cheese panini
intro
Crisp, golden pressed bread oozing with stretchy, savory melted cheese, this classic cheese panini is a fast, deeply satisfying meal for busy days.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Herbed Garlic Butter
Place the 1 tbsp softened unsalted butter in a small pile on the center of the maple cutting board. Add the 1/4 tsp garlic powder and 1 tsp picked fresh thyme leaves. Use the flat side of the chef's knife to mash and fold the ingredients together until fully combined, creating a smooth, evenly green-flecked herbed butter. The mixture should be soft enough to spread easily without tearing delicate bread crumb.
Butter Bread Exteriors
Lay all 4 slices of sourdough bread flat on the maple cutting board, pushing the mixed herbed butter to the top edge of the board to make space. Use the flat edge of the chef's knife to spread a thin, even layer of the herbed butter across one full side of every bread slice, coating all the way to the crust edges to avoid dry, unevenly toasted spots. Flip all slices buttered-side down once coated, so the unbuttered side faces up for filling.
Add Mustard and Cheese
Spread the 1 tsp of Dijon mustard evenly across the unbuttered, upward-facing side of two bread slices. Layer the thinly sliced low-moisture mozzarella and sharp white cheddar evenly over the mustard, dividing the cheese equally between the two sandwiches. Pile cheese slightly higher in the center of each slice, leaving a 5mm bare border around the edge to reduce cheese oozing during pressing. Top each cheese stack with the remaining two bread slices, buttered-side facing out, to form two complete, evenly thick sandwiches.
Preheat Panini Press
Retrieve the cast iron panini press from storage and place it in the center of the counter. Preheat over medium heat for 3 minutes, until the ribbed plates are hot enough that a drop of water sizzles and evaporates in exactly 2 seconds. Do not add extra oil or butter to the press plates, as the butter on the bread exterior will prevent sticking and create crisp grill marks. Place the metal spatula on the left side of the press, ready for use.
Press and Cook Panini
Carefully place both assembled sandwiches onto the preheated panini press bottom plate, close the top ribbed plate, and apply gentle, even pressure (do not press hard enough to squeeze filling out). Cook for 3 minutes total, flipping each sandwich with the metal spatula at the 1.5 minute mark, until both sides are deep golden brown with distinct dark grill marks, and cheese is fully melted with small bubbles oozing slightly from the sandwich edges.
Rest Cooked Panini
Use the metal spatula to transfer both fully cooked panini from the press back to the maple cutting board. Let the sandwiches rest for 1 full minute at room temperature; this allows the melted cheese to set slightly so it does not run out when sliced, and reduces the risk of burns from ultra-hot molten cheese.
Slice and Plate Panini
Use the chef's knife to cut each rested panini diagonally into two equal triangular halves. Transfer the cut pieces to the matte off-white ceramic dinner plate, arranging the halves so one cut edge faces outward to showcase the melted cheese interior. Place a single small fresh thyme sprig on the plate as a light garnish, leaving a few natural bread crumbs on the plate for an authentic, unpolished look.
Tips
2.Avoid pressing down hard on the panini lid while cooking: excessive pressure squeezes melted cheese out the sides and compresses the bread into a dense, tough texture, rather than maintaining a light, crisp crust and oozing, fully contained cheese center.
3.Don't skip the 1-minute rest after cooking: slicing panini immediately causes molten cheese to pour out onto the plate, while a short rest lets the cheese thicken slightly for that ideal stretch when you take a bite, and prevents painful mouth burns from overheated cheese.

OMG this classic cheese panini is SO good! I threw this together for a quick weeknight dinner last night when I forgot to meal prep, and my 8 year old asked for seconds before I even finished my first. Crispy outside, perfectly melty cheese inside, total game changer. Only took like 6 minutes just like the recipe says, no fancy equipment needed either!
Made these for my kid’s after-school soccer practice snack run and the whole team devoured them! I added a little slice of ham to half of them for the kids who wanted extra protein, but the plain classic cheese version was the first to disappear. So easy to make in bulk for potlucks too, 10/10.
Bro this saved my lazy Sunday. I don’t have a fancy panini press so I just used a regular skillet and pressed it down with a spatula like the tips said, turned out perfect. Way better than the sad grilled cheese I was making before. Only thing is I added a dash of garlic powder to the butter and *chef’s kiss*.
Wait, has anyone tried making these with dairy-free cheese? My daughter is lactose intolerant and I’m hunting for a quick lunch option she’ll actually eat, this looks so easy!
Added these to my weekly meal prep rotation! I make them on Sunday, wrap them individually, and they reheat so well in the toaster oven for work lunches. Way cheaper than buying paninis from the café down the street, and tastes way fresher.
Made this for my guys’ game night last weekend and everyone thought I ordered takeout from the fancy sandwich shop downtown. I used a mix of cheddar, mozzarella, and a little provolone because that’s what I had in the fridge, and the cheese pull was insane. 10/10, will be making this every game day from now on.
I’m literally just learning to cook for myself after moving out of my parents’ house, and this was the first recipe I didn’t burn! It was so easy to follow, only took 6 minutes like the recipe said, and my roommate said it was better than the paninis we get at our campus spot. So excited to make more variations now!