the entire surface of the filling.
Bake Until Just Set
Place the pie on the middle rack of the preheated 350°F (175°C) oven. Bake for 45 minutes, then carefully place the adjustable aluminum pie crust shield over the crimped edges to prevent over-browning. Bake for an additional 10-15 minutes (total bake time 55-60 minutes), until the outer edges of the custard are fully set and the very center 2 inches of the pie jiggles slightly like firm Jell-O when the dish is gently nudged. The center will set fully as the pie cools; do not overbake, as this will cause curdled, rubbery custard and deep surface cracks.
Cool Fully on Rack
Transfer the hot pie directly from the oven to the matte chrome wire cooling rack set on the right side of the counter. Let the pie cool completely at room temperature for 2 full hours, then chill for at least 1 hour before slicing (the custard needs this time to fully set; cutting warm pie will result in runny, messy slices). Do not cover the pie while it cools, as trapped condensation will make the bottom crust soggy.
Tips
2.Skip blind baking the crust for this recipe: the dense, moisture-rich custard cooks the crust evenly from the bottom up during the moderate-temperature bake, and blind baking can result in a dry, crumbly crust that separates from the filling.
3.If you don’t have full-fat buttermilk on hand, make a quick substitute by stirring 1 tablespoon of fresh lemon juice into 1 cup of whole milk, then letting it rest 5 minutes until slightly curdled. This replicates buttermilk’s tangy flavor and acidic structure for a nearly identical result.

OMG I was so nervous to make buttermilk pie for the first time for our family Thanksgiving dinner, but this recipe was so easy even a total baking newbie like me pulled it off! The tangy, creamy filling with that flaky crust? *Chef’s kiss* My picky 7 year old asked for a second slice before he even finished his first. 10/10 will make again!
Made this last night for my roommate’s birthday and he said it tasted better than the pie his grandma makes (don’t tell her I said that). Only note is I added a tiny pinch of extra nutmeg on top before baking and it added such a warm, cozy kick. SO good, will be adding this to my regular meal prep dessert rotation.
Wait, I don’t keep buttermilk on hand ever — can I use that milk + vinegar trick as a substitute here? I’ve got a whole gallon of whole milk in the fridge and don’t want to make a special trip to the grocery store just for one ingredient.
Made this for our post-hike potluck last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe! The 55 minute cook time was totally accurate too, I didn’t have to wait around forever for it to set. Pro tip: let it cool completely in the fridge for a couple hours before slicing, it makes the texture so much creamier.
As someone who grew up eating buttermilk pie every summer at my great-aunt’s house in Alabama, I’m super picky about this dessert. This recipe nails the exact balance of sweet and tangy that I remember, no weird extra add-ins or fancy frills. Tastes exactly like the old-fashioned version I loved as a kid. Perfect.
Tried this last night for our weekly family dinner and wow, my kids demolished half the pie in 10 minutes. I was worried the tangy buttermilk flavor would be too much for their little kid palates, but they kept asking for more. Super easy to make even after a long day at work, no fancy steps required.
This looks amazing! Does anyone know if this works with a gluten-free pie crust? I have celiac so I can’t do regular wheat crust, but I’ve been craving old-fashioned buttermilk pie for months now.
I love old-school dessert recipes that don’t require a million fancy ingredients! This buttermilk pie is so budget-friendly too, I calculated it cost me less than $5 to make the whole thing, which is way cheaper than buying a pie from the bakery down the street. Brought it to my office potluck and all my coworkers were raving.
Made this for my wife’s birthday dinner and she said it’s the best dessert I’ve ever made. I’m definitely not a skilled baker, so the easy difficulty rating was no lie — I just mixed all the ingredients together, poured it in the crust, and popped it in the oven. Turned out perfectly golden and creamy on the first try. 10/10.
Y’all, this is the real deal. I’ve been making my grandma’s buttermilk pie recipe for 20 years and I decided to give this one a shot when I couldn’t find her recipe card last week. It’s almost identical, just a touch less vanilla than I usually use, so I added an extra half teaspoon and it was perfect. Will be making this again when I inevitably misplace that recipe card again ?
Quick question — the edges of my crust got a little too dark halfway through baking, did I do something wrong? The filling still turned out great, but I want to make it look perfect for my friend’s housewarming party next weekend.
I’ve made this pie three times in the last two weeks, no joke. First for my kid’s soccer team snack night, then for my neighbor’s BBQ, then for our family Sunday dinner. Every single time people ask me for the recipe before they even finish their first bite. It’s foolproof, delicious, and everyone loves it. Total new staple in my house.
What do y’all serve this with? I’m making it for our Christmas dinner and I’m not sure if I should do whipped cream, vanilla ice cream, or just eat it plain. I don’t want to overpower the flavor of the pie!
I’m a broke college student with barely any baking supplies and I still managed to pull this off! I didn’t have a pie dish so I used a regular cake pan, and I used the milk + lemon juice buttermilk substitute, and it still turned out SO good. My roommates and I ate the whole thing in one sitting while we studied for finals. 10/10 easy, cheap, delicious.