Cookie Dough Stout
intro
Velvety, indulgent stout infused with brown butter, vanilla, and edible cookie dough notes, balanced with roasty malt depth for smooth, cozy autumn sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Sanitize Brewing Equipment
Wash all brewing tools (8-gallon brew pot, stirring spoon, fermentation bucket, strainer, thermometer, silicone spatula, mixing bowl, glass measuring cup) with warm soapy water, then rinse thoroughly. Spray all food-contact surfaces with no-rinse food-grade brewing sanitizer, and allow to air dry for 5 minutes. This step prevents bacterial contamination that causes off-flavors in the finished stout.
Brown the Unsalted Butter
Place 2 tablespoons of unsalted butter in the 1-quart stainless steel saucepan over medium-low heat. Melt the butter, swirling the pan occasionally, for 3-4 minutes until it foams, turns deep golden amber, and releases a rich nutty aroma, with tiny brown milk solids settled at the pan bottom. Remove from heat immediately to avoid burning, and set aside to cool to 120°F, about 10 minutes.
Steep Roasted Barley
Fill the large 8-gallon brew pot with 1 gallon of cold filtered water, place over medium heat, and warm to exactly 155°F. Add the 1oz of roasted barley to the fine-mesh strainer, lower the strainer into the warm water, and steep for 20 minutes, holding a steady temperature between 150-155°F. Do not boil the grain, as this extracts harsh, bitter astringent flavors. Lift the strainer from the pot and discard the spent barley grains.
Mix in Malt Extract
Remove the brew pot from heat. In the medium stainless steel mixing bowl, whisk together the 1lb dark stout malt extract, 4oz lactose powder, and 2 tablespoons light brown sugar to break up any dry clumps. Slowly stir the dry mixture into the warm barley water with the long stainless steel stirring spoon, mixing continuously for 2 minutes until all powders are fully dissolved with no lumps stuck to the pot bottom. Return the pot to medium heat and bring to a gentle rolling boil for 10 minutes, watching closely to prevent sticky boil-overs.
Infuse Cookie Flavors
After the 10-minute gentle boil, turn off the heat. Use the silicone spatula to scrape all of the cooled browned butter (including the brown milk solids) into the wort, then add 1 tsp vanilla bean paste, 1 tsp butter vanilla extract, and 2 tbsp mini semi-sweet chocolate chips. Stir slowly until the chocolate is fully melted and evenly incorporated, then cover the pot and allow the wort to cool to 70°F, about 20 minutes in an ice bath.
Transfer Wort to Fermenter
Once the wort holds a steady 70°F, place the fine-mesh strainer over the mouth of the 5-gallon fermentation bucket. Pour the cooled wort through the strainer to catch any undissolved grain bits or burnt milk solids, then top off with cold filtered water to bring the total liquid volume to 1 gallon. Sprinkle the full packet of neutral ale yeast evenly over the wort surface, seal the bucket with the airtight lid, and fill the attached airlock halfway with sanitizer.
Ferment for Two Weeks
Leave the sealed fermentation bucket in its fixed counter position, in a dim spot away from direct sunlight, at a steady 65-68°F for 14 days. Bubbles will rise through the airlock consistently for the first 3-5 days as active fermentation converts sugar to alcohol; when bubbles stop appearing for 48 straight hours, primary fermentation is complete. Do not open the bucket lid during this time to avoid contamination.
Add Cookie Dough Crumbles
After 14 days of primary fermentation, carefully open the fermentation bucket lid. Gently sprinkle the ¼ cup of heat-treated, egg-free edible cookie dough crumbles over the stout surface, stirring very slowly with the sanitized long spoon to distribute the crumbles evenly. Re-seal the lid and airlock, and allow the stout to condition for 3 additional days at 65°F to absorb the cookie dough flavor, then chill the entire batch to 42°F before serving.
