Mary Pickford Cocktails
intro
A blushing pink vintage rum cocktail named for silent film star Mary Pickford, balanced with bright pineapple, sweet grenadine, and nutty maraschino, served ice-cold for smooth tropical sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill Coupe Glasses
Place both clear crystal coupe glasses in the freezer 10 minutes before preparing cocktails, or fill each to the rim with ice water while you prep ingredients to ensure they are frosty cold when pouring. Dump all ice water and wipe glass interiors dry with a corner of the linen towel right before straining the cocktail into the glasses. Chilled glasses prevent the drink from warming too quickly after pouring.
Prep Cocktail Garnishes
Set the honey-toned acacia wood cutting board in its fixed far-left position. Use the 3-inch paring knife to cut two 1cm-thick small wedges from the mini gold pineapple, cutting a small 5mm notch into the base of each wedge so it can rest securely on the glass rim. Skewer one maraschino cherry onto each bamboo cocktail pick pulled from the maple pick holder, then set both picks and pineapple wedges in the 6cm clear glass ramekin until ready to use.
Measure Liquid Ingredients
Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to accurately measure and pour 4oz white rum, 3oz pineapple juice, 0.5oz maraschino liqueur, and 0.5oz grenadine into the larger 750ml weighted shaker tin. Hold the jigger at eye level when pouring to ensure measurements are exact, as even small over-pours of grenadine or maraschino can throw off the drink's balanced sweet-tart flavor.
Add Ice to Shaker
Add 2 cups of crushed ice to the 750ml shaker tin with the measured liquids, filling the tin no more than 2/3 full to leave adequate room for aeration during shaking. Seat the smaller 500ml shaker tin on top of the larger tin at a slight angle, then tap the top firmly with the palm of your hand to create a tight, leak-proof seal.
Shake Cocktail Vigorously
Hold the sealed Boston shaker with one hand gripping the top tin and one hand gripping the weighted bottom tin, shaking hard and fast in a back-and-forth motion for 12-15 seconds. Stop shaking when the entire outside of the metal shaker feels frosty and covered in a thin layer of condensation to the touch — this visual and tactile cue confirms the cocktail is chilled to the ideal 4°C (40°F) serving temperature and properly diluted.
Double Strain Cocktail
Empty the ice water from both coupe glasses, wiping the inside of each dry with a corner of the linen towel. Tap the side of the sealed shaker firmly where the two tins meet to break the vacuum seal, then remove the top tin. Set the stainless steel Hawthorne strainer over the mouth of the separated shaker tin (holding the shaken cocktail and ice), then hold the fine-mesh conical strainer 2 inches above the first coupe glass. Pour the cocktail slowly through both strainers to catch all ice shards and fine pineapple pulp, dividing the pink liquid evenly between the two glasses, filling each to 3/4 capacity.
Garnish and Serve
Rest one cherry-topped bamboo pick across the rim of each coupe glass, then tuck one notched pineapple wedge against the pick on each rim, seating the notch firmly on the glass edge so the garnish does not fall into the drink. Serve immediately while the glasses are frosty cold, before the cocktail warms above 7°C (45°F).
Tips
2.Never skip the double straining step: crushed ice leaves tiny sharp shards and fresh pineapple juice leaves fine stringy pulp that will make the cocktail look cloudy and become watery as trapped ice melts, so the fine-mesh strainer guarantees a perfectly clear, silky smooth sipping experience.
3.Avoid over-pouring grenadine: it is easy to add too much of this thick, sweet pomegranate syrup, which will turn the cocktail a dark red instead of the signature soft blush pink and make it overly sweet; always measure grenadine with the jigger at eye level for accuracy.

OMG these Mary Pickfords are SO good! I whipped them up for my girls' retro movie night last weekend and everyone begged for the recipe. The pineapple and rum balance is chef’s kiss, no weird fancy ingredients needed either. Total game changer for my go-to happy hour rotation!
Made these for my 1920s themed book club potluck and they were the first thing gone! I was worried they’d be too sweet since I don’t love super sugary drinks, but the tart pineapple cuts it perfectly. So easy to shake up in bulk too, will absolutely make again.
Quick, cheap, and tastes way fancier than it has any right to be. I used the cheap white rum I had lying around my apartment and it still slapped. Great for when you don’t want to run to the liquor store for fancy mixers after a long week of classes.
Tried these for brunch yesterday instead of my usual mimosas and my whole table was obsessed! I garnished each with a little pineapple wedge and a cherry, looked so pretty on the table. Only bummer is I didn’t make a double batch, we ran out in 10 minutes flat.
My husband and I made these for our at-home date night last Friday and it felt like we were at a fancy downtown cocktail bar! We don’t have any fancy bar tools, just a regular mason jar to shake with, and they turned out perfect. 10/10, will be a regular in our date night rotation.
So happy this recipe is naturally vegan without any weird substitutions! I served these at my backyard plant-based potluck last weekend and even my friends who only drink beer were going back for seconds. The light pineapple flavor is perfect for hot summer evenings.
I’ve been making these for 40+ years and this recipe is spot on to the classic version I used to serve back in the 80s. A lot of modern recipes add way too much grenadine, but the ratio here is perfect, not cloyingly sweet. Great job on nailing the classic!
Made these for my pool party last Saturday and they were a total hit! I froze little pineapple chunks to use as ice so they didn’t get watered down as we sat in the sun. Absolute game changer for summer pool days, I already have all the ingredients stocked for this weekend.
Tried this last night and it was solid, but I added a tiny splash of lime juice to cut the sweetness a little more for my taste. Still super easy to make, great base recipe to tweak to your own preference. Would recommend to anyone just getting into making cocktails at home.
These are so dangerous! They go down way too easy, I had two before I even realized it. Perfect for my book club meeting this week, none of us are super heavy drinkers so the light, fruity flavor is exactly what we like. No bitter alcohol aftertaste at all.
Brought a batch of these to my neighbor’s BBQ over the weekend and everyone was asking where I got the recipe. I usually just bring beer to cookouts, but I wanted to switch it up and I’m so glad I did. Even the self-proclaimed “whiskey only” guys loved them.
Wait a zero-cook cocktail that only needs 4 ingredients? Sign me up! I spent way too much money on fancy craft cocktails on my last vacation, so being able to make these at home for a fraction of the cost is a total win. They taste exactly like the ones I had at the tiki bar in Hawaii!
Made these after the kids went to bed last night for my husband and I, and it was the perfect little wind-down treat. I didn’t have any fresh pineapple for garnish so I just used extra cherries, and it still tasted amazing. So quick to throw together when you only have 5 minutes of free time after bedtime!
I was super nervous to host my first happy hour for my coworkers last week, and these were so easy I didn’t stress at all about making drinks while greeting people. Everyone raved about them, and a couple people even asked for the recipe before they left. 10/10 for beginner home hosts!
Obsessed with how pretty these look! The soft pink color is so perfect for bridal showers, I’m definitely making these for my best friend’s shower next month. I did add a little extra grenadine for a deeper pink color, and it didn’t make them too sweet at all. SO good!