Gummy Worm Jello
intro
Wiggly bright lime jello topped with chocolate cookie 'dirt' and chewy gummy worms, a playful, nostalgic spooky treat perfect for festive kid-focused gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep serving cups
Arrange 8 clear 180ml (6oz) plastic cups on a rimmed baking sheet for easy transport to the fridge. Measure out 50g (1/3 cup) of gummy worms, cut half of these into 2.5cm (1-inch) segments to suspend inside the jello, leaving the remaining 150g (1 cup) whole for topping.
Dissolve jello powder
Empty both 85g packages of lime gelatin mix into a large heatproof glass mixing bowl. Carefully pour 480ml (2 cups) of rolling boiling water (100°C/212°F) over the powder, whisking continuously for 2 full minutes off heat until all gelatin granules are fully dissolved with no visible lumps.
Cool jello base
Stir the full 480ml (2 cups) of ice-cold water (4°C/40°F) into the dissolved gelatin mixture, stirring for 30 seconds to combine evenly. Let the mixture rest at room temperature (21°C/70°F) for 10 minutes to cool slightly, so it will not melt gummy worms when added.
Add suspended gummies
Pour 40ml (2.5 tablespoons) of the cooled jello mixture into the bottom of each prepared cup. Drop 3-4 of the cut gummy worm segments into each cup, pushing them down gently with a small spoon so they are partially submerged. Place the baking sheet with cups in a 4°C (40°F) refrigerator for 25 minutes until the jello is softly set (not fully firm) to hold suspended gummies in place.
Fill cups and chill
Remove the tray of partially set jello from the fridge. Pour the remaining cooled jello mixture evenly between the cups (about 80ml per cup), leaving a 1cm (1/2-inch) gap at the top of each cup to make space for the cookie topping. Return the tray to the 4°C (40°F) fridge to chill for 3 full hours, until the jello is completely firm and wobbly to a light touch.
Add cookie dirt topping
Once jello is fully set, remove the tray from the fridge. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon (15g) of finely crushed chocolate cookie crumbs evenly over the surface of the jello in each cup, spreading gently to create a uniform layer that looks like dark, loose garden dirt.
Garnish with whole worms
Tuck 2-3 whole gummy worms into each cup, resting half of each worm on the cookie crumb 'dirt' and letting the other half drape over the cup edge for a playful, just-emerged worm effect. Serve immediately, or cover loosely and chill for up to 24 hours before serving.
Tips
2.For an extra spooky swamp effect, swap 120ml (1/2 cup) of the cold water for chilled sweetened condensed milk to create a murky, opaque green jello base.
3.To make the treats easier to transport to parties, set the jello in lidded plastic cups and add the cookie crumbs and gummy worms just before arriving to prevent the crumbs from getting soggy.

OMG I made this for my youngest’s 8th birthday party and every single kid was screaming over how cool it was! I added a little extra crushed Oreo on top for ‘dirt’ and it looked like real wormy dirt, chef’s kiss. Took barely any active time which was a lifesaver when I was juggling cake and goodie bags too.
Wait no way this is actually that easy? I only have a mini fridge in my dorm, no fancy kitchen stuff — do I just need boiling water and a pan? Looks so good for movie nights with my roommates.
Made this for our neighborhood block party last weekend and it was the first empty dish on the table! Everyone kept asking for the recipe, even the adults were sneaking extra gummy worms out of the pan lmao. 10/10 will make again for our Halloween bash this year.
Quick question — can I use vegan jello and vegan gummy worms for this? My niece has a gelatin allergy and I want to make a version she can eat at our family dinner this Sunday!
Told my kids we were having ‘worms for dessert’ last night and they looked horrified until I pulled this out of the fridge. Best dad prank win ever. They ate two servings each, zero complaints except that I didn’t make more. Easy peasy too, even for a guy who burns toast half the time.
Can I make this a few days ahead of time? I’m trying to prep all my kid’s school snacks for the week on Sunday and this looks way more fun than the usual goldfish and fruit cups.
Game changer for my annual spooky movie marathon! I used lime jello to make it look extra slime-green and added a few plastic spider rings on top for flair. Everyone thought I spent hours on it, little did they know it only took me 20 minutes of actual work lmao.
Wait, so do you put the gummy worms in while the jello is still liquid, or wait until it’s partially set? I tried a different jello worm recipe once and all the worms sank to the bottom and melted, total fail 😭
I made this for my grandkids when they visited last weekend and it took me right back to making the same jello treats for their dad when he was little! So simple, so fun, doesn’t require a million fancy ingredients. They asked if we can make it every time they come over now.
Brought this to our Sunday football tailgate and even the guys who only eat wings and beer were going back for seconds. I used cherry jello for our team’s red color and put little football toothpicks in it, perfect easy game day snack. Will absolutely be making this all season.
SO good, but has anyone tried adding a little sour candy twist? I was thinking of using sour gummy worms instead of regular and maybe a pack of lemon jello mixed with strawberry for a sweet-sour vibe? Would that work?
This saved me on a random Tuesday night when I forgot it was my turn to bring snacks for my daughter’s scout meeting. I had all the ingredients in the pantry, threw it together during dinner, popped it in the fridge overnight, and it was perfect by the next morning. Total lifesaver.
Full transparency: I messed up the first batch because I forgot to let the jello cool a little before adding worms and they all melted into little colorful blobs at the bottom. Still tasted good, just looked wild. Second batch I waited like the recipe said and it turned out perfect! Even kitchen newbies like me can nail this if you follow the steps.
We make this every year at summer camp for the kids’ ‘dirt and worms’ day and it never misses. Super easy to make in big batches, no fancy cooking needed, even the pickiest eaters get excited about it. Pro tip: add a little chocolate pudding layer for extra dirt vibe!
Wait will this work with sugar free jello and sugar free gummies? My son is type 1 diabetic and I’m always looking for fun low-sugar treats he can bring to class parties without feeling left out.
Wait who else has made this with vodka for adult parties? 👀 I did a batch for my girls’ night last month with lime jello and citrus vodka, added regular gummy worms, and it was such a hit. Way more fun than regular jello shots!
I love that you don’t need any special skills for this! I’m still learning to cook and most dessert recipes feel super intimidating, but this was so straightforward and turned out perfect on my first try. My little cousin thought I was a professional chef lmao.
Has anyone ever added fresh fruit to this? I was thinking of tossing in some blueberries or sliced strawberries to make it a little more fruit-forward for our family picnic next weekend.
My kids loved it? No, *I* loved it. I’m 32 years old with no kids and I made this just for myself last night because I was craving a nostalgic snack, no regrets. Ate half the pan while watching old cartoons, 10/10 self care.