Lobster Salad
intro
Sweet, tender chunks of fresh Atlantic lobster tossed in a light creamy lemon-dill dressing, served over crisp greens for a bright, luxurious warm-weather meal.
Ingredients
Steps
Boil salted water
Fill the 8-liter brushed stainless steel stock pot two-thirds full with cold tap water, stir in 1 tablespoon of kosher salt, and set over high heat to bring to a full rolling boil. The water should taste as salty as seawater to properly season the lobster meat as it cooks. While waiting for the water to boil, fill the large clear tempered glass mixing bowl with cold tap water and 4 cups of ice cubes to create an ice bath for shocking cooked lobster.
Cook fresh lobsters
Once the water reaches a vigorous, rolling boil, use the long stainless steel silicone-tipped tongs to carefully lower both lobsters head-first into the water. Cover the pot with the glass lid, set a timer for 10 minutes, and maintain a steady gentle boil. Lobsters are fully cooked when shells turn a bright, opaque red, and the thickest part of the tail reaches an internal temperature of 140°F (60°C). Do not overcook, as this will make the meat tough and rubbery.
Shock in ice bath
As soon as the 10-minute timer expires, use the tongs to immediately lift the hot lobsters from the boiling water, letting excess water drain off for 2 seconds, then transfer them fully into the prepared ice bath. Let lobsters rest submerged for 5 minutes to stop the cooking process completely; this prevents residual heat from overcooking the delicate tail meat and makes the meat easier to remove from the shell.
Pick lobster meat
Lift cooled lobsters from the ice bath, pat shells lightly dry with the corner of the sky-blue linen towel, and place them on the acacia wood cutting board. Use the 8-inch chef knife to split tails lengthwise down the center, then use the metal lobster cracker to crack open the large claws and smaller knuckle segments. Carefully pick out all meat in the largest possible chunks, removing and discarding the thin dark intestinal vein running down the center of each tail. Reserve any bright red roe or pale yellow tomalley for extra richness if desired. You should have approximately 1lb (450g) of picked lobster meat, placed in the medium brushed stainless steel mixing bowl.
Mix creamy dressing
Dry the interior of the large glass mixing bowl (previously used for the ice bath) with the linen towel. Add 1/3 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 1 tsp Dijon mustard, 2 tbsp fresh lemon juice, 1 tsp finely grated lemon zest, 1/2 tsp kosher salt, and 1/4 tsp freshly ground black pepper to the bowl. Use the pale sage green silicone spatula to stir the mixture until completely smooth, with no streaks of mustard remaining.
Toss lobster salad
Add the finely diced celery, 2 tbsp chopped fresh dill, and all picked lobster chunks to the bowl of smooth dressing. Use the silicone spatula to gently fold the ingredients together, taking care not to mash or break up the lobster chunks—aim for large, bite-sized pieces rather than finely shredded meat. Taste a small bite, and adjust seasoning with extra salt or lemon juice if needed. Cover the bowl with a small plate and chill in the refrigerator for 15 minutes to let flavors meld.
Arrange salad greens
Retrieve the chilled lobster salad from the refrigerator. Divide the 4 cups of washed, spun-dry mixed baby greens evenly across the four matte white ceramic salad plates, creating a loose, low mound in the center of each plate. Do not pack the greens down tightly; they should stay light and airy to support the weight of the lobster salad.
Plate and garnish
Divide the chilled lobster salad into four equal portions, mounding each portion gently on top of the bed of greens on each plate. Do not press the salad down. Garnish each plate with one small sprig of fresh dill, a light twist of freshly ground black pepper, and a thin lemon wedge placed on the outer rim of the plate. Serve immediately while chilled.
Tips
2.Fold lobster meat into dressing gently rather than stirring vigorously: this keeps lobster chunks large and intact, creating a luxurious, substantial texture instead of a mushy, tuna-salad-like consistency.
