Classic Cocktails
intro
Master three iconic, perfectly balanced classic cocktails: rich bourbon Old Fashioned, bittersweet Negroni, and crisp Gin Martini, ideal for elegant, cozy at-home sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep All Garnishes
First, prep all garnishes to avoid last-minute rushing: Use the beech wood channel knife to cut two 5cm long orange peel twists from the whole navel orange, taking care to cut only the bright orange zest and avoid the bitter white pith underneath. Cut one 5mm thick round orange wheel for the Negroni. Thread 3 pimento-stuffed green olives onto the thin stainless steel cocktail pick. Place each prepped garnish into a separate small clear glass pinch bowl and set aside. Place one large ice cube into each of the three serving glasses and set them aside to chill for 5 minutes while you mix the drinks.
Muddle Old Fashioned Base
Dump the ice from the chilled Old Fashioned tumbler and set the glass on a coaster to wait. Place 1 tsp granulated sugar and 3 dashes of aromatic bitters into the bottom of the stainless steel mixing glass. Add 1 tsp of cool filtered water to help dissolve the sugar. Use the small maple muddler to gently press the sugar and bitters together 4-5 times, until the sugar is nearly fully dissolved and the mixture releases a warm, spicy aromatic scent. Do not over-muddle, as this will grind undissolved sugar into a gritty texture and make the drink overly bitter.
Stir Old Fashioned Over Ice
Use the jigger to measure and add 60ml (2oz) of bourbon to the mixing glass with the muddled sugar and bitters. Fill the mixing glass 3/4 full with large ice cubes from the stainless steel ice bucket. Hold the twisted bar spoon between your thumb and forefinger, keeping the back of the spoon pressed against the inside of the mixing glass, and stir the mixture smoothly for 20 full seconds, until the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty to the touch (reaching approximately 45°F / 7°C). Place the Hawthorne strainer over the top of the mixing glass, and pour the strained liquid into the chilled Old Fashioned tumbler containing one fresh large ice cube. Hold one orange twist 2 inches above the drink, skin side down, and squeeze firmly to express citrus oils across the drink surface, then drape the twist over the glass rim as garnish.
Combine Negroni Ingredients
Rinse the mixing glass quickly with cool water and wipe it dry with the edge of the burnt orange linen towel. Dump the ice from the chilled Negroni rocks glass and set it on a coaster to wait. Use the double-sided jigger to measure and add 45ml (1.5oz) London Dry Gin, 45ml (1.5oz) Campari, and 45ml (1.5oz) sweet red vermouth to the clean mixing glass. Fill the mixing glass 3/4 full with fresh ice cubes from the ice bucket.
Strain and Garnish Negroni
Use the twisted bar spoon to stir the Negroni mixture smoothly for 15 seconds, keeping the spoon against the glass wall to avoid chipping ice, until the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty. Strain through the Hawthorne strainer into the prepared Negroni rocks glass over one fresh large ice cube. Lay the pre-cut thin orange wheel flat on top of the ice as a garnish, giving it a gentle press to release a small amount of bright citrus juice into the drink.
Stir Classic Gin Martini
Rinse the mixing glass again with cool water and wipe dry. Dump the ice from the chilled coupe martini glass, polish the rim with a clean corner of the linen towel to remove water spots, and set the glass on a coaster to wait. Use the jigger to measure and add 75ml (2.5oz) London Dry Gin and 15ml (0.5oz) dry white vermouth to the clean mixing glass. Fill the mixing glass 3/4 full with fresh ice, then stir extremely slowly and smoothly for 30 full seconds—this longer stir time creates the silky, crisp texture a classic martini is known for, and dilutes the drink to the perfect, non-harsh strength. The outside of the mixing glass will feel heavily frosted when the drink reaches the correct temperature.
Strain and Garnish Martini
Place the Hawthorne strainer over the mixing glass, and pour the perfectly clear, cold martini into the chilled coupe glass—pour slowly to ensure no tiny ice shards make it into the finished drink, which should be completely transparent. Lay the pre-skewered green olives across the rim of the coupe as garnish. Do not add ice to the martini glass, as this will over-dilute the drink as it sits and ruin its crisp texture.
Tips
2.Chill all serving glasses with ice for a full 5 minutes before pouring: warm glasses will melt serving ice too quickly, diluting your cocktail before you even take the first sip, and will prevent the drink from staying at the ideal cold temperature for sipping.
