Maple Old Fashioned Cocktails
intro
A smooth, warming autumn twist on the classic Old Fashioned, swapping refined sugar for rich maple syrup, balanced with aromatic bitters and bold bourbon for slow, cozy sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Cut Orange Twists
Set the whole navel orange on the center work area. Hold the matte stainless steel channel knife firmly, and pull it across the orange peel to cut two 2-inch long, 1-inch wide strips of peel, taking care to avoid cutting into the bitter white pith beneath the bright orange zest. Place the finished twists in the small matte cream ceramic pin dish, and set aside for garnish.
Build Cocktail Base
Set the 16oz crystal mixing glass in the center of the work area. Use the double-sided brushed stainless steel jigger to measure and add 4oz (120ml) bourbon, 1oz (30ml) pure Grade A dark amber maple syrup, and 8 dashes of aromatic bitters to the mixing glass. Do not add ice yet, as this will start dilution too early.
Add Stirring Ice
Add 1 cup (240ml) of fresh, cold cubed stirring ice to the mixing glass, filling the glass to 2/3 capacity. Use ice straight from the freezer with no surface melt, as wet ice will over-dilute the cocktail before stirring.
Stir Cocktail Gently
Hold the mixing glass steady with one hand, insert the long-handled twisted stainless steel bar spoon, and stir slowly and steadily in a circular motion for 25-30 seconds. Stop stirring when the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty cold to the touch; the liquid will dilute by roughly 20% as a small amount of ice melts. Do not shake, as this will introduce air bubbles that cloud the spirit and create a harsh, watery texture.
Prep Lowball Glasses
Place the two matching crystal lowball glasses on the counter to the right of the mixing glass. Add one large 2-inch clear ice cube to each glass, letting the cubes sit for 10 seconds to slightly chill the thick glass base before straining. This prevents the cocktail from melting too quickly after pouring.
Strain Cocktail Evenly
Rest the brushed stainless steel Hawthorne strainer firmly on top of the frosty mixing glass, holding it tight with one finger to secure the coiled spring against the glass rim. Pour the chilled cocktail evenly between the two prepared lowball glasses, pouring slowly to avoid splashing. Each glass will hold roughly 2.5oz (75ml) of finished cocktail, covering the bottom 1/3 of the glass around the large ice cube.
Express Orange Peel
Hold one orange twist over each filled glass, bright orange skin side facing down toward the cocktail surface. Squeeze the peel firmly between your thumb and forefinger to release the citrus essential oils onto the top of the drink, then rub the peel lightly along the outer rim of the glass before draping it over the edge as garnish. Discard any peels with thick white pith attached, as pith adds unwanted bitter flavor.
Tips
2.Stir, never shake, your Old Fashioned: shaking agitates the ice too quickly, creating over-dilution and tiny air bubbles that cloud the crystal-clear spirit and leave a thin, harsh mouthfeel. Slow stirring for 25-30 seconds chills the drink evenly and produces a silky, smooth texture with ideal dilution.
3.Keep ice as cold as possible before use: ice that has started to melt and has a wet surface will dilute the cocktail too quickly before you even start stirring, leading to a watery, weak drink. Pull ice straight from the freezer right before adding it to the mixing glass.

OMG this maple old fashioned is SO good! I made these for my husband’s birthday dinner with friends last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe. Swapping the simple syrup for maple adds such a cozy, warm depth that regular old fashioneds just don’t have. Total game changer for fall cocktail nights!
Super easy to whip up even when I’m running behind for a get-together! I brought a batch of these to our neighborhood fall block party potluck and they went faster than the spiced apple cider. The maple cuts the sharp bite of the bourbon so nicely, even people who say they hate whiskey came back for seconds.
Really solid cocktail! I used rye instead of bourbon because that’s what I had on hand, and it paired amazingly with the maple. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish the recipe noted how big of an orange peel to express over the top — I used a really thick, pith-heavy twist first and it made the first sip a little too bitter for me. Still will absolutely make this again, it was so quick to throw together!
Made these for our weekly date night in and my partner said it’s better than the old fashioneds we get at our favorite downtown cocktail bar! We’re already planning to make these for our Thanksgiving pre-dinner drinks for the whole family. So simple but so fancy-tasting, I can’t get enough.
Total game changer! I’ve been making old fashioneds with sugar cubes for years and never thought to swap in maple syrup. This is my new go-to for after-work drinks when I don’t feel like putting in any effort but want something that tastes like it came from a fancy cocktail bar. 10/10, no notes.
SO good! I made these for my girls’ weekend cabin trip up north and everyone was raving. We sat around the fire pit sipping these after hiking all day and it was the coziest vibe ever. So easy to make even when you’re tired, no fancy shakers or tools required.