Evan Williams
intro
A cozy, spiced Kentucky-style warm cocktail starring smooth Evan Williams bourbon, balanced with honey, lemon, and warm spices for cold winter sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep serving mugs
Set out 4 heatproof glass mugs; warm each by rinsing with 60 ml boiling water, let sit 30 seconds, then pour out the water to prevent thermal shock and cracking when adding hot liquid.
Measure core ingredients
Add 45 ml (3 tbsp) Evan Williams bourbon, 15 ml (1 tbsp) raw honey, and 11 ml (roughly 2 tsp) fresh lemon juice to each pre-warmed mug. Stir each briefly with a long bar spoon for 5 seconds to start dissolving the honey.
Infuse spiced water
Pour 480 ml filtered water into a small 1L saucepan, add 0.5g ground cinnamon and 4 whole cloves, set over medium-low heat. Bring to a gentle simmer (82°C / 180°F, do not bring to a rolling boil) and hold at that temperature for 2 minutes to extract spice flavors, then remove from heat.
Combine and mix
Strain the hot spiced water through a fine-mesh sieve to remove whole cloves, then pour 120 ml (1/2 cup) of the spiced water into each prepared mug. Stir each drink vigorously for 10 seconds to fully dissolve the honey and evenly blend the bourbon, lemon, and spice flavors.
Add butter topping
Place one 7g (1/2 tbsp) thin pat of cold unsalted butter on the surface of each drink; do not stir, allowing the butter to slowly melt over 30 seconds to create a silky, rich, glossy top layer.
Garnish and serve
Slit one lemon wheel per mug to rest on the glass rim, and add one cinnamon stick to each mug as a stirrer. Serve immediately while the drink reaches a sippable 70°C / 160°F for best flavor.
Tips
2.Do not substitute granulated white sugar for honey, as it will not fully dissolve at the drink's serving temperature and will leave a grainy residue at the bottom of mugs.
3.For a lighter, dairy-free version, skip the butter pat and add a 1mm thin slice of fresh ginger to the spiced water during infusion for an extra bright, zesty kick.

OMG this is exactly what I needed for this random November cold snap! Made it last night after walking the dog in 30 degree wind, and it warmed me right down to my toes. The Evan Williams spiced bourbon is perfect here, not too sweet, just the right kick. SO good, I already shared the recipe with my whole group chat.
Total game changer for my annual ski trip pre-game! I used to make hot toddies with plain bourbon and a random cinnamon stick, but the spiced Evan Williams adds so much depth I don’t even need extra nutmeg. Super easy too, took me like 8 minutes tops while everyone was getting their layers on.
Made this for our family bonfire last weekend and everyone raved! I knocked off one star only because I added a little extra honey for my mom who has a super sweet tooth, but the spiced Evan Williams base is perfect. Even my 22 year old cousin who 'hates warm drinks' went back for a second cup.
I’ve been testing hot toddy recipes all fall to find the perfect one for our Christmas party, and this is it. Not too boozy, not too watery, the spice blend from the Evan Williams pairs so well with the lemon and clove. Already bought two extra bottles of the spiced bourbon to have on hand for the party.
Brought a big batch of this Classic Evan Williams Spiced Hot Toddy to our neighborhood potluck last week and people were lined up for refills! I kept it warm in a slow cooker on the low setting so people could serve themselves, and it worked perfectly. Even the non-bourbon drinkers were asking for the recipe.
Made this with Evan Williams Spiced when I was feeling super under the weather with that flu that’s been going around campus, and I swear it made my sore throat feel 10x better. Super easy to make in my dorm microwave (don’t tell my RA I had bourbon lmao) and it knocked me right out for a solid 8 hours of sleep, which I never get during midterms.
My wife and I have been making a version of this for years, but we switched to Evan Williams Spiced after trying this recipe and we’re never going back. We have one every Sunday evening while we watch our favorite show, it’s become our new little ritual. 10/10, no notes.
Packed all the ingredients for this Evan Williams Spiced Hot Toddy on our backcountry camping trip last weekend, and it was the best reward after hiking 8 miles in the snow! We heated the water over our camp stove, and everyone in our group agreed it was the best post-hike drink we’ve ever brought. Would 100% make again for cold weather trips.
I’ve been making hot toddies for over 40 years, and I have to say this recipe is the simplest, most flavorful version I’ve come across. The key is definitely using the spiced Evan Williams instead of adding a million different spices yourself—cuts the prep time way down and tastes more balanced. Made it for my bridge club last week and all the ladies asked for the recipe.
Just made this Evan Williams Spiced Hot Toddy for my husband and I after we finished decorating our Christmas tree, and it’s so cozy! We moved to Florida from Michigan last year, so even 60 degree nights feel cold to us now, this was the perfect treat to end the night. We added a cinnamon stick garnish just for fun, it looked so fancy for 10 minutes of effort.
Made this Evan Williams Spiced Hot Toddy for my football watch party yesterday, it was a hit! Only thing is I added a splash too much lemon on my first batch and it was a little tart, but I adjusted on the second batch and it was perfect. Will definitely be making this again for our New Year’s get together.
I make this every single time I feel a cold coming on, and it never lets me down. The warm bourbon, honey, and lemon soothe my throat instantly, and the spice from the Evan Williams makes it feel way more special than just regular hot tea. It’s my go-to sick day essential, I always keep a bottle of the spiced bourbon in my liquor cabinet just for this.