old fashioned shrimp salad
intro
Creamy, bright, and deeply nostalgic, this classic chilled shrimp salad features tender poached shrimp, crisp celery, and fresh dill in a tangy mayo dressing, perfect for summer gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Poach the Shrimp
Fill the 3-quart brushed stainless steel saucepan with 6 cups of cold water, add 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt and 1 teaspoon whole black peppercorns, and bring to a gentle rolling boil over medium heat. Add the raw peeled, deveined shrimp, reduce heat to low, and poach for exactly 2-3 minutes until shrimp turn opaque pale pink and curl into a loose 'C' shape. Do not overcook: tightly curled 'O' shaped shrimp indicate overcooking and will be tough. Immediately remove shrimp from the water using the off-white silicone slotted spoon and transfer to the fine-mesh stainless steel colander to drain.
Chill Cooked Shrimp
Move the colander of hot drained shrimp to the sink, and run cold tap water over the shrimp for 2 full minutes to shock them and stop the cooking process completely. Pat the shrimp very dry with clean paper towels to remove all surface moisture, then transfer to a small plate, cover loosely, and chill in the refrigerator for 20 minutes until completely cold to the touch. Warm shrimp will melt mayonnaise and result in a soggy, separated dressing.
Prep Aromatic Vegetables
Return the light maple wood cutting board to its fixed center-left position. Use the 6-inch maple-handled chef's knife to finely dice celery into uniform 1/4-inch pieces, thinly slice red onion into delicate strips, chop fresh dill fronds (discard thick, woody stems), and zest the lemon before squeezing to collect 2 tablespoons of fresh juice. Transfer all prepped vegetables, herbs, lemon zest, and juice to the 1L clear glass mixing bowl.
Mix Creamy Dressing
Add 2/3 cup full-fat mayonnaise, 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard, the remaining 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt, and 1/4 teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper (ground from the oak pepper mill) to the prepped vegetables in the clear glass mixing bowl. Stir thoroughly with the off-white silicone spatula until the mixture is a smooth, pale creamy yellow, with celery, dill, and lemon zest evenly distributed throughout.
Combine Shrimp and Dressing
Remove the fully chilled shrimp from the refrigerator. Cut any extra-large shrimp into 1-inch bite-sized pieces, leaving medium shrimp whole. Add the cold, dry shrimp to the dressing mixture in the mixing bowl, along with the sliced red onion, and fold very gently with the silicone spatula until every shrimp is evenly coated in dressing. Take care not to mash or break the tender shrimp pieces during mixing.
Chill to Meld Flavors
Cover the mixing bowl tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for a minimum of 30 minutes (up to 24 hours for make-ahead prep) to allow flavors to meld. During this rest, the lemon and salt will slightly soften the onion and celery, and the dressing will absorb the bright dill and sweet shrimp flavor for a more cohesive, balanced taste.
Plate and Serve Salad
Remove the chilled shrimp salad from the refrigerator and give it one gentle stir to redistribute any dressing that settled at the bottom of the bowl. Arrange one large butter lettuce leaf on each matte cream white ceramic salad plate, then scoop 1/4 of the shrimp salad onto the center of each lettuce leaf. Garnish with a small fresh dill sprig, a light crack of black pepper, and a thin lemon wedge on the plate rim. Serve immediately while cold.
Tips
2.Use full-fat mayonnaise for authentic flavor and texture: low-fat or light mayonnaise often contains added stabilizers and starches that become gummy when chilled, and lacks the smooth, rich mouthfeel that defines classic old fashioned shrimp salad.
3.Do not skip the post-mixing chill time: letting the salad rest in the fridge for 30 minutes allows the bright dill, lemon, and celery flavors to infuse into the dressing and shrimp, rather than tasting like separate ingredients tossed together right before serving.

OMG this old fashioned shrimp salad is SO good! I brought it to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and every single person asked for the recipe! The 5 minute cook time is no joke, I threw it together right before running out the door and it tasted like I spent hours prepping. My kids even asked for seconds, which is basically a miracle with how picky they are lately.
Solid shrimp salad recipe! Super easy to throw together after a long day fishing on the boat. I added a little extra Old Bay because I like that extra zing, and tossed in a handful of diced avocado too. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish it had a little more tang out of the gate, but that’s an easy fix with a squeeze more lemon.
Total game changer for my weekly meal prep! I make a batch on Sunday and eat it for lunch all week on top of greens, between crackers, even stuffed in avocado halves. It holds up so much better than the store-bought shrimp salad that gets all soggy after a day. The easy difficulty rating is 100% accurate, even someone who burns toast could make this.
Made this for our Father’s Day family dinner and everyone raved! I was worried it would be too fancy for my meat-and-potatoes crew, but nope — my 82 year old dad said it tasted exactly like the shrimp salad his mom used to make when he was a kid. Total nostalgia win, will be making this all summer long for cookouts.
Dude, as a college kid with basically zero cooking skills, this was a breeze. 5 minutes cook time? No fancy ingredients? I made this for my roommates and they thought I ordered it from that fancy seafood place downtown. 10/10, will be making this every time I need to impress someone without putting in actual work.
Finally! A shrimp salad recipe that doesn’t have weird add-ins like grapes or raisins (who thought that was a good idea??). This is the classic, old fashioned version I’ve been searching for forever. I served it on buttery croissants for my book club luncheon and all the ladies were begging for the recipe link.
I’ve been making shrimp salad for over 50 years and this recipe is exactly the classic version everyone should have in their recipe box. No frills, no weird trendy ingredients, just perfectly balanced creaminess, crunch from the celery, and tender shrimp. I make a batch every other week to keep in the fridge for quick lunches, and it never disappoints.
Really tasty base recipe! I used frozen pre-cooked shrimp to save even more time, which worked great, but I felt like the dressing needed a little something extra for my taste. Ended up adding a spoonful of fresh dill and a pinch of smoked paprika, and that made it perfect for me. Will definitely make again with those little tweaks.