marie callender's pot pie air fryer
intro
Crispy, flaky golden crust wrapped around creamy, savory chicken and vegetable filling, cooked perfectly in the air fryer for fast, cozy, no-fuss comfort food.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat the Air Fryer
Remove any excess accessories from the 6-quart matte black air fryer basket, then preheat the appliance to 360°F (182°C) for 3 minutes. Do not add parchment paper or basket liners, as unobstructed hot air flow is required for an evenly crisp crust. Wait for the preheat cycle to fully complete before opening the basket.
Unwrap Frozen Pot Pies
Retrieve the two frozen pot pies from the freezer, and remove all outer cardboard packaging and clear plastic wrap. Do not thaw the pot pies at any point—cooking directly from frozen prevents a soggy bottom crust. Leave each pie in its original shallow aluminum baking tin, as this holds the creamy filling securely during cooking. Discard packaging in an off-frame bin.
Cut Crust Vent Slits
Use the 3.5-inch paring knife to cut 3 evenly spaced 1-inch slits across the top crust of each frozen pot pie. These vents allow built-up steam to escape during cooking, preventing the crust from bubbling, cracking unevenly, or leaking filling out the sealed crimp edges.
Spritz Crust for Crisp
Hold the clear glass oil mister 6 inches away from the top crust of each pot pie, and spritz a thin, even coating of canola oil across the entire crust surface. Use roughly 1/4 teaspoon of oil per pie—this light layer encourages a deep golden, shatteringly flaky crust without making it greasy. Avoid getting oil on the outside of the aluminum tins.
Add Foil Edge Shields
Fold each 4x12 inch aluminum foil strip into a 1-inch wide ring that fits snugly around the outer crimped edge of each pot pie. The foil should cover only the outermost 1/2 inch of crust, leaving the entire center top crust exposed. This shield prevents the thin crimped edge from burning before the center crust and filling finish cooking.
Air Fry First Stage
Use the silicone-tipped tongs to carefully place both foil-shielded pot pies in the preheated air fryer basket, leaving 1 inch of open space between the tins for unobstructed air circulation. Do not stack the pies. Cook at 360°F (182°C) for 25 minutes, keeping the basket closed for the full duration to maintain consistent internal temperature. Do not flip the pies during this stage.
Remove Foil Shields
After 25 minutes of cook time, carefully pull the air fryer basket out. Use the silicone-tipped tongs to gently lift the aluminum foil rings off the crust edges, taking care not to tear the partially set, pale golden crust. Set the used foil strips aside to discard later.
Finish Cooking Pies
Slide the air fryer basket back into the appliance, and continue cooking the pot pies at 360°F (182°C) for an additional 8-10 minutes, until the entire top crust is deep golden brown and flaky. There is no need to flip the pies. Add 1-2 minutes of cook time if your air fryer model runs cooler than average.
Check Internal Temperature
Once the final cook time elapses, pull the air fryer basket out. Insert the digital instant-read thermometer through one of the crust vents into the thickest center of the filling, taking care not to touch the hot bottom of the aluminum tin. The filling is fully cooked and safe to eat when it reaches an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C). If the temperature is lower, cook for 2 more minutes and retest.
Rest Before Serving
Use the silicone-tipped tongs to carefully lift the hot pot pies out of the air fryer basket, and transfer them to the clear counter space in front of the air fryer. Let the pies rest for 5 full minutes before cutting. This resting period allows the scalding creamy filling to set slightly, so it does not run out when cut, and reduces the risk of mouth burns from overly hot filling.
Plate and Garnish
Use the paring knife to cut each rested pot pie into two equal wedges. Slide the stainless steel slotted turner under one wedge, and transfer it to the waiting matte cream ceramic dinner plate at front center. Pluck a single small sprig of thyme from the potted plant on the back right counter, and place it on the crust edge as a simple garnish.
Tips
2.Do not skip the foil edge shields: The thin crimped outer crust cooks 10-12 minutes faster than the thicker center crust, and will turn dark and bitter if left unprotected for the full cook time.
3.Avoid opening the air fryer basket unnecessarily during cooking: Every time the basket is opened, hot air escapes and drops the internal temperature by 20-30°F, leading to uneven cooking and longer total cook time.

OMG this is such a game changer! I used to heat these up in the oven forever and the crust would always get soggy on the bottom, but 33 minutes in the air fryer? Perfectly flaky crust, the filling is bubbly all the way through, no cold spots! My kids devoured two of them last night for our quick weeknight dinner, will 100% be making this every time we grab these pot pies from the freezer section now.
Super easy recipe, worked almost perfectly for me! The only issue I had was the top crust got a little too dark around the edges at the 33 minute mark, so next time I’ll probably pull it 2 minutes early. Still way better than microwave or oven results, the filling was creamy and the chicken was tender, no weird frozen aftertaste at all.
