Old-Fashioned Donuts
intro
Crisp cracked edges, tender cakey crumb, and sweet vanilla glaze make these nostalgic old-fashioned donuts a timeless, beloved American diner treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix the donut dough
In a large mixing bowl, whisk together 315g (2 ½ cups) all-purpose flour, 2 tsp baking powder, ½ tsp baking soda, 1 tsp fine sea salt, ½ tsp ground nutmeg, and ¼ tsp ground cinnamon until fully combined. In a separate medium bowl, whisk 1 room-temperature large egg (50g) with 100g (½ cup) granulated sugar until smooth, then stir in 180g (¾ cup) full-fat sour cream, 28g (2 tbsp) cooled melted unsalted butter, and 1 tsp vanilla extract. Pour the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients, and stir with a rubber spatula just until no dry flour remains—do not overmix, as this will create tough donuts. The finished dough will be thick and slightly sticky.
Roll and cut donuts
Lightly dust a clean work surface with flour, then turn the sticky dough out onto it. Pat or roll the dough to a uniform ½-inch thickness, adding only a tiny extra dusting of flour if the dough sticks to your rolling pin. Use a 3-inch round donut cutter (or a 3-inch biscuit cutter paired with a 1-inch round cutter for the center hole) to cut donuts, pressing straight down without twisting to ensure even rising. Gather scraps, re-roll once, and cut remaining shapes to yield 10-12 donuts plus small donut holes. Set cut donuts on a parchment-lined tray while heating oil.
Heat frying oil
Pour 1L (4 cups) of canola or peanut oil into a heavy-bottomed Dutch oven or deep fryer, and heat over medium heat until the oil reaches a steady 365°F (185°C), measured with a clip-on candy thermometer. Adjust stovetop heat as needed to hold this temperature for the entire frying process: oil that is too hot burns donut exteriors before interiors cook, while too-cool oil creates greasy, soggy donuts.
Fry the donuts
Carefully lower 2-3 donuts into the hot oil at a time, taking care not to overcrowd the pot (this drops oil temperature rapidly). Fry for 90 seconds on the first side, until the bottom is deep golden brown with the signature cracked, crisp edges of old-fashioned donuts, then use a slotted spider strainer to flip each donut, and fry for 75 seconds on the second side. Transfer cooked donuts to a wire rack set over a baking sheet to drain excess oil for 2 minutes. Fry donut holes for 45 seconds per side until golden all over.
Make vanilla glaze
While donuts drain and cool slightly, prepare the glaze in a shallow wide bowl: whisk together 240g (2 cups) powdered sugar, 45ml (3 tbsp) whole milk, and ½ tsp vanilla extract until completely smooth with no lumps. Adjust consistency as needed: add 1 extra teaspoon of milk if the glaze is too thick to dip, or 1 extra tablespoon of powdered sugar if it is too thin and runs off donuts immediately.
Glaze and set donuts
Once donuts are cool enough to handle (about 2 minutes after frying), dip each donut into the glaze to coat both sides (or just the top for a thinner coating). Lift the donut out, hold it above the bowl for 5 seconds to let excess glaze drip off, then place it back on the wire rack. Let the glaze set for 10 minutes at room temperature, until the coating is dry to the touch and slightly crisp, before serving.
Tips
2.Monitor oil temperature closely with a clip-on candy thermometer; if oil drops below 350°F or rises above 375°F, adjust heat immediately to avoid greasy or burnt donuts.
3.Wait 2 minutes after frying to glaze donuts: donuts that are too hot will melt the glaze, causing it to slide off instead of setting into a crisp, sweet coating.

OMG these old-fashioned donuts taste exactly like the ones my grandma used to make when I was a kid! The crispy, slightly spiced outside, that soft dense cakey inside, the sweet vanilla glaze? *Chef’s kiss* My kids devoured half the batch before I even finished glazing the last one. Total game changer for slow weekend breakfasts!