Tips
2.Hold fermentation to a strict 65-68°F range: temperatures above 72°F will produce harsh, solvent-like fruity off-flavors, while temperatures below 60°F will make yeast go dormant, leaving the stout overly sweet and flat.
3.Do not skip straining the wort when transferring to the fermenter: leftover roasted barley bits or burnt milk solids from the browned butter will create a cloudy, gritty mouthfeel instead of the smooth, velvety texture that defines this stout.

OMG, this cookie dough stout is such a game changer! I brought it to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and every single person asked for the recipe. The sweet cookie dough notes balance the roasty stout so perfectly, I can’t believe how easy it was to pull off even with medium difficulty. 10/10 will make again for our next game night!
Wait, quick question — do I have to use a specific brand of stout for this? I have a random grocery store stout in my fridge I’ve been meaning to use up, will that work or do I need a more specialty one?
Tried this last night for my partner’s birthday dinner and it was SO good! I did add a tiny extra splash of vanilla extract because I’m obsessed with vanilla, and it paired amazing with the chocolate chip cookies we had for dessert. My kids even asked for a tiny sip (don’t worry, I gave them non-alcoholic cookie dough milk instead lmao)
Made this for our office happy hour yesterday and everyone was raving! I was worried it would be too sweet since I don’t love super cloying drinks, but the balance is spot on. The 40 minute cook time is totally reasonable too, I was able to prep it while my lunch was in the oven. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular rotation!
Uh oh, I think I messed up the cookie dough infusion part? My batch came out a little grainy, did I overheat it maybe? Flavor is still great but the texture is off.
My husband is obsessed with stouts so I made this for our anniversary dinner and he said it’s better than the fancy craft stout we paid $18 a bottle for last month! I used edible cookie dough (no raw egg) to be safe, and it turned out incredible. Game changer for date night at home.
Tested this out ahead of our college football tailgate next weekend and it’s going to be a hit! I’m gonna batch make it the night before so I don’t have to mess with it at the parking lot. So much better than bringing the same old beer every time.
I swapped in a vegan stout and vegan edible cookie dough for this and it turned out perfect! I was nervous the substitutions would throw off the flavor but you can’t even tell the difference. My vegan roommates went crazy for it, we finished the whole batch in one night.
This is such a fun twist on a regular stout! I brew my own beer at home so I added the cookie dough notes during secondary fermentation and it came out insane. Way better than any commercial cookie dough stout I’ve tried at the liquor store.
Obsessed!!! I’m a total sucker for anything cookie dough flavored so I knew I had to try this. I topped mine with a little mini chocolate chip garnish and a tiny dollop of whipped cream and it felt like a fancy bar dessert drink. My kids loved the smell so much they begged for their own mocktail version, so I made them a root beer float with cookie dough bits on the side and they were over the moon.
Was looking for a fun make-ahead drink for our weekly family dinner and this did not disappoint. Cook time was exactly 40 minutes like the recipe said, no hidden steps or weird fancy equipment needed. Even my picky father-in-law asked for a second glass, which is basically a 5 star review on its own.
How long does this stay good in the fridge? I love prepping drinks ahead for the week so I don’t have to make stuff every night after work, and this looks perfect for that.
Wait, has anyone tried adding a little cinnamon or nutmeg to this? I feel like a warm spice kick would go so well with the cookie dough and stout flavors, but I don’t wanna mess up a good thing.
I work at a small craft cocktail bar and we tested this recipe for our fall menu last week and it flew off the taps! We served it chilled with a chocolate chip cookie rim and customers were ordering two at a time. Already added it as a permanent menu item, thanks for the killer recipe!
Quick check — can I make this gluten free? I have celiac so I need to make sure all the ingredients are safe, but this sounds way too good to pass up.
Made this for our annual fall cabin trip with friends and it was the star of the weekend! We sat around the fire pit sipping it and everyone kept saying it tasted like a cookie in a glass. 10/10, will be making this for every fall trip from now on.