Classic Eggnog with Rum
intro
Creamy, rich, warmly spiced classic eggnog spiked with aged dark rum, a cozy nostalgic winter holiday staple perfect for sipping by the fire.
Ingredients
Steps
Separate and whisk yolks
Carefully separate 6 cold pasteurized eggs, placing yolks in a large heatproof mixing bowl and whites in a completely clean, dry separate bowl. Add 75g (⅜ cup) of the granulated sugar to the egg yolks, then whisk continuously for 2–3 minutes until the mixture turns pale yellow, thickens, and leaves a slow, thick ribbon when the whisk is lifted above the bowl.
Warm spiced dairy base
In a medium heavy-bottomed saucepan set over medium-low heat, combine 480ml whole milk, 180ml (¾ cup) of the heavy cream, 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg, ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon, and ¼ teaspoon kosher salt. Stir slowly and heat for 4–5 minutes until the mixture reaches 70°C (160°F), just before a simmer forms; do not bring to a boil, as boiling will cause egg curdling in later steps.
Temper egg yolk mixture
Slowly pour 120ml (½ cup) of the warm spiced dairy mixture in a thin stream into the whisked egg yolks, whisking constantly at a fast pace to prevent the eggs from curdling from sudden heat. Once fully combined, pour the warmed yolk mixture back into the saucepan with the remaining dairy, stirring steadily with a wooden spoon.
Cook custard base
Keep the saucepan over medium-low heat, stirring constantly for 3–4 minutes, until the custard thickens enough to coat the back of the wooden spoon and reaches 75°C (165°F) on a food thermometer. Immediately remove the pan from heat to stop the cooking process and prevent curdling.
Add rum and chill
Stir 180ml aged dark rum and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract into the warm custard until fully combined. Pour the base through a fine-mesh sieve into a clean airtight container to remove any small lumps, then seal and refrigerate for a minimum of 4 hours (up to 3 days) until completely chilled to 4°C (40°F).
Whip cream and whites
When ready to serve, take the remaining 180ml (¾ cup) cold heavy cream and remaining 25g (2 tablespoons) granulated sugar, and whip in a chilled bowl until soft, billowy peaks form. In a separate completely clean, dry bowl, whip the reserved egg whites until soft, glossy peaks form.
Fold and serve eggnog
Gently fold first the whipped cream, then the whipped egg whites into the chilled rum custard base until just combined; do not overmix, as this will deflate the light, airy texture. Ladle 250ml (8oz) portions into glass mugs, garnish each with a light dusting of freshly grated nutmeg, and serve immediately.
Tips
2.Never rush the tempering step: pouring hot milk too quickly into egg yolks will cook the eggs into grainy curds, ruining the smooth, silky texture of the finished eggnog.
3.For a non-alcoholic version, swap the dark rum for an equal amount of extra whole milk mixed with 1 teaspoon rum extract to replicate the signature warm, spiced flavor without alcohol.

OMG this eggnog is a total game changer! I made it for our annual family Christmas dinner last weekend and everyone was asking for the recipe. I was worried the raw eggs would weird people out but the slow tempering made it so silky and rich, way better than the grocery store carton stuff. I used dark rum like the recipe said and it was perfectly balanced, not too boozy where my cousin who’s a lightweight couldn’t enjoy it. Don’t skip the freshly grated nutmeg on top, that’s chef’s kiss!
Solid eggnog recipe, turned out great for my neighborhood holiday potluck. I knocked a star off only because I wish it noted how important it is to not rush the chilling step! I only chilled mine for 2 hours because I was running late and it was a little thinner than I wanted, but the flavor was still spot on. My neighbors kept going back for refills, even the guys who usually say eggnog is ‘too sweet’ loved the rum addition. Next time I’ll make it the night before so it’s nice and thick.
My kids went crazy for this! I made a non-alcoholic batch for them by leaving out the rum and adding a little extra vanilla, and they were begging for second mugs before we even finished dinner. The adult batch with spiced rum instead of light? *Chef’s kiss* SO good, I’ll be making this every Christmas from now on. I was intimidated at first because I thought making eggnog from scratch would be super hard, but the steps were really straightforward even for a medium difficulty recipe.
