Hot Butter Rum Hot Cider
intro
Velvety spiced apple cider spiked with dark rum, topped with melting spiced butter, a cozy, aromatic cold-weather sipper perfect for holiday gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Spiced Butter
Place 4 tbsp softened unsalted butter, 2 tbsp packed dark brown sugar, 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon, 1/4 tsp freshly grated nutmeg, 1/8 tsp ground cloves, and 1/2 tsp vanilla extract into the small beech wood mixing bowl. Use the charcoal silicone spatula to mash and stir the ingredients together for 2 minutes until completely smooth, with no visible streaks of separate spice or sugar. The finished butter will be a uniform light golden-brown color, soft and spreadable. Set aside at room temperature until ready to serve.
Simmer Cider Base
Pour 4 cups unfiltered apple cider into the 3-quart stainless steel saucepan. Add 2 whole cinnamon sticks and 4 whole cloves to the cider. Place the pan over medium-low heat on the induction zone, and bring to a gentle simmer (do NOT boil, as this will make the cider taste flat and cloudy). Adjust heat to maintain a low, steady simmer for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally with the long beech wood stirring spoon. The cider will darken slightly and release a strong warm apple and spice aroma as it simmers.
Strain Out Spices
After 15 minutes of simmering, turn off the heat to the induction zone. Use the long beech wood stirring spoon to fish out the softened whole cinnamon sticks and cloves, discarding them. For an extra-smooth base, pour the cider through the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer to catch any small spice fragments. The spiced cider base will be a deeper, richer amber color than when it started.
Stir in Dark Rum
Pour 1 cup dark spiced rum into the warm spiced cider base, stirring gently with the beech wood spoon for 30 seconds to fully combine. Do not return the pan to high heat after adding rum, as excessive heat will cook off the alcohol and dull the rum's warm spiced flavor. The finished mixture will have a rich, deep amber hue and a warm, spicy-sweet aroma.
Prep Serving Mugs
Set the four 12oz clear glass mugs in a neat row on the front center of the counter, ensuring they are clean, dry, and heat-safe. Divide the spiced butter evenly between the mugs, placing a 1 tbsp soft dollop into the bottom of each. The butter will hold its soft shape at the bottom of the mugs until hot cider is poured over it.
Pour Hot Cider
Set the fine-mesh strainer over the first mug, then use the stainless steel ladle to pour the hot rum-cider mixture through the strainer into each mug, filling each to 2cm below the rim. The hot liquid will immediately melt the spiced butter at the bottom, which will rise to the surface to create a rich, glossy golden layer on top of the cider. Repeat until all mugs are filled.
Garnish and Serve
Rest one whole cinnamon stick across the rim of each mug, then skewer 2 fresh cranberries onto the protruding end of each cinnamon stick for a bright pop of festive color. Let the drinks rest for 1 minute to cool slightly to a comfortable sipping temperature, then serve immediately while piping hot. Wispy steam will rise softly from the surface of each mug as they are served.
Tips
2.Use refrigerated fresh-pressed unfiltered apple cider instead of shelf-stable clear apple juice: unfiltered cider has a richer, more complex apple flavor and cloudy, hearty texture that makes the drink feel cozy and substantial, while clear juice tastes overly sweet, thin, and artificially flavored. Avoid ciders with added sugar or preservatives for the best taste.
3.Soften butter to room temperature for 30 minutes before mixing the spiced butter: cold butter will not blend smoothly with sugar and spices, leading to lumpy, unevenly flavored butter that won't melt evenly into a glossy layer when hot cider is poured over it. Room temperature butter mixes into a smooth paste that melts instantly for a velvety texture.

OMG this is the coziest drink I’ve made all fall! Made it for our Sunday family dinner last night and everyone went back for seconds. The butter rum flavor is so warm, not too sweet, perfect with the apple cider base. 10/10 will be making this for our Thanksgiving pre-game too!
Super easy to throw together, took me exactly 20 minutes like the recipe said! Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I added a little extra rum because I like my drinks boozier, but the base recipe is solid. Brought it to my friend’s bonfire last weekend and it was gone in 45 minutes.
My kids begged me to leave the rum out of a small batch for them and they chugged it! I added a little extra cinnamon stick and a dash of nutmeg on top for the adult version, and it tastes like a hug in a mug. SO good on these cold Chicago evenings when we’re coming home from soccer practice.
Game changer! I’ve been making regular spiced cider for years for our annual fall potluck and this version blew my old recipe out of the water. Got so many people asking for the recipe I just sent them all straight to this page. The salted butter pat on top is *chef’s kiss*.
Made this in my dorm room with a tiny electric kettle and it worked! I didn’t have fresh cinnamon sticks so I used ground cinnamon and it still turned out great. Perfect for late night study sessions when it’s freezing outside and I don’t want to walk to the coffee shop.
I’ve been making hot buttered rum for 40 years and this twist with fresh apple cider is the best version I’ve ever tried. My grandkids (even the grown ones) ask for it every time they come over now. I add a clove-studded orange slice to each mug for a little extra zing.
Great post-hike warm up drink! I poured it into insulated travel mugs for me and my partner after our morning hike in the Rockies and it was the perfect treat. Next time I’ll use a little less butter though, it felt a tiny bit greasy on top for my taste.
Hosted a girls’ night in last night and made a big batch of this in my slow cooker so it stayed warm the whole time. We added a caramel rim to the mugs and a little whipped cream on top, felt like we were at a fancy ski lodge! 10/10 will be making this all winter.
Just finished making this and my whole house smells like fall! The recipe is so easy even my teen who burns toast helped me stir the pot and didn’t mess it up. Can’t wait to serve this at our neighborhood tree lighting next month.
Served this at our weekly board game night and it was the perfect pick me up between rounds of Catan. I used spiced rum instead of regular and it added such a nice extra layer of flavor, highly recommend that swap!
Made this vegan by swapping the regular butter for vegan salted butter and used a non-alcoholic rum alternative for my sober friends, and it still tasted amazing! Great versatile base recipe that’s easy to adjust for different diets.
We got our first snowstorm of the year yesterday and I made this first thing when I woke up. Curled up on the couch with my dog, a mug of this, and a Christmas movie? Absolute perfection.
I was so nervous to bring something to my office potluck because I’m a terrible cook, but this recipe was so easy I couldn’t mess it up! Everyone kept saying it was the best thing at the whole potluck, I felt like a real chef.
Brought a thermos of this to my kid’s cross country meet on a cold Saturday morning and all the other parents were asking for sips. Way better than the sad lukewarm coffee they were selling at the concession stand.
I made a big batch of this on Sunday and stored it in mason jars in the fridge to reheat during the week. It reheats so well! Only thing is I wish it was a little less sweet, so next time I’ll use unsweetened apple cider instead of the regular kind I grabbed.
Test ran this for my upcoming holiday party and it’s officially on the menu! I’m gonna set up a little topping bar with cinnamon sticks, whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and star anise so people can customize their mugs. Can’t wait!
We made this for our local fall festival’s adult beverage booth and we sold out in 2 hours! We had people coming back twice asking for refills, it was such a hit. We’ll definitely be bringing it back next year.