3.When prepping citrus garnishes, avoid cutting into the white pith under the orange zest: pith has a harsh, bitter flavor that will overpower the bright, aromatic citrus oils you want to add to the drink, and will leave an unpleasant aftertaste.

OMG these are so perfect for my upcoming housewarming party! I’ve been stressing about what easy, crowd-pleasing drinks to serve and this guide is a total game changer. I tested the Old Fashioned last night for my partner and he said it’s better than the one we get at our favorite downtown speakeasy. Quick question—can I pre-batch the Negronis a day ahead so I’m not stuck mixing drinks the whole party?
Tried the gin martini last night for date night with my wife—went with the extra dry version with a lemon twist like the recipe suggested, and she said it felt like we were at a fancy steakhouse without the $20 price tag per drink. Will absolutely be making all three for our Labor Day backyard BBQ next weekend.
As someone who’s totally new to making cocktails at home, these recipes are so straightforward! I was intimidated at first because I thought classic cocktails required all kinds of fancy equipment, but I already had everything I needed in my kitchen cabinet. The Old Fashioned is my new go-to weeknight sipper.
Wait, hold up—this Negroni recipe uses equal parts? I’ve been making mine with way too much Campari for years and my friends always make fun of how bitter it is. Can’t wait to try the correct ratio this weekend for our fantasy football draft watch party.
Made these for my weekly bridge club meetup and the ladies went crazy for them! I was worried the martinis would be too strong for the group, but I served them up with little blue cheese stuffed olives and everyone asked for the recipe. Even my granddaughter who only drinks seltzers tried a Negroni and liked it!
Solid recipes, no weird frills, just exactly what a classic cocktail should be. I’m a bartender on the side and I send new home bartenders to guides like this all the time when they ask how to make drinks that don’t taste like a sugar bomb. Only note is I wish there was a note about what bourbon works best for Old Fashioneds for total newbies.
Game. Changer. I hosted a girls’ night potluck last Saturday and set up a little cocktail station with all three of these recipes printed out for people to mix their own. It was such a hit! No one had to wait for me to make drinks, everyone got to customize their garnish, and we had zero leftover booze by the end of the night.
Tried the Old Fashioned last night but used rye instead of bourbon because that’s all I had on hand—turned out amazing! Also muddled a tiny maraschino cherry and an orange slice with the bitters like my dad taught me, and it hit just right. Is that sacrilege to the classic recipe?
SO good! I’ve been wasting so much money going out for cocktails when these are literally just as easy to make at home for a fraction of the cost. The Negroni is my new favorite, I never would have tried it if I hadn’t seen this recipe—always thought it was too “fancy” for me to make.
Decent recipes, but I feel like the gin martini section should mention that you can make it with vodka too for people who don’t love the strong juniper taste of gin. I made it for my partner with vodka and it turned out great, even if purists will yell at me for it.
My partner and I did a little at-home date night where we made all three to taste test, and we both agreed the Old Fashioned was the clear winner! We even made a little scorecard and everything, super fun for a low-key Friday night when we didn’t feel like going out to bars.
Made the Negronis for my book club meeting last night and everyone was raving! We paired them with charcuterie and chocolate covered almonds and it was the perfect combo. One person said it tasted just like the Negronis they had on their trip to Italy last summer, which is the highest praise possible.
Perfect recipes for someone like me who’s tired of the sickly sweet frozen cocktails everyone serves at summer parties. These are strong, balanced, and feel adult without being pretentious. Already shared the link to our group chat for our annual camping trip next month.
Quick question for anyone who’s made the martini recipe—how much dilution do you get from stirring for 30 seconds like the recipe says? I like my martinis ice cold but I hate when they get watery before I can finish them.
OMG I can’t believe how easy the Old Fashioned is! I always thought it was this super complicated drink only old guys at dive bars knew how to make, but I whipped one up after work tonight in like 2 minutes flat. Put a little extra orange bitters in because I love that citrusy kick, chef’s kiss.
Tried all three over the long weekend when my cousins were in town visiting, and they were all a hit! Even my cousin who swears he only drinks beer tried a martini and admitted it was pretty good. Will be pulling these recipes out for every holiday gathering from now on.