Bro this saved my dorm dinner last night. I didn’t even know you could air fry frozen pot pies, I thought you had to have a whole oven. Crust was crispy, filling was hot all the way through, no sad soggy microwave mess. 10/10, no notes.
Made these for our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend, I cooked 4 of them back to back in the air fryer and everyone was asking how I got the crust so perfect! I told them it was just the air fryer trick from this recipe, nobody believed me how easy it was. Even my picky mother in law asked for seconds!
Wait, does this work for the gluten free version of Marie Callender’s pot pie too? I tried following the time and temp for the GF one I bought and the crust was a little burnt on top but the filling was still half frozen in the middle. Bummed because I was so excited for an easy GF dinner.
SO good. I was feeling super lazy on Sunday after hiking, didn’t want to put in any effort for dinner, tossed one of these in the air fryer while I showered and it was perfect when I got out. No prep, no mess, no waiting around for the oven. Crust was flaky, filling was hot, exactly the comfort food I needed.
I was skeptical an air fryer could cook a frozen pot pie right, I’ve been using my conventional oven for these for 20+ years. Tried it last night on a whim, and I’ll be darned if the crust wasn’t flakier than it ever was in the oven, and the filling didn’t boil over and make a mess all over my oven racks. Sold.
Game. Changer. My 7 year old has been obsessed with Marie Callender’s pot pies since he tried them at his grandma’s house, but I hated how long they took in the oven on school nights. 33 minutes in the air fryer, no preheat wait? We had dinner on the table before homework was even done last night, he ate every single bite and asked for another one tonight.
Great recipe! I will say, I have a smaller 2 quart air fryer and the pot pie sat a little close to the heating element, so the top got pretty crispy fast. I tented a little piece of foil over the top for the last 10 minutes and it turned out great, no burnt crust, perfect hot filling.
I’ve been craving pot pie for weeks but didn’t want to make one from scratch, this hack is perfect! The crust is so buttery and flaky, the veggies and chicken in the filling are perfectly cooked, no weird icy spots at all. Way better than I expected for a frozen meal in the air fryer.
Perfect for single people! I don’t love cooking huge meals just for myself, so having a quick 33 minute meal that actually tastes good, no leftovers to go bad in the fridge? Absolute win. The crust didn’t get soggy at all, the filling was hot all the way through, will be stocking my freezer with these for busy work nights.
First thing I ever cooked in my brand new air fryer! I was so nervous I’d mess it up, but I followed the directions exactly and it turned out so good. The only thing I messed up was I forgot to cut the little slits in the top crust like the package says, so a little bit of filling bubbled out onto the basket, but it was easy to wipe up. Still tasted amazing!
Made this as a midnight snack after my late shift at the hospital last night, it hit so different. I don’t have the energy to cook when I get home at 1am, so tossing one of these in the air fryer while I change out of my scrubs is the perfect low effort, delicious snack/dinner hybrid. Crust was perfect, no cold middle, 10/10.
This is such a great budget friendly meal! These pot pies go on sale for like $2 each at my grocery store all the time, and cooking them in the air fryer is cheaper than heating up my whole oven for one little pie. Tastes way better than takeout for a fraction of the price, perfect for when I’m trying to save money at the end of the month.
Finally! I’ve tried so many different time and temp combos for these pot pies in the air fryer and they always came out wrong—either burnt crust and cold middle, or soggy crust and overcooked filling. 33 minutes as written here is perfect, crispy flaky crust top to bottom, bubbly hot filling all the way through. No more guesswork for me!
I prepped a bunch of these for my work lunches this week! I cook one the night before, slice it up, toss it in a meal prep container, and it reheats in the office microwave so well. The crust even stays a little crispy, not the soggy mess I get when I cook it in the microwave from frozen. Total game changer for work lunches.
Made these for a casual at home date night with my girlfriend last week, we paired them with a little side salad and it was such a cute low key dinner. We both laughed because we thought frozen pot pies were too basic for date night, but they were so good we’re adding them to our regular rotation. Only con is my air fryer smelled like pot pie for 2 days after, but that’s a small price to pay.
Y’all, this is the easiest comfort food fix ever. I grew up eating Marie Callender’s pot pies after church on Sundays, and cooking them in the air fryer makes them taste just like I remember, even better than the oven if I’m being honest. The crust is so buttery and flaky, the filling is creamy and full of chicken and veggies, no complaints at all.
I was able to cook this while walking my dog last night! I set the air fryer, leashed up my pup, did a 25 minute walk around the neighborhood, came back and let it rest for 8 minutes, and it was perfect. No cold spots, no burnt crust, I didn’t even have to stand around the kitchen waiting for it to cook. Absolute win for busy pet parents.
If you’re like me and hate when the bottom of your pot pie crust is soggy and gross, run don’t walk to make this in the air fryer. The circulating air gets the bottom crust just as crispy as the top, no more sad mushy crust under the filling. I’ll never cook these in the oven or microwave again, this is the only method I’m using from now on.