grilled lobster
intro
Sweet, succulent lobster tails grilled over hardwood coals, basted with garlic herb butter, finished with bright lemon for a showstopping summer cookout centerpiece.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat Charcoal Grill
Remove the grill grate from the built-in brushed stainless steel charcoal grill, light 2lbs of hardwood lump charcoal, and let burn until coals are covered in a thin layer of pale gray ash, approximately 15 minutes. Replace the grate, adjust top and bottom vents to reach a steady medium-high cooking temperature of 425°F, measured 2 inches above the grate. Test heat by holding your palm 2 inches above the grate: you should only be able to hold it for 3 seconds before pulling away.
Make Garlic Herb Butter
Place the 1/2 cup unsalted butter in the small brushed stainless steel mixing bowl, melt fully in 20-second microwave increments (or rested on the warm edge of the grill) until completely liquid. Stir in the 4 minced garlic cloves, 2 tbsp chopped parsley, 1 tsp picked thyme leaves, 1/4 tsp smoked paprika, 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper, and 1 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil until fully combined, with herbs and spices evenly distributed. Set the bowl back in its fixed position next to the basting brush.
Butterfly Lobster Tails
Place one raw lobster tail at a time on the central maple cutting board, hard rounded shell side up. Hold the tail steady with one hand, use the 8-inch walnut-handle chef knife to carefully cut lengthwise through the top center of the hard shell and through the top half of the meat, stopping 1/2 inch from the bottom soft shell membrane so the two halves remain connected. Gently pry the split shell open with your fingers, lift the lobster meat up through the cut, and rest it on top of the shell, leaving the hard tail fan fully intact. Repeat this process for all 4 lobster tails, taking care not to cut all the way through the bottom shell.
Season Lobster Meat
Pat the exposed surface of the butterflied lobster meat lightly with a clean corner of the indigo cotton towel to remove excess surface moisture. Sprinkle the meat evenly with the 1 tsp flaky sea salt, then use the silicone basting brush to coat the meat lightly with 1/3 of the garlic herb butter, ensuring the entire exposed meat surface is covered. Do not apply butter to the outer hard shells, as this will cause burning and flare-ups over the hot coals.
Grill Shell-Side Down
Use the long stainless steel grill tongs to pick up each seasoned lobster tail and place it on the preheated grill grate, shell side down, arranged 1 inch apart over direct charcoal heat. Close the grill lid and cook for exactly 5 minutes, until the outer shells turn a bright, vivid red, and the bottom edge of the meat closest to the shell starts to turn opaque white. Do not flip the tails at this stage, as the hard shell acts as a natural heat shield to protect the delicate meat.
Baste and Finish Grilling
After 5 minutes of shell-side cooking, open the grill lid, use the silicone basting brush to coat the top of the exposed lobster meat with half of the remaining herb butter. Close the grill lid and cook for an additional 3-4 minutes, until the lobster meat is fully opaque pearlescent white, with faint light golden grill marks on the surface, and the internal temperature reaches 140°F when measured with the digital instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the meat. Do not cook past 145°F internal temperature, as lobster meat will quickly become tough and rubbery when overcooked.
Plate and Serve
Use the long stainless steel grill tongs to transfer the cooked lobster tails to the matte off-white stoneware dinner plate, arranging them meat-side up for presentation. Drizzle the last of the remaining garlic herb butter over the top of the lobster meat, tuck fresh lemon wedges between the tails, and sprinkle with a pinch of extra chopped parsley for color. Serve immediately, with the small terracotta ramekin of extra melted butter on the side for dipping.
Tips
2.Pull lobster from the grill at 140°F internal temperature: residual carryover heat will raise the temperature to a perfect 145°F as the tails rest for 2 minutes, and any longer on the grill will result in tough, rubbery, overcooked meat.
3.Pat raw lobster meat dry before buttering and seasoning: excess surface moisture on the meat will prevent butter from adhering evenly, and will stop light, golden grill marks from forming during the final minutes of cooking.

OMG these garlic herb grilled lobster tails were the star of our anniversary dinner last night! I was so nervous to grill lobster for the first time since it feels like such a fancy, easy-to-mess-up dish, but the 10 minute cook time was totally manageable even for someone like me who burns shrimp half the time. The garlic herb butter was SO good I was dipping my sourdough in the leftover drippings straight from the pan. My husband kept saying it tasted like something we’d pay $50 a plate for at a waterfront restaurant. 10/10 will be making this for our Fourth of July cookout with the whole family!
Really solid recipe! The garlic herb blend is chef’s kiss, total game changer for weeknight date night when we don’t feel like dropping a bunch of money going out. I knocked a star off only because I found the cook time ran a tiny bit long on my gas grill — my tails were a touch chewy right at the 10 minute mark, so next time I’ll pull them at 8. My kids even snuck bites off our plates and asked when we can have lobster again, which is wild because they usually turn their nose up at any seafood that isn’t frozen fish sticks.
Brought these to a neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were swarming the platter before I even set it down on the table! I prepped the garlic herb butter the night before as part of my weekly meal prep, which made throwing these on the grill day-of so quick and low-fuss. I was worried the medium difficulty rating would mean too many fussy, complicated steps, but it was honestly super straightforward even for a casual grill guy like me. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular summer grilling rotation.