new fashioned drink
intro
A silky, balanced modern twist on the classic Old Fashioned, with warm bourbon, bright citrus depth, subtle maple sweetness, and rich brandied cherry garnish.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill the serving glass
Place the 2-inch clear spherical ice cube into the 10oz crystal lowball glass, then set the glass back in its fixed right-counter position to chill while you build the drink. Chilling the glass beforehand prevents rapid ice melt once the cocktail is poured, keeping dilution consistent. Let sit for 2 minutes while you prep remaining ingredients.
Add syrup and bitters
Retrieve the 16oz crystal mixing glass from the right floating shelf and place it in the center counter position. Use the matte black jigger to measure 0.25oz pure maple syrup into the mixing glass, then add 3 dashes of aromatic bitters directly to the syrup. Do not add ice at this stage, as ice will dilute the sweetener before it can fully integrate with the bourbon.
Muddle orange peel lightly
Use the matte black vegetable peeler to remove two 2-inch wide strips of orange peel from the whole navel orange, taking care to leave as much bitter white pith attached to the fruit as possible to avoid harsh flavor. Set one peel strip aside on the marble beside the mixing glass for garnish, place the other in the mixing glass on top of the syrup and bitters. Use the 8-inch oak muddler to gently press the peel into the syrup mixture 2-3 times, just enough to release bright citrus oils from the peel, not hard enough to tear the peel or mash any remaining pith. You will smell bright, fresh orange aroma when the oils are properly released.
Add measured bourbon
Use the matte black double jigger to measure exactly 2oz of bourbon whiskey, then pour it into the mixing glass on top of the muddled orange, syrup, and bitters. Set the jigger back in its fixed left position after pouring, wiping any small bourbon drips from the counter with the edge of the linen towel if needed.
Stir to chill and dilute
Retrieve the 4-inch clear glass prep bowl holding 3-4 large cocktail ice cubes from the floating shelf, and pour the ice into the mixing glass until it is 3/4 full. Hold the twisted handle of the stainless steel bar spoon, insert it into the mixing glass so the back of the spoon rests against the glass interior, and stir slowly and steadily for exactly 25 seconds in smooth circular motions. The outside of the mixing glass will feel frosty and cold to the touch when the drink is properly chilled, with ideal dilution (roughly 20% water added from gentle ice melt).
Strain into chilled glass
Place the fine-mesh stainless steel julep strainer over the top of the frosty mixing glass, holding it firmly in place with one index finger. Slowly pour the chilled cocktail through the strainer into the waiting 10oz lowball glass (which still holds the large clear ice sphere), straining out the muddled orange peel and used stirring ice cubes. Pour steadily at a slight angle to avoid splashing or creating bubbles in the drink.
Express orange peel oils
Pick up the reserved orange peel strip from beside the mixing glass, holding it about 2 inches above the surface of the poured drink, skin side facing down. Gently squeeze the peel between your thumb and forefinger to release a fine mist of citrus oil across the drink surface, then rub the peel lightly along the outer rim of the lowball glass. Rest the peel on the edge of the glass as a citrus garnish.
Add cherry and serve
Retrieve the gold cocktail pick holding three brandied cherries from the cream ceramic pin dish, and rest it across the rim of the lowball glass so the cherries hang slightly over the drink surface. Do not drop the cherries directly into the drink unless preferred. Give the glass a very gentle 1-second swirl to combine the citrus oils with the cocktail surface, then serve immediately.
Tips
2.Stir (never shake) this cocktail: shaking aerates bourbon, creating a cloudy, watery drink with a sharp, unbalanced texture, while 25 seconds of slow, steady stirring produces a silky, crystal-clear, perfectly chilled drink with controlled dilution.
3.Skip neon-red maraschino cherries for garnish: these candied, artificially flavored cherries clash with bourbon’s warm, oaky notes. Use jarred brandied cherries for a deep, tart-sweet flavor that complements the drink’s other components.

OMG this is SO good! I made these for our backyard potluck last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe. I swapped the regular simple syrup for maple because that’s what I had on hand and it was chef’s kiss. Way easier than I thought a fancy cocktail could be, zero cook time? Sign me up for every weekend happy hour from now on.
Game changer for my Friday night wind down. I’ve been making old fashioneds for years and was skeptical of a “new fashioned” but this hits so smooth. My wife loved it too, even said she prefers it over the classic I usually make. Will be adding this to our regular rotation for date nights in.
Super easy to throw together for my pre-game with roommates! Didn’t have any fancy bar tools, just stirred it in a mason jar with ice and it turned out perfect. Way cheaper than buying these at the bar downtown, I’ll be making these all semester.
Made this for my girls’ night last night and it was a total hit! Quick question though – can I make a big batch of this for a potluck I’m going to next weekend, or does it not hold up well pre-mixed?
Wait a cocktail with 0 cook time? That’s my kind of recipe! I don’t have a lot of time for fussy drinks after getting the kids to bed, so this is perfect for my little nightly treat. Tastes like something I’d pay $18 for at a downtown speakeasy, no joke.
Made this around the campfire last weekend, it was so easy to pack all the ingredients in my cooler. Everyone in our group was raving, even the people who say they don’t like whiskey. 10/10, will be bringing this on every camping trip from now on.
Tried this after my round on Saturday and wow, so smooth. I used bourbon I had sitting on the shelf from Christmas and it worked perfectly. Only thing I did different was add an extra dash of bitters because I love that deep flavor.
This is good, but I felt like it was missing a little something? I followed the recipe exactly, but it tasted a little too plain for me. Any ideas for a little extra kick to jazz it up?
Wait, dumb question – do I have to use rye for this, or can I use regular bourbon? I don’t keep a ton of different liquors at my apartment and I already have a bottle of bourbon I don’t want to waste.