I’ve tried so many homemade eggnog recipes over the years and this is hands down the best one. The ratio of cream to milk to eggs is perfect, not so heavy that you feel sick after one mug, and the rum doesn’t overpower the warm spice notes. I brought a batch to my office holiday happy hour and it was gone in 20 minutes, people were scraping the bottom of the punch bowl. 10/10, no notes.
Taste was great but man, I messed up the tempering step so bad the first time! I poured the hot milk too fast into the eggs and ended up with sweet scrambled egg bits, had to strain it twice to save the batch. Ended up tasting fine but it was stressful. Maybe I’m just bad at medium difficulty recipes lmao. Still better than the cheap stuff our campus dining hall serves this time of year, though.
I’ve been making eggnog for my grandkids for 50 years, and I have to say this recipe is right up there with my mama’s! I used a blend of dark rum and a little bourbon like I always do, and it came out so smooth. I will say I let mine chill overnight instead of 4 hours because that’s how I’ve always done it, and it was thick and perfectly spiced. My oldest grandson brought his new girlfriend over and she had three mugs, said it was better than any eggnog she’d ever had.
Made this tonight after a cold snowy hike with friends, and it was the perfect warm-up (well, chilled, but you know what I mean – warm and cozy vibe!). I used a local dark rum from a distillery near my house and it added such a nice depth. Only thing is I wish it had a little less sugar, next time I’ll cut the granulated sugar by a tablespoon since my rum was a little on the sweeter side. Otherwise, super tasty, we all sat around the fire sipping it for an hour.
As someone who usually turns his nose up at sweet holiday drinks, I was shocked how much I loved this. I used an aged dark rum that I had leftover from a cocktail party last month, and it added this nice oaky, almost vanilla note that cut through the sweetness perfectly. My roommate made fun of me for spending 25 minutes stirring and tempering eggs instead of just buying a carton, but he had two mugs and admitted it was way better than store bought. Win.
Brought this to my friend’s ugly sweater party last weekend and it was the star of the show! I served it in a big punch bowl with a cinnamon stick stirrer and a little bowl of extra nutmeg for people to top their own mugs, and everyone was raving. I even had a few people ask if I spiked it extra, but I followed the recipe exactly for the rum amount – I guess the 4 hour chill time really lets the flavors meld so it tastes extra boozy in the best way.
I wanted to love this, but I think I messed up the ratio? I ended up with something that tasted really strongly of egg and not enough spice or rum. I followed the measurements exactly, but maybe my eggs were extra large? I even chilled it for the full 4 hours, but the texture was a little watery too. Bummed because I was so excited to make homemade eggnog for the first time.
I keep accidentally making vegan stuff for my partner and then remembering he hates plant based alternatives, so I went full classic dairy and eggs for this and he was OBSESSED. Said it’s the first holiday drink I’ve made all month that he didn’t have to force a smile through. The rum amount is perfect, not so strong that you feel like you’re drinking straight liquor, but enough that you know it’s spiked. 10/10, will be making again before New Years.
Made this for mine and my husband’s first Christmas as a married couple, and it felt so special to have a homemade treat to enjoy while we decorated our tree. We don’t have kids yet so we added a little extra rum (don’t judge!) and sipped it while we watched old Christmas movies. It was so creamy and flavorful, way better than the eggnog lattes we get at our local coffee shop. We’re already planning to make a double batch for when my parents come to visit next week.
We did a build-your-own eggnog bar at our company holiday party this year, and this recipe was the base! We set out different rums, bourbon, whiskey, non-alcoholic rum extract for people who don’t drink, plus toppings like whipped cream, cinnamon sticks, nutmeg, caramel drizzle, and even crushed candy canes. People went absolutely wild for it, our CEO came up to me to ask for the recipe because he wanted to make it for his family at home.
I was worried this wouldn’t hold up for meal prep since it has dairy and eggs, but I stored it in a sealed mason jar in the fridge and it stayed perfect for 3 days! I had a little mug every night after work as a little holiday treat. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is that it separated a little on day 3, but a quick shake fixed it right up. Super convenient, way better than buying individual servings from the grocery store.