good whiskey drinks
intro
Three perfectly balanced, iconic whiskey drinks — silky Old Fashioned, crisp Highball, warming Hot Toddy — easy to master at home for cozy autumn date nights.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep citrus garnishes
Place the whole orange, lemon, and ginger knob on the cherry wood cutting board. Use the paring knife to cut two 2-inch long orange peel twists (take care to cut only the outer zest, leaving the bitter white pith on the fruit), one 1/4-inch thick lemon wheel for the highball, one 1/4-inch thick lemon slice for the toddy, and one thin 1/8-inch ginger coin for the toddy. Set all cut garnishes on the edge of the cutting board within easy reach.
Muddle sugar and bitters
Add 1 tsp of granulated sugar and 4 dashes of aromatic bitters to the bottom of the matte black mixing glass. Pour in 1 tsp of cool water to help dissolve the sugar. Use the honey oak muddler to gently press and twist the sugar mixture for 30 seconds, until the sugar is almost fully dissolved into a thick, fragrant dark syrup at the bottom of the glass. Do not over-muddle or grind the sugar into a fine powder, as this will create a gritty texture.
Stir Old Fashioned base
Use the stainless steel jigger to measure 4oz of bourbon, and pour it into the mixing glass with the dissolved sugar and bitters. Add one large ice sphere to the glass. Hold the twisted stainless steel bar spoon between your thumb and forefinger, submerging the spoon head against the inside of the glass, and stir slowly and smoothly for 20 seconds, until the outside of the mixing glass feels faintly chilled to the touch. Never shake an Old Fashioned, as this aerates the spirit, clouds the liquid, and causes over-dilution.
Strain into rocks glasses
Place one large clear ice sphere into each of the two crystal rocks glasses. Fit the Hawthorne strainer snugly over the top of the mixing glass, and pour the chilled, stirred bourbon mixture evenly between the two glasses. Hold each orange peel twist 2 inches above a glass, squeeze gently to express citrus oils over the drink surface, then rub the peel along the glass rim before resting it in the drink. Skewer one maraschino cherry on a small silver pick and lay it across the rim of each glass.
Mix Whiskey Highball
Fill the tall clear highball glass completely with crushed ice, packing it down gently with the bar spoon to eliminate air gaps. Use the jigger to measure 2oz of Japanese whiskey, and pour it over the crushed ice. Top slowly with 4oz of cold club soda, pouring down the inside edge of the glass to preserve carbonation. Give the drink one slow, single stir with the bar spoon to combine — over-stirring will flatten the soda and dilute the drink too quickly. Perch the pre-cut lemon wheel on the glass rim.
Prepare Hot Toddy
Heat water in the gooseneck kettle until it reaches 170°F (do not bring to a rolling boil, as high heat will ruin the whiskey’s delicate flavor). Add 1 tsp of raw honey and the thin ginger coin to the bottom of the matte cream ceramic mug. Measure 2oz of blended Scotch with the jigger, pour it into the mug, then top with 6oz of the hot water. Stir gently with the bar spoon until the honey is fully dissolved. Float the pre-cut lemon slice on top of the drink, and rest one cinnamon stick in the mug as garnish.
Arrange to serve
Arrange the two Old Fashioneds, Highball, and Hot Toddy evenly across the front of the counter, spacing them so each drink is easily reachable. Do a quick quality check: Old Fashioneds should be crystal clear with a bright citrus aroma, the Highball should have active bubbles rising through the ice, and the Hot Toddy should smell of warm honey and spice. Serve immediately while drinks are at their ideal serving temperature.
Tips
2.For the crispiest Whiskey Highball, chill your highball glass in the freezer for 10 minutes before building the drink. A cold glass keeps club soda carbonated longer and slows ice melt, so the drink stays bright and well-balanced from the first sip to the last.
3.When making a Hot Toddy, never use boiling (212°F) water: high heat evaporates whiskey’s delicate aromatic compounds and makes the alcohol taste harsh. Heating water to 170°F melts honey and extracts ginger and cinnamon flavor without damaging the whiskey’s smooth profile.

OMG these are SO good! I made these for my friend’s housewarming last night and everyone was asking for the recipe. It literally took 2 minutes to stir together, no fancy tools needed. Total game changer for casual get-togethers, I’ll be making these all fall!
As someone who’s been drinking whiskey for 20+ years, I was skeptical a 2-minute easy recipe could hit that perfect balanced note, but man, this delivers. Not too sweet, not too boozy, lets the actual whiskey shine instead of covering it up with a ton of mixers. I’ve made this three nights in a row after work, no cap.
Hosted a small dinner party last weekend and tested this recipe out ahead of time for my whiskey-loving in-laws. They raved so much my father-in-law asked me to write the ratios down for him to take home! Way easier than fumbling with a bunch of fancy cocktail recipes when you’re also trying to get dinner on the table. 10/10.
Really solid base recipe! I added a tiny splash of orange bitters because I had it on hand, and it took it to the next level for me. Only note is that the ratio felt a little sweet for my taste, so I cut the simple syrup by a quarter ounce when I made it the second time. Otherwise super easy and quick, great weeknight treat after a long day at work.
Just whipped these up for our neighborhood tailgate pregame and OMG, everyone is already going back for seconds! I was worried whiskey drinks would be too strong for the crowd, but the balance is so perfect even people who say they don’t like whiskey are sipping these. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular potluck rotation!
Made these on our last camping trip outside Aspen and they were chef’s kiss. No fancy equipment needed, just a metal cup to stir in, and we didn’t even have to bring a bunch of random mixers along. Sat around the campfire sipping these after hiking 8 miles all day, absolute perfect vibe. 10/10, will be bringing the ingredients on every trip from now on.
Wait why did I overcomplicate whiskey cocktails for so long??? This is exactly the balanced, no-fuss drink I’ve been searching for to make at home after long work days. I don’t have a fancy bar setup, just a bottle of bourbon, some sugar, and lemons, and this turns out perfect every single time. Game. Changer.
Tried this last night for my weekly poker night with the guys, and normally we just crack open beers, so everyone was shocked how good these were. Even my buddy who only drinks light beer had two of these! Super easy to make between hands, no shaking or straining required if you don’t want to. Total win.