Manhattan
intro
A timeless, balanced rye whiskey cocktail with rich, warm notes of sweet vermouth and aromatic bitters, finished with a luxe maraschino cherry garnish.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill coupe glasses
Place two 180 ml (6 fl oz) coupe or Nick & Nora glasses in the freezer set to -18°C (0°F, no heat applied) for 3 minutes to fully chill; alternatively, fill each glass with ice water and set aside while you mix the drink, discarding the water right before straining.
Assemble mixing glass
Set a sturdy 500 ml mixing glass on your work surface at room temperature (no heat is required for this recipe), add 2 cups of large, dense ice cubes to the glass over 30 seconds; large ice minimizes excess dilution while properly chilling the cocktail to the correct temperature.
Pour cocktail components
Measure and pour 120 ml rye whiskey, 60 ml sweet red vermouth, and 8 dashes of Angostura aromatic bitters directly over the ice in the mixing glass over the course of 1 minute, pouring slowly to avoid splashing; no heat is applied to ingredients at this stage, and you should avoid adding cherry syrup now to keep the drink crisp and balanced during stirring.
Stir to chill and dilute
Insert a long-handled bar spoon into the mixing glass, stir steadily and gently for 25 seconds at a moderate pace (no external heat is applied, as the ice chills the mixture), until the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty to the touch and the drink reaches approximately 4°C (39°F); do not shake, as this will cloud the cocktail and create a harsh, over-diluted texture.
Strain into chilled glasses
Place a Hawthorne strainer over the top of the mixing glass, hold it firmly in place, and pour the mixed cocktail evenly (≈90 ml per serving) between the two pre-chilled coupe glasses over 45 seconds, keeping the drink chilled with no heat exposure; leave 1 cm (≈0.4 in) of headspace at the top of each glass to avoid spills when serving.
Garnish and serve
Skewer one Luxardo maraschino cherry per glass, rest the skewer across the rim of each coupe, and add 5 ml (1 tsp) of reserved maraschino cherry syrup to each drink if you prefer a slightly sweeter profile; keep the drink chilled with no heat exposure, and serve within 1 minute of straining without additional ice to preserve the balanced dilution.
Tips
2.For the most authentic, balanced flavor, use spicy, 90+ proof rye whiskey instead of bourbon; rye’s peppery, dry bite cuts through the sweet, herbal notes of vermouth perfectly.
3.Skip artificially colored, candy-sweet grocery store maraschino cherries; opt for jarred Luxardo-style cherries for a deep, tart, complex fruit garnish without artificial flavor.

OMG this is the perfect Manhattan! I’ve been messing up the ratio for years and this 5 minute recipe is a total game changer. Made these for our weekly poker night with the guys and everyone asked for the recipe. No more overpaying at fancy downtown bars for me!
Made this for my anniversary dinner with my wife last night and she said it was better than the one we had on our first date at that speakeasy in Brooklyn. So easy to throw together too, I didn’t even break a sweat while getting the rest of dinner ready. 10/10 will be making these every weekend now.
Brought a batch of these (pre-mixed, no ice so they didn’t dilute!) to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and they were such a hit. I set out a little dish of maraschino cherries for garnish and people went crazy. SO good, I even had a few neighbors text me the next day for the recipe.
Wait, does anyone else skip the maraschino cherry and use a brandied cherry instead? I tried that last time I made this recipe and it felt like a total upgrade! The sweet, boozy cherry pairs so much better with the whiskey and vermouth if you ask me. Only reason it’s not a 5 is I wish the recipe mentioned brandied cherries as an option, they’re such a game changer!
Full transparency: I’ve never made a cocktail at home before, ever. This was so easy I couldn’t believe it! Took me all of 5 minutes, just like the recipe said, and it tasted like something a professional would make. My roommate thought I ordered delivery from the cocktail bar down the street lmao.
I made these for our monthly book club meeting last week instead of our usual wine, and everyone was raving. We ended up talking about cocktails for 45 minutes instead of the book, oops. Worth it though, this recipe is a new staple for all my get-togethers from now on.
Full disclosure: I usually hate vermouth, like I avoid any drink that has it in it. But my partner begged me to try making this recipe, and I was shocked how much I loved it! The ratio is perfect, the vermouth doesn’t overpower the whiskey at all. Total convert over here.
Made these for our Sunday football watch party and they went faster than the buffalo wings. I didn’t even get a second one before the pitcher was empty! Next time I’m doubling the batch for sure. Way better than drinking beer the whole time.
I’ve been making Manhattans for 40 years, and I have to say, this ratio is spot on. I used to go a little heavy on the bitters, but dialing it back like this recipe suggests makes such a difference. Tastes like the ones I used to get at the old steakhouse downtown back in the 80s.
Quick question: do you guys stir this with ice and then strain it into a chilled glass, or do you serve it over ice? I did a test batch last night and it tasted great, but I’m not sure if I served it right, and I don’t want to mess it up when I make these for my dinner party this weekend.
OMG I added a little splash of the maraschino cherry juice to my drink last night and it was chef’s kiss. Don’t @ me, I know it’s not “traditional” but it added the perfect little extra sweetness. 10/10 would recommend if you have a sweet tooth like me.
I pre-batched a whole bottle of these on Sunday to have after work all week, and it’s the best decision I’ve made all month. No messing around with measuring after a long day, just pour over a little ice (if I’m feeling lazy) and sip. Perfect way to unwind.
Wait has anyone tried adding a tiny dash of orange bitters along with the regular aromatic bitters? I did that last time I made this and it added such a bright, citrusy little note that was unreal. Felt like a fancy bar cocktail for real.
Finally got 20 minutes of quiet after the baby went to sleep last night, so I whipped this up to have with my wife while we watched our show. It was such a nice little treat, took no time at all, and made our random Tuesday night feel like a special date. 10/10, will be a regular in our house now.
Y’all I used the super cheap bottom-shelf rye I had in the back of my liquor cabinet for this, and it still tasted incredible? I thought for sure you needed top-shelf stuff to make a good Manhattan, but this recipe is so well balanced it even makes cheap liquor taste fancy. Total win for my wallet. Knocked a star off because I wish I found this recipe years ago, I would’ve saved so much money on bar tabs!
I was stressing about what to serve as a welcome drink for my husband’s birthday dinner party last weekend, and this was the perfect call. It’s classic, everyone likes it, it’s quick to make, and I didn’t have to play bartender all night because I pre-batched a big pitcher. Got so many compliments.
Just whipped one of these up after coming in from shoveling 6 inches of snow, and let me tell you, there is nothing better. Warmed me right up, was so easy to make when my fingers were still half frozen, and it made the whole cold, snowy afternoon feel so cozy. Already planning to make another one later tonight when I have to go shovel round two that’s coming down now.