3.Use full-fat mayonnaise for the dressing: low-fat mayonnaise has a higher water and stabilizer content that will make the salad watery as it chills, and lacks the rich, creamy mouthfeel that balances the sweet, briny lobster meat.

OMG this tastes exactly like the lobster salad my grandma used to make at our summer cookouts in Cape Cod! I was worried it’d be too fancy or fussy but the 10 minute cook time is no joke — threw it together for a quick weeknight dinner last night and my husband ate two full servings. SO good, will absolutely be making this for our neighborhood potluck next weekend.
Game changer for my weekly meal prep! I pre-made a batch on Sunday, kept it in an airtight container, and it held up perfectly for 3 days of work lunches. Not too heavy, the lemon zest adds such a bright pop that keeps it from getting boring. Only swap I did was a tiny bit of extra celery for crunch, no notes otherwise.
My kids loved it!! I was nervous they’d turn their noses up at lobster since they usually only eat chicken nuggets and mac and cheese, but they kept asking for seconds. Pro tip for other parents: cut the lobster into extra tiny bites so it’s easier for little hands to pick up. Will be adding this to our regular family dinner rotation.
Wait, hold on — the recipe says medium difficulty? I’m a total beginner cook and I pulled this off without a single mishap! Used fresh lobster tails from my local fish market, followed the directions exactly, and it tasted restaurant quality. Brought it on a day hike to eat at the summit and my hiking buddy begged me for the recipe. Knocked a star off only because I wish there was a note about how to use pre-cooked lobster if you don’t want to boil it yourself, but otherwise 10/10.
Made this for our college football tailgate last Saturday and it was gone in 15 minutes flat. People were hovering over the platter asking who made it. I added a tiny pinch of Old Bay on top for a little extra kick and it slapped. 10/10, perfect for any outdoor gathering.
Wait has anyone tried making this with a plant-based lobster substitute? I have a vegan friend coming to our dinner party next week and I want to make something everyone can eat, but I don’t want to mess up the flavor balance.
I’ve been making New England lobster salad for 40 years since I grew up in Massachusetts, and I have to say this recipe is spot on. The ratio of mayo to lemon to celery is exactly right — no gloopy mess, no overpowering seasonings, just the clean sweet taste of lobster front and center. My only tiny tweak is a sprinkle of fresh chives on top.
I had a total brain fart while making this and accidentally added sour cream instead of mayo for half the mixture, and honestly? It was still incredible. Rich, a little tangy, didn’t ruin it at all. Just goes to show how forgiving this recipe is. Would absolutely make again, even when I don’t mess up the ingredients.
Perfect light post-gym lunch! I swapped the full-fat mayo for light mayo and served it over a bed of arugula with some cherry tomatoes, and it was so satisfying without leaving me feeling bloated. High protein, super fresh, will be making this on repeat all summer.
Made this for a brunch I hosted last weekend and it was the star of the spread. I served it on mini brioche buns as sliders with a side of coleslaw and dill pickle chips, and every single guest asked for the recipe. The 10 minute cook time is a total lifesaver when you’re juggling 3 different brunch dishes and a house full of people, no notes.
Wait I thought lobster salad was supposed to be all boring and fancy, but this slapped harder than most of the side dishes I make for my weekend BBQs. I added a little smoked paprika to the mix to give it a tiny smoky edge and it paired so well with grilled corn and coleslaw. Who knew seafood and BBQ went this hard together?
Made this for my husband’s birthday dinner since lobster is his favorite, and he said it was better than the lobster salad we had on our honeymoon in Maine. Super easy to pull off after work, no messy complicated steps, just really good simple food. We ate it on our back porch with a glass of white wine and it was the perfect little date night meal.
I was worried this would feel too heavy for 90 degree beach weather, but it was light, bright, and perfect for eating on our condo balcony after a day in the sun. Only issue I had was I overcooked the lobster a tiny bit so it was a little rubbery — definitely setting a timer next time so I don’t do that again!