Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie
intro
Silky, warmly spiced old-fashioned sweet potato pie with a flaky buttery crust, the nostalgic Southern staple that brings cozy, rich flavor to every autumn holiday table.
Ingredients
Steps
Roast Sweet Potatoes
Preheat oven to 400°F (200°C). Scrub sweet potatoes under cool water, pat dry, and prick skins all over 8-10 times with a fork to prevent bursting. Place directly on the middle oven rack and roast for 45-50 minutes, until flesh is completely tender when pierced with a paring knife; skins will be slightly wrinkled with small spots of caramelized juice seeping out. Remove from oven and let cool 15 minutes until safe to handle.
Make Buttery Pie Crust
While sweet potatoes cool, add 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour and 1/4 tsp fine sea salt to the medium stainless steel mixing bowl. Cut 6 tbsp of the cold unsalted butter into 1/2-inch cubes, add to the flour. Use the stainless steel pastry blender to cut butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs with distinct pea-sized butter pieces remaining. Drizzle in 3-4 tbsp ice water, 1 tbsp at a time, tossing gently with the silicone spatula until dough just clumps together (do not overmix, as this creates tough crust). Form dough into a 4-inch disk, chill 10 minutes, then roll to a 12-inch circle on a lightly floured surface. Gently lay the rolled dough into the aluminum pie dish, press firmly against the bottom and fluted sides, trim excess overhang to 1 inch, and crimp edges decoratively.
Scoop and Mash Flesh
Once sweet potatoes are cool enough to handle, slice them in half lengthwise on the acacia cutting board. Use the stainless steel teaspoon to scoop all soft orange flesh away from the skins into the large stainless steel mixing bowl, discarding the skins. Use the wire potato masher to mash the sweet potato flesh until completely smooth, pressing out any stringy fibers; you should have approximately 2 cups of smooth, lump-free mashed sweet potato.
Mix Filling Ingredients
Add 2 tbsp melted unsalted butter, packed light brown sugar, granulated sugar, remaining 1/4 tsp sea salt, ground cinnamon, and 1/2 tsp freshly grated nutmeg (grated on the box grater) to the smooth mashed sweet potato. Stir with the silicone spatula until fully combined. Crack in 2 large eggs, one at a time, stirring thoroughly after each addition to avoid curdling, then stir in evaporated milk and pure vanilla extract. Mix until the filling is completely silky, uniform deep orange, and free of streaks of spice or egg.
Assemble and Bake Pie
Place the crust-lined aluminum pie dish on the rimmed aluminum baking sheet to catch any spills during baking. Pour the smooth sweet potato filling directly into the unbaked crust, spreading gently with the silicone spatula to create a level top. Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 55-60 minutes, until the outer 2 inches of filling are fully set and the center 2 inches jiggles slightly like firm Jell-O. If crust edges brown too quickly after 30 minutes of baking, tent with a narrow strip of aluminum foil to prevent burning.
Cool Pie Completely
Once baked, carefully remove the pie from the oven using the quilted oven mitts, and transfer it to the matte black wire cooling rack set on the counter. Let the pie cool completely at room temperature for 2 full hours before slicing; the slightly jiggly center will set fully as it cools, and cutting early will result in a runny filling.
Plate and Garnish Pie
Once fully cooled, transfer the pie from the aluminum baking dish to the matte cream ceramic pie serving plate. Dust the top lightly with a pinch of extra freshly grated nutmeg for aroma and visual appeal. Slice into 8 equal wedges, and serve with an optional dollop of softly whipped cream, using the vintage brass pie server.
Tips
2.Keep butter ice cold for the crust: Cold butter creates small steam pockets as it melts during baking, producing light, flaky layers; room temperature butter melts too fast, resulting in a tough, dense crust.
3.Avoid overbaking the filling: The center 2 inches should jiggle slightly when removed from the oven, as residual heat will set it as it cools; overbaking causes unsightly surface cracks and a dry, grainy texture.

OMG this old fashioned sweet potato pie is EXACTLY what my grandma used to make! I brought it to our family Sunday dinner and everyone went back for seconds, even my super picky 10 year old who swears he hates all veggies. The spice balance is perfect, not too much cinnamon, just the right amount of nutmeg. Total game changer for my holiday dessert rotation!
Really solid recipe! I made this ahead for my weekly meal prep snacks (don’t judge, pie for breakfast is a fall vibe) and it held up great in the fridge for 4 days. Only knock is I wish the instructions specified how long to blind bake the crust — my first crust got a little soggy on the bottom. Still SO good though, will make again!
Y’all, I made this for my church potluck last Sunday and I had 3 people ask me for the recipe before we even got to the dessert table! Tastes just like the sweet potato pie my auntie used to make every Thanksgiving, no weird canned filling or artificial flavor. 10/10, no notes.
Okay, full transparency: this was my first time ever making a pie from scratch, so take this with a grain of salt. The cook time felt way longer than I expected (who knew peeling and mashing sweet potatoes took so long?!) and my filling cracked a little on top, but the flavor was actually really good. Just wish I’d budgeted more time to make it before my friend’s fall party.
My kids loved it!!! I was nervous they’d turn their noses up at sweet potato pie since they always beg for pumpkin, but they ate every last bite and asked if we could have it for their Halloween party treats. I added a tiny extra dash of cloves because we love warm spices in our house, and it was chef’s kiss.
Made this with a couple swaps to make it vegan (coconut condensed milk, vegan butter crust) and it turned out so tasty! I was worried the texture would be off, but it was smooth and creamy just like the non-vegan version I grew up eating. Definitely a staple for me now, even my non-vegan roommate stole a slice and said it was great.
I’ve been searching for a sweet potato pie recipe that tastes like the one my wife made for 40 years before she passed, and this is the closest I’ve found. Not too sweet, perfectly smooth, no weird stringy bits from badly mashed potatoes. Made it for our grandkids’ visit last weekend and they said it was almost as good as grandma’s. That’s the highest compliment I could get.
Just pulled this out of the oven and the whole house smells like fall heaven!!! I haven’t even cut into it yet but I already know it’s gonna be a hit at my work potluck tomorrow. The filling was so easy to mix up, even with my medium baking skill level (per the difficulty rating, they were not lying, totally doable even if you’re not a pro baker).
I was so intimidated to make this because pie feels like such a fancy, hard dessert, but the instructions were so straightforward! I messed up the crust crimping a little (it looks lumpy, don’t look too close) but the flavor is unreal. I served it with a dollop of bourbon whipped cream and my roommate said it’s better than the pie we got at that fancy Southern restaurant downtown last month. Win!