christmas mixed drinks
intro
Three cozy, spiced Christmas mixed drinks—cranberry mule, creamy eggnog old fashioned, and pomegranate fizz—perfect for sipping by the tree with holiday guests.
Ingredients
Steps
Simmer Spiced Simple Syrup
Combine ½ cup granulated sugar, ½ cup filtered water, 3 cinnamon sticks, 8 whole cloves, and 3 star anise in the 1-quart glass measuring cup. Microwave on high for 90 seconds, stirring once at the 45-second mark with the bar spoon, until sugar is fully dissolved with no gritty granules at the bottom of the cup. Let the syrup cool for 10 minutes at room temperature, then strain out the whole spices using the Hawthorne strainer into a clean ramekin, leaving a smooth, translucent amber spiced simple syrup.
Muddle Cranberry Base
Place ½ cup fresh cranberries and 2 tablespoons of the cooled spiced simple syrup into the base of the stainless steel cocktail shaker. Use the acacia wood muddler to gently press the cranberries just until they burst and release deep red juice; avoid crushing the small inner seeds, as this creates unwanted bitter flavor. The finished base will be a chunky, bright ruby red with visible pieces of cranberry skin.
Shake Cranberry Mule
Add 4oz bourbon (measured with the stainless steel jigger), 1 tsp pure vanilla extract, and 1 cup of ice cubes to the cocktail shaker with the muddled cranberry base. Seal the shaker tightly with the brushed silver lid, shake vigorously for 15 seconds until the outside of the shaker feels frosty to the touch. Pull the two copper mule mugs from the back-right stack, fill each ¾ full with crushed ice, then strain the shaken cranberry mixture evenly between the two mugs. Top each mug with 3oz spiced ginger beer, then give one gentle stir with the bar spoon to combine.
Stir Eggnog Old Fashioned
Rinse the cocktail shaker to remove leftover cranberry residue, then add 4oz bourbon (measured with the jigger), 2 tablespoons spiced simple syrup, ¼ cup heavy cream, and 1 large clear ice cube to the shaker. Stir slowly (do not shake, as this will over-dilute the cream) with the bar spoon for 20 seconds until the mixture is chilled and turns a pale creamy gold. Pull the two heavy-bottomed rocks glasses from the back-right stack, place one large clear ice cube in each, then strain the creamy bourbon mixture evenly between the two glasses. Use the microplane grater to grate fresh whole nutmeg over the top of each drink until a light, even dusting covers the surface.
Assemble Pomegranate Fizz
Pull the two champagne flutes from the back-right stack. Divide the remaining 2 tablespoons of spiced simple syrup between the flutes, then add 1 tablespoon of fresh pomegranate arils to each. Tilt each flute at a 45-degree angle and slowly pour dry prosecco down the inner side of the glass to fill each ¾ full; this slow pour preserves carbonation for bubbly, long-lasting fizz. Do not stir, as this will flatten the sparkling wine.
Garnish All Drinks
Add festive, aromatic garnishes to each drink: tuck one fresh rosemary sprig and 3 skewered fresh cranberries onto the rim of each copper mule; rest one whole cinnamon stick across the rim of each rocks glass, sitting on top of the nutmeg dusting; drop one small rosemary tip and 3 extra pomegranate arils into each champagne flute. Let the drinks rest for 1 minute to allow a light layer of condensation to form on the outside of the glass for a cozy, cold, just-poured look. A few scattered rosemary needles and loose cranberries on the counter are normal and add to the casual, welcoming feel.
Tips
2.Press cranberries gently when muddling, just enough to burst the skins. Over-muddling crushes the bitter inner cranberry seeds, which will make the spiced cranberry mule taste sharp and astringent instead of bright and tart.
3.Pour prosecco slowly down the side of a tilted champagne flute to preserve carbonation. Pouring straight into an upright glass creates fast, foamy fizz that dissipates quickly, leaving your pomegranate fizz flat before guests take their first sip.

OMG these were SUCH a hit at my neighborhood Christmas potluck last weekend! I made all three, and the cranberry spritz one was gone in 10 minutes flat. Super easy to whip up too, even with my three kids running around hanging ornaments while I prepped. Quick question—can I make a big batch of the spiced apple one a day ahead for my sister’s Christmas Eve dinner?
Game changer for my annual ugly sweater party! I was stressing about making fancy drinks that wouldn’t take all night, and these came together in literally 5 minutes like the recipe says. Only note: I added an extra shot of bourbon to the peppermint white Russian one for my friends who like stronger drinks, and it went over so well. Anyone try making a non-alcoholic version of these for the kids and sober guests?
Made these for my family’s annual cookie baking night this week, and even my teen grandson who turns his nose up at everything said the peppermint one was “actually fire”. I did skip the extra sugar rim on all three because we’re watching our sugar intake, and they still tasted perfect! Question: do you have a recommendation for a dairy-free swap for the creamy peppermint drink? My granddaughter is vegan and coming for Christmas dinner.
SO good!!! I made the cranberry orange spritz for my book club holiday meetup yesterday and everyone asked for the recipe. It was so easy I didn’t even have to write down the measurements after the first read-through. 10/10 will be making these all December long.
Tried these last night for my girlfriend’s family Christmas dinner and I didn’t mess them up, which is a miracle because I can barely make toast without burning it. The difficulty rating saying “easy” is no lie, literally took me 5 minutes to make all three. Only thing is I couldn’t find fresh cranberries at my grocery store so I used frozen, worked totally fine.
Obsessed with this trio! I hosted a girls’ night holiday movie marathon last weekend and we sipped on these while watching Elf and Home Alone. The spiced apple bourbon one is my personal favorite, it tastes like Christmas in a cup. Will definitely be adding these to my annual holiday rotation.
Brought these to my office holiday potluck today and everyone was raving! I pre-portioned the ingredients in mason jars ahead of time so I could just shake and pour when I got to work, which made meal prep for the potluck so much easier. The peppermint rim is *chef’s kiss*. Only knocking one star because I found the spiced apple one a touch too sweet for my taste, next time I’ll cut back a little on the maple syrup.
Made these for our annual tree trimming party and they were perfect! No fancy equipment needed, no weird ingredients I had to run to three stores to find, which is my biggest pet peeve with holiday cocktail recipes. 10/10, will be making these for New Years too.
Just finished making a test batch of all three for my upcoming Christmas party, and OMG they are incredible. The peppermint white Russian tastes like a grown up candy cane, I could drink that every night. No notes, perfect as written!
Made these for my dorm floor holiday party last night and they were such a hit! I was on a super tight budget and all the ingredients were affordable, no fancy expensive liquor required. My friends kept asking if I took a bartending class, lol. SO good.
These are great! I made the spiced apple one for my wife’s family Christmas gathering last weekend and everyone loved it. Super quick to throw together even when you’re running late to the party (speaking from experience). Will definitely be making these again next year.
My kids loved it when I made the non-alcoholic versions of these for our family dinner last night! They got to pick their own garnishes (extra candy canes for the peppermint one, obviously) and felt so grown up having a special drink with dinner. The alcoholic versions were a hit with the adults too, total win-win.