Pimento Cheese Sandwich
intro
A tangy, creamy Southern American staple, this no-cook cheesy sandwich is packed with sharp cheddar and sweet pimentos for a satisfying, portable bite.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep spread components
First, set the 57g cream cheese out on the counter to soften to room temperature (21°C/70°F) for 30 minutes prior to mixing to avoid lumps in the final spread. Drain the 113g jarred pimento peppers completely, patting them dry with paper towels to remove excess brine, then finely dice into 3mm pieces. Grate the 226g block of sharp cheddar using the small holes of a box grater; avoid pre-shredded cheese for the creamiest texture.
Mix creamy spread base
In a 1.5L medium mixing bowl, combine the softened cream cheese, 120ml full-fat mayonnaise, 15ml Dijon mustard, and 5ml Worcestershire sauce. Stir vigorously with a rubber spatula for 1 full minute until the mixture is completely smooth, with no visible lumps of cream cheese remaining.
Season and fold cheese
Add the 1g garlic powder, 1g onion powder, 1g smoked paprika, 3g kosher salt, and 1g freshly ground black pepper to the creamy base, stirring for 30 seconds to evenly distribute the spices. Fold in the freshly grated cheddar and diced pimentos, mixing gently for 45 seconds until all cheese is coated in the creamy base; do not overmix, as a slightly coarse, textured spread is ideal.
Chill pimento spread
Cover the mixing bowl tightly with plastic wrap, pressing the wrap directly onto the surface of the pimento cheese to prevent a dry skin from forming as it chills. Refrigerate for 1 full hour at 4°C/40°F to allow the flavors to meld and the spread to firm to a perfect spreadable consistency.
Assemble sandwich layers
After chilling, remove the spread from the fridge and lay all 8 slices of soft white sandwich bread on a clean cutting board. Scoop approximately 120g (1/2 cup) of pimento cheese onto 4 of the bread slices, spreading it evenly in a 6mm thick layer all the way to the crust edges to prevent dry, unspread bites. Top each cheese-covered slice with a second piece of bread, pressing gently to help the layers adhere.
Cut and serve sandwiches
Use a sharp serrated bread knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two neat triangular halves, wiping the knife blade with a damp paper towel between cuts to keep edges clean. Serve immediately, or wrap each sandwich tightly in parchment paper for transport. Do not leave assembled sandwiches out at room temperature for longer than 2 hours to follow food safety guidelines.
Tips
2.Pat drained pimentos fully dry with paper towels before dicing; leftover brine from the jar will make the spread watery and cause it to slide out of the sandwich while eating.
3.Customize the spread to taste: add 2 tablespoons (30 grams) of finely diced pickled jalapeños for heat, or 3 slices of crispy crumbled bacon for smoky savoriness before chilling.

Game changer! I’ve been making pimento cheese for years for our family Sunday dinners and this recipe is way better than my old go-to. The cream cheese ratio is perfect, not too runny not too thick, and that hour of chill time in the fridge makes all the difference for the flavor. My husband ate two sandwiches before I even got all the sides on the table! Only thing I did differently was use extra sharp cheddar because that’s what I had in the fridge. Absolutely delicious.
Perfect for weekly meal prep! I whipped up a big batch of the pimento cheese spread on Sunday, and we’ve been using it for sandwiches, dipping veggies, and even topping burgers all week. It holds up so well in the fridge, no weird separated texture after a few days like some other recipes I’ve tried. OMG, my kids loved it, even my super picky 7 year old asked for seconds! Total win in our house.
Made this for my work lunch this week and wow, this spread is SO good, way better than the sad deli sandwiches I usually grab. Super easy to make even for someone who burns toast half the time (guilty). I added a little hot sauce on top of my sandwich for a kick and it was chef’s kiss. Will be adding this to my regular rotation for sure.
Brought these sandwiches to our office potluck yesterday and they were gone in 10 minutes flat! Multiple coworkers came up to ask where I got the recipe, I felt like a total rockstar. I made the spread the night before so the flavors had time to meld, which I think made it even better. I did cut the crusts off the bread and cut them into little tea sandwich sizes which made them perfect finger food. Only note: make sure your cream cheese is fully softened before mixing, otherwise you get little lumps – learned that the hard way! 😂
So happy I found this recipe! I used gluten free sourdough bread and it worked perfectly, the spread is so flavorful you don’t even miss regular bread. I was worried it would be too heavy but it’s light enough for a quick summer lunch, especially with a side of pickles and potato chips. 10/10, even my non-gluten free roommate stole half my sandwich and said it was the best pimento cheese she’s ever had.