Jell-O shots (heart-shaped)
intro
Wobbly, fruity heart-shaped Jell-O shots with a smooth vodka kick, perfect for Valentine’s celebrations, easy to prep ahead for party guests.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep the silicone molds
Lightly coat the cavities of a 12-cavity heart-shaped silicone mold (each cavity 45ml/1.5oz size) with 1 teaspoon (5ml) of non-stick cooking spray, then wipe excess spray away with a paper towel to prevent greasy residue on set shots. Place the mold on a small rimmed baking sheet for stable, easy transfer to the fridge.
Dissolve Jell-O powder
Pour 240ml (1 cup) of cold tap water into a small 1L saucepan, bring to a rolling boil over medium-high heat (approximately 3-4 minutes, with large bubbles breaking constantly at the surface). Remove the pan from heat, pour in the full 85g (3oz) box of strawberry Jell-O powder, and whisk continuously for 2 full minutes until all powder clumps are fully dissolved and no graininess remains.
Mix in chilled vodka
Slowly pour the 240ml (1 cup) of chilled plain vodka into the warm dissolved Jell-O mixture, stirring constantly with a whisk for 30 seconds to fully combine. Wait 5 minutes for the mixture to cool slightly if it is still steaming, to avoid alcohol evaporation from high heat.
Fill mold cavities
Hold the saucepan by its handle and use the pour spout (or a small funnel) to carefully pour the red Jell-O-vodka mixture into each prepared heart mold cavity, filling each to 1mm below the top edge to prevent overflow during transfer. Use a paper towel to wipe up any spilled mixture on the flat mold surface between cavities to ensure clean, smooth edges on set shots.
Chill to set fully
Carefully lift the baking sheet with the filled mold and slide it onto a flat middle shelf in a refrigerator set to 4°C (39°F). Chill for a full 2 hours, until the Jell-O is completely firm with no liquid sloshing when the mold is gently jiggled. Never place the mold in the freezer, as ice crystals will form and ruin the smooth Jell-O texture.
Unmold and garnish
Once fully set, gently peel the silicone mold edges away from the sides of each Jell-O shot, then push up from the bottom of each cavity to release the smooth heart shapes. Top each shot with a 1 teaspoon (5ml) dollop of whipped cream and a light pinch of red sprinkles right before serving to prevent the cream from melting.
Tips
2.Avoid adding fresh pineapple, kiwi, papaya, or ginger root to your Jell-O mixture, as natural enzymes in these ingredients break down gelatin and will prevent shots from setting firmly.
3.If shots stick to the mold during unmolding, dip the bottom of the silicone mold in a shallow dish of warm (not boiling) water for 5 seconds to loosen the edges slightly, taking care not to let water seep into the mold cavities.

OMG these were the absolute hit of my Galentine’s girls night last weekend! I used strawberry vodka for half the batch and made a non-alcoholic cherry version for my teen cousin who crashed, and everyone went back for seconds. So easy to pop out of the heart molds too, no sticking at all! 10/10 will make again for our summer cookout too.
Brought these to our office potluck for Valentine’s week and my coworkers would not stop asking for the recipe. Did a mix of lime and raspberry Jell-O with plain vodka, super smooth, no weird artificial aftertaste if you follow the ratios exactly. Only tiny note: make sure you give them the full 2 hours to set, I rushed my first test batch and they were goopy.
Made the non-alcoholic version for my kids’ class Valentine’s party and they went crazy for them! The heart shape is so cute, I even added a little whipped cream and a sprinkle of pink sugar on top for extra flair. Zero leftovers, every single one got eaten. SO good, and so easy even my 7 year old helped stir the Jell-O!
Game. Changer. We made these for my best friend’s bachelorette weekend in Scottsdale and they were perfect for poolside. We used coconut rum and pineapple Jell-O for a tropical vibe, and the little heart shapes were so on brand for the love-themed weekend. Did I mention how easy these are? Total prep took like 15 mins tops, then we just let them set while we got our nails done.
My niece made me help her make these for her birthday party, I thought it was gonna be a whole messy production but nah, super straightforward. Ate like 6 of the non-alcoholic ones before the party even started. Don’t tell her I said that though.
Made these for our dorm pre-game last Saturday and they were way better than the sad plastic cup Jell-O shots we usually make. The heart molds make them feel way fancier than they are, and they’re way less messy to eat too. Only thing is I forgot to grease the molds a little on my first batch so a couple broke when I popped them out, oops.
I’ve made these three times in the last month! First for my book club, then for my neighbor’s Super Bowl watch party (I know, hearts at a football game, but they were red so it worked), then for my granddaughter’s soccer team snack. Everyone always asks where I got the idea. Perfect easy recipe that looks way more impressive than it is.
Made these for my husband for our first Valentine’s Day married, did a mix of his favorite lemon Jell-O with vanilla vodka. He thought I spent forever on them, ha! Little does he know it took 15 mins of active time and then just chill time. We ate them while we watched our wedding video, so cute. Will definitely be a yearly tradition.
Tried these for a TikTok I was making for my date night ideas series, and they went viral! So many people commented asking for the link to the recipe, I had to tag this page. The heart shape is so photogenic, they look amazing on camera, and they taste even better than they look. 10/10 for content and for flavor.
Made these for my daughter’s daddy-daughter dance, she told all her friends I was the ‘cool dad’ because of them. Win! I did the non-alcoholic strawberry version, added a little gummy bear in the center of each heart before they set, the kids lost their minds over it. Super easy, minimal cleanup, dad win all around.
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I have celiac and it’s so hard to find fun party treats I don’t have to modify a ton. I used a vegan gelatin alternative to make them work for my vegan best friend too, and they set perfectly! We brought them to our friend’s game night and no one could tell they were vegan.
These are my go-to for every girls’ night now. Last time I made them I did layered hearts: half strawberry, half peach, looked so pretty! I also added a little edible glitter on top before they set, they looked so sparkly and cute. People kept taking photos of them before eating them, it was hilarious.
I am literally the worst at making anything in the kitchen, I burn toast half the time. But these? I made them perfectly on the first try! I was so proud of myself. I did the non-alcoholic berry blue version for my little sister’s sleepover, and all the girls thought I was a professional cook. Thank you for such an easy, foolproof recipe!
These gave me such 90s/00s party nostalgia! I remember my mom making Jell-O Jigglers for every birthday party growing up, and the heart shape makes them feel so updated and fun. I made them for my 90s themed birthday party last weekend, used cherry and orange Jell-O just like my mom did, and all my friends were talking about how nostalgic they were.
Made these with sugar free Jell-O and unflavored protein powder mixed in for a little post-workout treat (non-alcoholic, obviously) and they slapped! Who says healthy snacks have to be boring? The heart shape makes them feel like a fun little treat instead of a boring protein snack. Will be making these weekly for my meal prep.
I tested these as a possible signature cocktail treat for an upcoming Valentine’s themed wedding, and they are perfect! We’re going to make them in the couple’s wedding colors (deep red and pale pink) and serve them during cocktail hour. They’re portable, easy to make in big batches, and guests love little bite-sized treats at weddings. Total win for my client!
Made these for my Galentine’s brunch and paired them with mimosa chasers, chef’s kiss. I used prosecco instead of vodka for half the batch, they tasted like a bubbly strawberry dream. My friends are already begging me to make them again for our next brunch in March.
Made these as a little fun reward for my high school students who aced their midterms (non-alcoholic, obviously, I’m not trying to get fired!) and they were so excited. The heart shape was perfect for the week of Valentine’s Day, and even my most stoic senior was grinning when he got his. Such a fun, easy pick-me-up for the kids.