hershey banana pudding ice cream
intro
Creamy no-churn ice cream loaded with ripe banana, crunchy vanilla wafers, and rich Hershey’s milk chocolate, capturing classic Southern banana pudding flavor in a frosty, scoopable summer treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Melt Hershey Chocolate
Break 2.5oz of Hershey’s milk chocolate into 1-inch pieces, place in the small stainless steel mixing bowl. Microwave in 20-second increments, stirring thoroughly with the tip of the pale yellow silicone spatula between each burst, until chocolate is fully smooth and glossy (about 60 seconds total). Set the bowl aside to cool to room temperature for 10 minutes—do not refrigerate, as chocolate will seize and harden unevenly. Chop the remaining 0.5oz chocolate into tiny shavings for topping, and set the shavings on the corner of the maple cutting board.
Crush Vanilla Wafers
Place 1 cup of whole vanilla wafer cookies on the center of the maple cutting board. Use the flat side of the 7-inch chef’s knife to press down firmly on the wafers, crushing them into coarse, uneven crumbs. Set aside 2 tablespoons of larger, pea-sized wafer pieces for topping; pile the remaining crumbs on the edge of the cutting board. Do not grind wafers into a fine powder, as the crunchy, uneven texture is core to classic banana pudding flavor.
Mash Ripe Bananas
Peel all 3 spotty ripe bananas, place them on the cleared center of the maple cutting board. Use the polished stainless steel potato masher to press the bananas into a slightly chunky puree, leaving soft 1/4-inch banana pieces for texture. Stir in 1 teaspoon fresh lemon juice to slow enzymatic browning, then pile the mashed banana next to the wafer crumbs on the cutting board edge.
Whip Cream Base
Pour the cold heavy whipping cream into the large matte stainless steel mixing bowl. Whip on medium-high speed with the matte white electric hand mixer until stiff, billowy peaks form (3-4 minutes), where the peak holds its straight shape when the beater is lifted from the cream. Do not overwhip, as this will cause the cream to separate into butter and create a grainy ice cream texture.
Combine Ice Cream Base
Reduce mixer speed to low, slowly pour in the sweetened condensed milk, 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract, and 1/8 teaspoon flaky sea salt. Mix for 30 seconds just until fully combined, taking care not to deflate the light, airy whipped cream. Use the silicone spatula to fold in the mashed ripe bananas, stirring gently only 2-3 times to leave visible banana streaks through the base.
Layer and Swirl Mix-Ins
Scoop one third of the ice cream base into the parchment-lined matte silver loaf pan. Drizzle one third of the cooled melted Hershey’s chocolate over the base, then sprinkle one third of the crushed vanilla wafer crumbs. Repeat this layering process two more times to fill the pan, then run the stainless steel butter knife through the layers in a gentle S-curve to create thick chocolate and wafer swirls. Do not overmix, as distinct chocolate ribbons are preferred over uniformly mixed chocolate.
Top and Freeze Ice Cream
Sprinkle the reserved larger vanilla wafer pieces and Hershey’s chocolate shavings evenly over the top of the swirled ice cream. Cover the loaf pan tightly with a layer of plastic wrap, then place it on a flat middle freezer shelf for 6 hours, or until the ice cream is fully firm and scoopable. Avoid storing the ice cream in the freezer door, as fluctuating temperatures will create icy crystals.
Scoop and Serve
Remove the fully frozen ice cream from the freezer, let it sit at room temperature for 5 minutes to soften slightly for easy scooping. Use the matte silver spring-loaded ice cream scoop to form rounded, smooth scoops, and serve in the cream white fluted ceramic dessert bowl. Garnish with a thin fresh banana slice and a single mint leaf if desired.
Tips
2.Allow melted Hershey’s chocolate to cool to room temperature (about 10 minutes) before swirling: warm chocolate will melt the delicate whipped cream base, creating dense, icy spots instead of smooth, fudgy chocolate ribbons.
3.Freeze the ice cream on a flat middle freezer shelf rather than the door: the door experiences frequent temperature fluctuations that cause large, crunchy ice crystals to form, ruining the smooth, creamy texture.

OMG this was SO good!!! I made this for our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and every last scoop was gone before I even got a second helping. The combo of creamy Hershey chocolate, sweet banana, and that classic pudding texture hits so different than regular store-bought ice cream. Total game changer for summer treats!
Super easy recipe to follow! Only tiny gripe is I think I let my bananas get a touch too overripe so the banana flavor was almost overpowering the chocolate for me. Still ate three bowls in one sitting though, no regrets lmao.
My kids loved this. I’ve been trying to find fun summer treats to make for our after-dinner family time and this is now on permanent rotation. Even my super picky 7 year old asked for seconds before he finished his first scoop! I added a handful of crushed vanilla wafers on top to lean into the banana pudding vibe and it was chef’s kiss.
Just pulled this out of the freezer after the 6 hour chill and WOW. I was worried homemade ice cream would be a huge hassle without a fancy machine but the no-churn method is so straightforward? How is this this creamy without churning? Blown away. Already texted the recipe to my whole friend group.
I’ve been making old fashioned banana pudding for my grandbabies for 40 years, so I was skeptical about an ice cream version. Let me tell you, this might be my new go-to! It has all that creamy banana and vanilla flavor I love, plus the Hershey chocolate adds such a nice rich twist. Brought it to Sunday family dinner and the grandkids were begging for the recipe before they left.
Tasted good but mine turned out a little icy? I followed the measurements exactly, not sure what I did wrong. Maybe I didn’t mix the condensed milk in well enough? Bummer because the flavor was on point when I licked the spoon mid-prep.
Meal prepped a batch of this for my late night sweet cravings this week and I’m already halfway through the tub. No shame. It’s so rich and creamy, I don’t even feel like I’m missing out on the fancy $8 a pint ice cream from the grocery store. Will absolutely be making this monthly.
Made this for my niece’s birthday cookout like I said I would and it was a home run. I swirled in extra Hershey syrup right before I froze it and there were chocolate ribbons in every bite. 10/10, will be making this for every summer cookout from here on out.
Great recipe overall! I cut back a little on the sugar since the Hershey bars are already sweet, and it was perfect for my taste. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is the 6 hour wait time is pure torture when you’re craving ice cream lol.
Game changer. I’ve made so many homemade ice cream recipes over the years that were either a ton of work or tasted off, but this one is so easy and tastes like something you’d get at a premium ice cream shop. The banana flavor isn’t artificial at all, and the Hershey chunks melt perfectly on your tongue.
I made this for my partner who is OBSESSED with all things banana pudding and he said it’s better than the banana pudding his grandma makes. Don’t tell his grandma that, obviously. 😂 The Hershey chocolate cuts the sweetness perfectly so it doesn’t feel heavy even after two scoops.
Just finished making this for the first time and oh my gosh. I added a little salty peanut butter swirl because I’m a peanut butter chocolate banana fiend and it’s unreal. Don’t sleep on adding a little peanut butter to this, trust me.
Wait why did I wait so long to make this?? I had all the ingredients in my kitchen already, I didn’t even have to run to the grocery store. It’s so easy even someone who burns toast could make it. 10/10, no notes.
Made this for my roommate’s birthday last night and we ate almost half the tub while binge watching our favorite show. It’s so creamy and the Hershey chocolate chunks are the perfect little surprise in every bite. Will be making this on repeat all summer long.