cinnamon crunch shot
intro
This sweet, warm cinnamon-kissed shot tastes just like crunchy cinnamon toast cereal, with a smooth creamy finish and sugary crisp rim, perfect for fun casual gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Crunch Rim Mix
Place 1/4 cup Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal on the small acacia wood cutting board. Use the flat end of the natural beech wood muddler to gently press and crush the cereal into coarse, uneven crumbs (roughly 2-3mm size, do not crush into fine powder). Transfer the crushed crumbs to the matte terracotta shallow rim dish, add 2 tablespoons granulated white sugar and 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon, stir lightly with the end of the stainless steel bar spoon until evenly mixed.
Coat Shot Glass Rims
Run the cut, juicy edge of the fresh lime wedge around the entire top outer rim of each clear 1.5oz shot glass, moistening a 5mm wide band evenly; take care not to drip lime juice inside the glasses. Hold each glass upside down and press the moistened rim gently into the cinnamon crunch mixture in the terracotta rim dish, twisting slightly to create a thick, even coating across the full rim. Set all coated glasses upright in the front-center work area once finished.
Measure Cocktail Ingredients
Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure and pour ingredients into the clear glass mixing pitcher: first 3oz cinnamon whiskey, then 1.5oz vanilla vodka, then 1.5oz creamy horchata liqueur. Hold the jigger at eye level to ensure measurements are exact for balanced flavor.
Add Ice for Chilling
Add 1 cup of large ice cubes to the mixing pitcher with the measured liqueurs, filling the pitcher about halfway. The ice will quickly chill the drink to the ideal serving temperature of 40°F (4°C) without over-diluting the mixture.
Stir Shot Mixture
Use the long twisted-handle stainless steel bar spoon to stir the ice and liqueur mixture slowly and steadily for 20 seconds, until the outside of the glass pitcher feels frosty and cold to the touch and the liquid blends into a uniform golden amber color. Stir gently rather than shaking to keep the creamy texture smooth and avoid creating air bubbles.
Strain Into Shot Glasses
Place the Hawthorne stainless steel strainer over the top of the mixing pitcher, holding it firmly in place with one finger. Tilt the pitcher slowly to pour the chilled cinnamon mixture evenly between the four rimmed shot glasses, filling each glass to 5mm below the coated rim to avoid disturbing the crunch coating.
Garnish and Serve
Place one small whole Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal piece on the coated rim of each shot glass for an extra crunch cue, and lean one small whole cinnamon stick across the rim of the front-most shot for visual appeal. Serve immediately while the glasses are frosty cold, before the rim coating softens or the drink warms to room temperature.
Tips
2.Stir the drink slowly instead of shaking it: shaking creamy horchata-style liqueurs can cause dairy proteins to curdle or create a foamy, uneven texture, while 20 seconds of gentle stirring chills the drink evenly and keeps the texture silky smooth.
3.Wait to rim the shot glasses until 5 minutes before serving at the earliest: if you coat the rims too far in advance, the sugar and cereal will absorb moisture from the air and become soggy, losing the signature crisp crunch that gives this shot its name.

OMG these Cinnamon Crunch Shots were the absolute star of my Halloween pregame last weekend! I whipped up a double batch in 10 minutes flat (hello, zero cook time? Game changer!) and all my friends were begging for the recipe before the first round was even done. Tastes exactly like the Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal milk I loved as a kid, I could not get over it! 10/10, will be making these for Friendsgiving too.
I made these for my husband’s birthday bonfire last night and even my picky college-aged kid who swears he hates sweet drinks went back for thirds! They’re SO easy to throw together last minute, I didn’t even have to run to the store for fancy ingredients. I added a tiny extra splash of vanilla syrup when I mixed them up and it was chef’s kiss. Will absolutely be adding these to our fall gathering rotation!
Tried these last night for our weekly neighborhood potluck and wow, way better than the cloyingly sweet fireball shots we usually serve. Super smooth, no weird artificial cinnamon aftertaste, and even the couple on our block who swear they ‘don’t do shots’ tried one and asked for the recipe. Only heads up: the recipe doesn’t mention chilling the mixture first, but do yourself a favor and pop it in the fridge for 30 minutes before serving — it’s way better ice cold than room temp!