grilled feta
intro
Creamy, briny block feta grilled to golden, charred perfection, infused with herby olive oil and a drizzle of honey, with a crisp edge and warm, oozing center perfect for summer sharing.
Ingredients
Steps
Pat Feta Dry
Remove the feta block from its brine packaging, discard excess brine. Place the unwrapped feta on the light oak cutting board. Use a clean corner of the folded oatmeal linen napkin to gently pat all surfaces of the feta completely dry, taking care not to crumble the firm block. Drying the surface ensures the feta will char properly instead of steaming on the grill, and prevents sticking to the pan ridges. The finished feta should feel matte and dry to the touch, with no visible surface moisture.
Mix Herb Marinade
In the first matte white ceramic ramekin, combine 2 tablespoons of the extra virgin olive oil, minced garlic, picked oregano and thyme leaves, kosher salt, black pepper, and crushed red pepper flakes. Stir the mixture with the tip of the chef knife to combine fully, until herbs are evenly distributed through the golden oil. The finished marinade will smell bright, garlicky, and herbaceous.
Coat Feta in Marinade
Use the stainless steel pastry brush to brush all sides of the dry feta block generously with the herb oil marinade, using roughly two-thirds of the oil mixture. Set the remaining marinade aside for drizzling on the finished dish. Let the feta rest for 5 minutes at room temperature to absorb the oil and herb flavors while you preheat the grill. The thin oil coating creates a non-stick barrier that prevents the soft cheese from melting through the grill ridges as it cooks.
Preheat Grill Pan
Retrieve the cast iron square grill pan from its stored position on the far right stovetop, and place it on the center burner over medium-high heat. Let the pan preheat for 5 minutes, until it is very hot: you should be able to hold your hand 2cm above the pan ridges and feel intense radiant heat after 3 seconds. Do not oil the pan ridges directly, as the oil coating on the feta is sufficient to prevent sticking. A properly preheated pan creates distinct, dark char marks without the cheese sticking.
Grill Feta and Lemon
Once the pan is fully preheated, use the metal grill spatula to carefully lift the oiled feta block and place it directly on the hot grill ridges. Place the two lemon halves cut-side down on the empty corner of the grill pan. Grill the feta undisturbed for 3 minutes, until deep golden char marks form on the bottom, and the edges of the cheese start to soften slightly. Do not move the feta during this time, as it will stick if disturbed before the charred crust forms. After 3 minutes, use the spatula to gently flip the feta block, and grill the second side for another 3 minutes. Remove the lemon halves after 4 minutes, once they have dark grill marks and release a bright, caramelized citrus aroma. Total feta cook time is 6 minutes, resulting in a crisp charred exterior and soft, warm, slightly oozing center.
Transfer to Plate
Once both sides of the feta are charred and the center gives slightly when pressed gently with the spatula, turn off the heat. Use the metal grill spatula to carefully lift the feta from the grill pan, and place it centered on the hand-thrown terracotta serving plate. Add the grilled lemon halves to the plate, positioned to the right of the feta. Work slowly when transferring, as the soft feta can break if lifted too quickly.
Add Finishing Garnishes
Drizzle the remaining herb olive oil over the top of the warm feta. Drizzle the wildflower honey in thin zigzags across the feta surface, letting it run slightly down the sides. Squeeze a light splash of juice from one grilled lemon half over the cheese, then sprinkle with toasted sesame seeds and a few extra fresh oregano leaves for garnish. Add a light crack of fresh black pepper over top if desired. The heat from the feta will warm the honey and oil, creating a fragrant, glossy coating.
Tips
2.Resist the urge to move the feta for the first 3 minutes of grilling on each side. The cheese will release naturally from the grill ridges once a firm, charred crust forms; moving it too early will tear the soft cheese and leave half of it stuck to the pan.
3.For outdoor charcoal or gas grilling, place the feta on a small sheet of heavy-duty aluminum foil poked with 1cm holes if you are worried about it falling through wider grill grates. The foil still allows smoke flavor to reach the cheese and creates distinct char marks, while providing a stable surface as the feta softens.

OMG this was such a game changer for our weekend cookout! I was so sick of the same old burgers and hot dogs, so I threw this on the grill last minute and everyone was begging for the recipe. The herb marinade is so bright, and the feta gets perfectly gooey in the middle with those crispy little grill marks. SO good, 10/10.