These were SO good! I swapped in a 1:1 gluten free all purpose flour for regular since I have Celiac, and they still came out fluffy and delicious, no weird gritty texture. Only note is I had to fry mine a full minute longer per side than the recipe said to make sure the center wasn’t doughy. Will absolutely make again for our next family brunch!
Made these for my son’s soccer team snack this weekend and the parents were asking for the recipe left and right! I skipped the glaze on half and tossed them in a cinnamon-sugar mix instead, and both versions were a massive hit. Total cook time was spot on for me, right around 50 minutes start to finish even with my kids “helping” sprinkle extra topping everywhere.
Wait, has anyone tried baking these instead of frying? I don’t have a deep fryer and I’m nervous about heating up a pot of oil on my stovetop, lol. The flavor sounds incredible but I don’t want to start a kitchen fire!
These donuts are better than the ones I get at my local fancy donut shop, no cap. I added a tiny bit of nutmeg to the glaze like my mom used to do and it elevated the whole thing so much. Had one with my morning coffee today and it made my whole commute feel less terrible.
I was intimidated because the recipe says medium difficulty, but as someone who’s only been baking for 6 months, these were totally doable! The instructions were super clear, I didn’t have any confusing steps. My roommates are already begging me to make another batch this weekend.
Brought these to my neighborhood block party last weekend and people were lined up for seconds! I cut the donut holes out and fried those too, tossed them in powdered sugar, and the kids went absolutely feral for them. 10/10, will be adding this to my regular rotation for every gathering.
Ugh, my first batch came out super greasy! I think my oil was too cold? They tasted fine but were so oily I had to pat them down with, like, 5 paper towels each. Anyone else run into this issue?
I made a double batch of these on Sunday to have for quick breakfasts all week, and they held up so well! I stored them in an airtight container on the counter and they were still soft and tasty 4 days later. Way better than the store bought donuts that get stale after 1 day.
Made these for a date night in with my partner last night and they were obsessed! We did a little donut glazing station with sprinkles, chocolate drizzle, and crushed peanuts, it was so fun. Way more memorable than just going out for dessert, will definitely do this again.
The nutmeg in the donut batter is such a perfect touch! I was worried it would be too overpowering but it just gives that warm, cozy old-fashioned flavor I remember from donut runs as a kid. 10/10 recipe, no notes.
Has anyone tried making these dairy free? My kid has a milk allergy and I’ve been searching for a good old-fashioned donut recipe we can all enjoy without needing special store bought treats.
Okay, I’m not gonna lie, I messed up the first two donuts because I rolled the dough too thin, but once I got the hang of it these were incredible. The recipe says medium difficulty and that feels fair, you definitely need to pay attention to dough thickness and oil temp, but the payoff is so worth it.
I swapped the vanilla glaze for a maple glaze with a tiny bit of maple extract and a sprinkle of bacon bits on top, and oh my GOD it was the best decision I’ve made all month. Salty sweet perfection, 10/10 will be making that version again and again.
I’ve been making old-fashioned donuts for 60 years and this recipe is almost identical to the one I got from my own mother back in the 60s! The balance of sugar and spice is perfect, no weird fancy add-ins, just straight up classic donut shop flavor.
Has anyone tested these in an air fryer? I use mine for everything and I’m curious if they’d turn out as good as fried, I hate how my whole house smells like oil for days after frying on the stovetop.
I work at a small town bakery and I tested this recipe at home before bringing it in to see if we could add it to our menu, and my boss immediately said we need to sell these! The flavor is exactly what our regular customers ask for when they say they want a “real old-fashioned donut.”
Brought these in for my team meeting this morning and not a single donut was left. Even our intern who says he “doesn’t like sweets” ate two. The glaze sets perfectly so you don’t get sticky fingers while you’re typing at your desk, which is a huge win for office snacks.
I accidentally added a little too much buttermilk to the batter so it was stickier than it should have been, so I just added a couple extra tablespoons of flour and they still came out amazing! Don’t stress if your batter isn’t perfect, these are super forgiving even if you mess up measurements a little. SO good warm with a cold glass of milk.