New York Sour Cocktails
intro
A sophisticated classic American cocktail with a bold bourbon base, bright citrus, silky egg white froth, and a dramatic floating layer of dry red wine for balanced, rich flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Measure all ingredients
First, use the paring knife on the maple wood cutting board to cut two 5mm-thick lemon wheels from the whole lemons, set aside in the 10cm clear prep bowl. Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure 120ml bourbon, 60ml fresh lemon juice (squeezed with the handheld citrus juicer), 45ml simple syrup, and 30ml pasteurized egg white (separated first in the 8cm prep bowl to ensure no yolk is present), adding each directly into the matte black cocktail shaker. Do not add ice yet—this is for the initial dry shake. Set the measured 60ml red wine aside in a small glass measure near the wine bottle for the float step later.
Dry shake for froth
Seal the cocktail shaker tightly without any ice. Shake vigorously for 15 full seconds, holding both ends of the shaker firmly to prevent leaks. The dry shake (no ice) emulsifies the egg white, creating a thick, silky, pale froth that gives the drink its signature smooth, mousse-like texture. You will feel the mixture lighten and expand slightly inside the shaker as you shake.
Shake with ice to chill
Open the shaker, add two of the large square ice cubes to the frothy sour base. Reseal the shaker tightly, then shake vigorously for another 20 seconds, until the outside of the shaker feels frosty and ice-cold to the touch. This chills the drink to approximately 4C (40F), diluting it slightly to balance the strong bourbon and bright tart citrus. Reserve the remaining two ice cubes for serving.
Strain into rocks glasses
Place one reserved large fresh square ice cube into each of the two thick-walled crystal rocks glasses. Fit the Hawthorne strainer tightly over the opening of the cocktail shaker, then pour the chilled, frothy whiskey sour base evenly between the two glasses, filling each about 3/4 full. The used shaking ice will remain caught in the strainer, leaving a smooth, frothy pale amber liquid in each glass topped with a thin layer of white egg froth.
Float red wine layer
This is the signature step that defines a New York Sour. Hold the twisted long-handled bar spoon upside down over the first glass, so the flat disc end of the spoon sits just 1cm above the surface of the frothy sour base. Slowly pour 30ml of red wine over the back of the spoon, letting it spread gently across the top of the drink rather than sinking and mixing. Repeat for the second glass. When poured correctly, a sharp, distinct deep crimson layer will form on top of the pale amber sour, with no blending between the two liquids.
Add garnish and serve
Perch one thin lemon wheel on the rim of each glass. Tuck a small fresh thyme sprig against the ice if using, for a subtle earthy aromatic note. Let the drinks rest for 30 seconds to let the froth settle slightly between the sour and wine layer, then serve immediately while ice-cold.
Tips
2.Pour the red wine as slowly as possible over the back of the bar spoon, holding the spoon just 1cm above the drink surface: pouring too fast will cause the wine to sink and mix into the sour base, ruining the sharp, dramatic two-tone layer that defines a New York Sour.
3.Use large, dense clear ice cubes instead of crushed or small cubed ice: large ice melts 50% slower, preventing the drink from becoming over-diluted and watery before you finish it, and the clear cubes look more elegant in the crystal rocks glasses.

OMG I made these for my girls' night last weekend and everyone went absolutely feral for them! The red wine float was so much prettier than I expected, even for a first try. SO good, already added this to my regular happy hour rotation.
Tried these last night for date night with my partner, and honestly? Total game changer. I was worried the medium difficulty meant I'd mess it up, but the instructions were so clear. Only note: I used a cabernet sauvignon for the float and it worked perfectly.
I've been making New York Sours for years and this recipe is easily the best ratio I've ever tried. Not too sweet, not too tart, the egg white gives it that perfect silky froth. 10/10.
Wait a second, cook time is 0 minutes? Do you not even need to make simple syrup for this? I thought that was a staple for sours. Confused because I don't want to skip a step and mess these up for my poker night this weekend.
Made these for our backyard BBQ last weekend and even my bourbon-obsessed brother said it's the best cocktail he's ever had. I did mess up the float on the first two, but by the third I had the technique down. Will definitely make again!
Is there a non-alcoholic swap for this? I'm sober curious but love the flavor profile of sours, and I want to make something I can enjoy along with my friends at our next game night.
I work at a cocktail bar in Williamsburg and this is almost exactly the house sour recipe we use. The ratio of lemon to bourbon to simple is spot on, guests always rave about it. Great recipe for home bartenders!
Tried this last night and the egg white totally freaked me out at first? I've never used raw egg in a cocktail before, I was worried it would be weird or unsafe. But it gave it that perfect foamy top! Game changer, no more skipping egg white in sours for me.
Made these for our apres-ski get together last month and they were gone in 20 minutes flat. Everyone kept asking where I got the recipe, I had to send the link to like 8 people. Only thing I changed was adding a tiny dash of cinnamon on top, chef's kiss.
Wait, has anyone tried making these ahead for a party? I'm hosting a potluck this Saturday and don't want to be stuck shaking cocktails all night when guests show up. Would they hold up if I pre-batched the base?
I'm usually a margarita girl but I wanted to switch things up for taco night last week and these were unreal. Who knew bourbon and red wine went so well with spicy tacos? My husband is already begging me to make them again this week.
This recipe is so solid, but I had a little trouble getting the wine to float even when I poured it over a spoon. Did I pour too fast? Is my wine too heavy? I used a really bold zinfandel, maybe that's the issue?
Made these for my wife's birthday dinner and she said it felt like we were at a fancy NYC steakhouse. The only fail was that I forgot to buy lemons so I used bottled lemon juice, and it was still good, but I bet fresh is way better.
I brought these to my office holiday happy hour back in December and even my boss who only drinks beer asked for the recipe. So easy to tweak to taste too, I add a little extra lemon because I love tart drinks. Obsessed.
Wait, is there a way to make this without egg white? I have an egg allergy so I can't do the traditional froth, but I've been dying to try a New York Sour forever. I don't want to miss out!