Wait, hold up—8 minute cook time? That’s my kind of weeknight win! I made this last night to go with roasted veggies and quinoa for my meal prep bowls, and even my two picky kids ate every bite. I did add a little extra red pepper flake to the marinade for a tiny kick, would highly recommend.
Brought this to my office potluck yesterday and people literally crowded the platter. I served it with crostini and a little drizzle of honey on top, and it was gone in 10 minutes flat. Who knew grilled feta was this easy? The recipe says easy difficulty and they are NOT lying.
Made this after a long day hike last weekend, cooked it on our little camp grill right by the trailhead. It was so quick to throw together, we pre-marinated the feta at home before we left and it was perfectly flavored by the time we got to our spot. 10/10 camp food, will be making this on every trip this summer.
Wait, total newbie question here—do I need to oil the grill grates really well so the feta doesn’t stick? I’m terrible at grilling cheese, I always make a huge mess and half of it ends up stuck to the grates. This looks too good to mess up!
This is such a perfect gluten free appetizer for when I have friends over! I don’t have to make a separate thing for myself, and all my gluten-eating friends go crazy for it too. I used fresh oregano and thyme from my windowsill herb garden and it made the marinade taste so fresh.
This was solid! I will say, I used a pre-crumbled feta block by accident instead of a firm solid block packed in brine and it fell apart a little on the grill, but it still tasted amazing. Next time I’ll definitely grab the right kind of feta like the recipe says. Flavor was 10/10, I just messed up the cheese selection.
Made this for date night with my partner last night, paired it with a crisp white wine and some olives, and he said it felt like we were at a fancy Mediterranean restaurant instead of our tiny apartment balcony. Total win, will be adding this to our regular rotation.
Wait, has anyone tried making this on a grill pan indoors? My apartment complex doesn’t allow balcony grills and I’m dying to make this, but I don’t know if it’ll turn out the same without actual grill char.
Made this for our college football watch party last weekend, and it was the perfect appetizer to snack on during the game. Hearty, flavorful, way more interesting than the usual chips and dip. Even my buddy who swears he ‘doesn’t eat fancy cheese’ went back for thirds.
Wait why did I never think to grill feta before? I made this for brunch last weekend, served it alongside scrambled eggs, roasted tomatoes, and sourdough toast, and it was the star of the whole spread. The herb marinade is so simple but it packs so much flavor, I’m already obsessed.
I tossed a handful of chopped fresh jalapeños into the marinade and it slapped. The heat from the jalapeños pairs so well with the salty, creamy feta, I’ll never make it without that add again. Cooked up perfectly in 8 minutes just like the recipe says, zero hassle.
This is so affordable to make! I grabbed a block of feta on sale for $3, used dried herbs I already had in my pantry, and it tasted like a $15 restaurant appetizer. Perfect for when you want something fancy but don’t want to blow your grocery budget for the week.
I grew up eating feta with every family dinner, so I was a little skeptical of grilled feta at first, but this recipe knocked it out of the park. The herb marinade is exactly the kind of flavor my yiayia would use, it tasted like home. 10/10, will be passing this recipe around to my whole family.
Tried this last night and overcooked it by a couple minutes because I got distracted chatting with my roommate, so it was a little softer than I meant it to be, but it still tasted insane. I mopped up the leftover herb oil from the plate with crusty bread, no shame. Even my cat was trying to steal a bite off the counter.
Has anyone tested this with vegan feta? My daughter is dairy free and I’d love to make this for her high school graduation party next month, but I don’t want it to turn out rubbery or weird on the grill.
Wait this marinade is so good I used it on chicken too after I grilled the feta! Don’t sleep on saving the leftover herb oil, it makes the best quick marinade for grilled proteins or even a salad dressing. Total game changer, I’m never throwing out leftover marinade again.
I cut the feta into smaller cubes instead of grilling it as a whole block, skewered them with cherry tomatoes and cucumber chunks after grilling, and served them as little appetizer bites for my book club. They were so cute and easy to eat standing up, no plates needed! Everyone raved.
Threw this together last night after a long day at work when I had zero energy to cook. It took literally 10 minutes total from pulling the feta out of the fridge to having it on the table, paired with some leftover pita and hummus I had in the fridge. Quick, tasty, minimal cleanup? That’s my kind of weeknight meal. Will be making this on repeat on busy nights.