Old Fashioned
intro
The iconic slow-sipped American whiskey cocktail, balanced with warm sugar, aromatic bitters, and bright citrus—smooth, rich, and perfectly timeless for quiet, cozy evenings.
Ingredients
Steps
Muddle Sugar Base
Place the single sugar cube into the bottom of the 500ml clear glass mixing beaker. Dash 3 full shakes of aromatic bitters directly onto the sugar cube, then pour in 1 teaspoon of filtered room-temperature water. Hold the natural maple muddler straight up and down, pressing gently and twisting to crush the sugar cube into a thick, evenly damp paste with no large gritty chunks remaining, about 15 seconds of gentle muddling. Do not over-muddle or scrape hard against the glass bottom to avoid chipping the beaker.
Pour Bourbon Into Mixer
Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure exactly 2 oz of bourbon whiskey, pouring it directly over the muddled sugar paste in the mixing beaker. Give the mixture a single gentle stir with the twisted bar spoon to initially combine the sugar and bourbon before adding ice.
Stir With Ice
Add 3 large ice cubes to the mixing beaker with the bourbon and sugar mixture. Hold the twisted bar spoon vertically, stirring the mixture slowly and smoothly in a constant circular motion around the inside edge of the beaker for exactly 20 seconds. The liquid should feel noticeably cold to the touch on the outside of the beaker, diluting to roughly 20% added water content for a smooth, not watery, finish. Do not shake, as this will cloud the whiskey and create a harsh, aerated texture.
Chill Serving Glass
While the mixture rests for 5 seconds after stirring, place the single large spherical ice cube into the 10oz heavy-based lowball glass. Swirl the ice around the inside of the glass for 10 seconds to chill the glass walls completely, then pour out any small amounts of melted ice water from the glass before straining.
Strain Cocktail Into Glass
Place the matte black Hawthorne strainer firmly over the top of the mixing beaker, holding it tight with your index finger. Pour the chilled, diluted bourbon mixture slowly through the strainer directly over the spherical ice cube in the lowball glass, leaving 1cm of space at the top of the glass to avoid spills.
Cut Citrus Twist
Use the stainless steel channel knife to cut a single 2cm wide, 5cm long strip of orange peel from the whole navel orange, avoiding cutting too deep into the bitter white pith under the colored orange zest. Set the peel aside temporarily, leaving the whole orange with a neat shallow cut mark on its surface.
Express Orange Oil
Hold the cut orange peel between your thumb and forefinger, with the colored outer side facing down toward the drink surface, 5cm above the drink. Squeeze firmly to bend the peel and release a fine mist of bright citrus oil directly over the drink surface. Lightly rub the peel along the outer rim of the lowball glass, then drape one end of the peel over the edge of the glass as garnish. Do not drop the entire peel into the drink unless preferred.
Add Final Garnish
Skewer one single brandied cherry on the 12cm bamboo cocktail pick, then rest the pick across the top of the lowball glass so the cherry sits just above the ice, not fully submerged in the drink. Give the drink one single slow stir with the bar spoon to combine the citrus oil with the bourbon before serving.
Tips
2.Avoid cutting deep into the white pith when prepping your orange twist: The pith has a harsh, unpleasantly bitter flavor that will overpower the bright, sweet citrus aroma; only the thin colored outer zest contains the fragrant oils that elevate the drink.
3.Use large, dense ice for both mixing and serving: Large ice melts 2-3 times slower than small crushed or standard fridge tray ice cubes, keeping your drink perfectly cold without watering it down before you finish sipping, preserving balanced flavor from first sip to last.

OMG this is the perfect Old Fashioned recipe! I’ve messed up so many batches before that were either too sweet or too bitter, but this ratio is chef’s kiss. Made it for my girls’ night last weekend and everyone asked for the recipe. SO good, will be my go-to from now on!
Super easy to throw together after a long work day! I didn’t have any fancy luxardo cherries so I used the maraschino ones I had in the pantry, and it still turned out great. My wife said it’s better than the one we get at our local steakhouse. Win for dad!
Took this to our neighborhood potluck last Saturday and the cocktail station was empty in 20 minutes! Who knew such a simple drink could be such a crowd pleaser? I pre-mixed a big batch ahead of time and it saved me so much time during the party. Game changer for hosting!
First time ever making an Old Fashioned and I was so nervous I’d mess it up! This recipe was so straightforward, I didn’t even need any fancy tools. I did accidentally add a tiny extra splash of bitters but it still tasted amazing. Any tips for making this for a big group?
I’ve been making Old Fashioneds for 40+ years and let me tell you, this is the classic ratio I remember from my favorite bar back in the 70s. No weird frills, no added fruit muddled to mush, just pure, smooth perfection. My grandkids even asked for a (non-alcoholic) taste they thought it smelled so good!
Tried this last night at my dinner party and paired it with smoked ribs and mac and cheese — *chef’s kiss*. The slight sweetness from the simple syrup cuts right through the rich, smoky meat perfectly. 10/10, will be making this again for our next cookout.
I swapped the regular simple syrup for maple syrup on a whim and oh my gosh, it’s such a cozy fall twist! Perfect for sipping on the porch while the leaves change. Would definitely recommend trying that variation if you have maple syrup on hand.
Made this for my date night last night and my partner said it was the best cocktail they’ve ever had! I was worried I didn’t have the right bourbon (I used a mid-shelf bottle I had lying around) but it still tasted incredible. Do you guys think rye works as a substitute here?
Hosted a trivia night with friends last night and made a big batch of these for everyone. I thought for sure I’d have leftovers, but every last drop was gone! One friend said she never liked Old Fashioneds before because they were too strong, but she had three of these last night. Total win!
I’m usually a fruity cocktail girl, but I wanted to try something a little more classic for my husband’s birthday dinner. This was so easy to make and I actually loved it! Not too sweet, super smooth, the orange twist adds such a nice bright note. My husband said he feels like he’s at a fancy speakeasy now when he gets home from work 😂
Quick question — I don’t have any granulated sugar to make simple syrup, can I use a sugar cube instead? I’ve seen old movies where they muddle a sugar cube with bitters, but I wasn’t sure if that works as well as simple syrup.