old fashioned lemon pudding cake
intro
A nostalgic two-layer treat: light, tangy lemon sponge floats atop silky, bright curd-like pudding, baked in one dish for a cozy, low-effort old-fashioned dessert.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Baking Setup
Preheat oven to 175°C (350°F). Use 1 tsp of the softened unsalted butter to grease the interior of the 8-inch square matte white ceramic baking dish, coating the bottom and 1 inch up the sides evenly to prevent sticking. Set the greased dish inside the high-sided stainless steel roasting pan (to hold the water bath later) and place the assembly at right center on the counter.
Zest and Juice Lemons
Hold the fine-mesh stainless steel zester against each whole lemon, pulling it across the rind to collect the bright yellow outer zest, taking care not to grate the bitter white pith underneath; you will need approximately 1 tbsp of packed zest. Cut the zested lemons in half, and use the vintage brass lemon reamer to squeeze 80ml (1/3 cup) of fresh lemon juice into the small glass mixing bowl, straining out any seeds by pouring the juice through the zester. Set zest and juice aside.
Cream Butter and Sugar
Place the remaining softened butter and measured granulated sugar in the medium glass mixing bowl. Use the matte stainless steel hand whisk to cream the butter and sugar together for 2 minutes, until the mixture is pale, fluffy, and light lemon-yellow with no visible lumps of butter. Stir in the collected lemon zest and 1/4 tsp fine table salt, mixing until evenly distributed.
Mix Thin Batter Base
Crack the 3 eggs one at a time, separating them so the yolks go directly into the creamed butter-sugar mixture, and the whites go into the completely clean, dry large glass mixing bowl (set aside for whipping). Whisk the egg yolks into the butter mixture until completely smooth, then alternate adding small amounts of all-purpose flour and whole milk, whisking constantly to avoid lumps. Once all flour and milk are incorporated, stir in the strained lemon juice; the finished base will be thin, smooth, and pourable.
Whip Egg Whites
Use the clean, dry stainless steel hand whisk to beat the reserved egg whites in the large glass mixing bowl for 3-4 minutes, until they hold stiff, glossy peaks: when you lift the whisk straight up out of the whites, the peak should stand straight up without flopping over. Do not over-whip, as this will cause dry, clumpy whites that will not fold smoothly into the batter.
Fold Whites Into Batter
Add one third of the beaten egg whites to the thin lemon batter, using the pale yellow silicone spatula to stir vigorously to lighten the dense batter. Add the remaining egg whites in two equal batches, folding gently by cutting down through the center of the batter, scraping across the bowl bottom, and folding the mixture over the top, just until no large streaks of white remain. Do not over-mix, as this will deflate the air bubbles that create the light floating cake layer.
Bake in Water Bath
Pour the finished frothy batter evenly into the greased 8-inch ceramic baking dish. Carefully pour hot tap water into the outer stainless steel roasting pan until the water comes halfway up the sides of the baking dish, creating a gentle, even heat water bath. Transfer the whole pan assembly to the preheated oven, and bake for 35-40 minutes until the top is golden brown and set, with a slight soft jiggle in the center when nudged; the silky pudding layer will form underneath the cake as it bakes.
Rest and Plate
Carefully remove the roasting pan from the oven, lift the baking dish out of the hot water, and set it on the chrome wire cooling rack to rest for 10 minutes (the dessert is best served warm, not piping hot). Scoop generous portions into the fluted white ceramic dessert bowls, dust lightly with powdered sugar, and garnish with a twist of lemon zest and a small mint sprig.
Tips
2.Do not skip the water bath: the gentle, moist, even heat from the surrounding hot water cooks the pudding layer slowly without curdling the eggs, and prevents the cake top from browning too quickly before the center has a chance to set into silky pudding.
3.Avoid over-folding the egg whites into the batter: a few faint streaks of white remaining in the batter is preferable to over-mixing, which deflates the trapped air bubbles that allow the light cake layer to separate and float above the pudding as it bakes.

OMG this lemon pudding cake was the star of our Sunday family dinner! I was nervous it would be too fussy since I’m not a huge baker, but the easy difficulty rating was no lie — took me 40 minutes total even with my toddler hanging on my leg the whole time. The cake layer is so light and the tangy lemon pudding underneath? *Chef’s kiss* My kids begged for second helpings before they even finished their first slice. I brought it to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and everyone was hounding me for the recipe!
So so good! I added a tiny extra splash of lemon zest because I love super tart lemon desserts, and it came out perfectly. The magic layer thing where it separates into cake and pudding while baking? Total game changer, I felt like a professional baker pulling this out of the oven. Only thing I’ll note is my 9x9 pan was a little deep so I added 5 extra minutes of cook time, came out perfect!
Made this last night for my roommates when we had a random weeknight movie night, and everyone lost their minds. It’s so easy even with my terrible tiny apartment oven that burns everything, and I already had almost all the ingredients in my pantry except fresh lemons. Only reason it’s not a 5 is I forgot to dust a little powdered sugar on top like the recipe suggested, so it looked a little plain, but taste was 10/10. Will be making this on repeat all summer when it’s too hot to make heavy cookies or brownies.
I’ve been making a version of this lemon pudding cake for 40 years, and this recipe is even better than my old handwritten one! The ratio of lemon to sugar is spot on, not too sweet, not too puckery. My granddaughter is home from college and ate three servings after her soccer practice yesterday. Perfect easy dessert for when you don’t want to run to the store for fancy ingredients.
Took this on our weekend day trip to the canyon last weekend, kept it in the cooler and it was such a refreshing treat after being out in the sun. I topped each slice with a little dollop of whipped cream and a few fresh blueberries, *chef’s kiss*. Only complaint is I wish I made a double batch because it was gone in 10 minutes between me and my three hiking buddies.