PA Dutch Chicken Pot Pie
intro
Hearty, crust-free Pennsylvania Dutch stew with tender simmered chicken, root vegetables, and chewy homemade square noodles, made for cozy shared family meals.
Ingredients
Steps
Simmer the chicken base
Place 900 grams bone-in skin-on chicken thighs, 1.9 liters chicken broth, diced yellow onion, and 1 teaspoon (6g) kosher salt in a large 7-liter enameled Dutch oven over medium-high heat. Bring to a rolling boil, then reduce heat to medium-low to maintain a gentle simmer, cover, and cook for 30 minutes until chicken is tender and pulls easily from the bone.
Mix pot pie noodle dough
While chicken cooks, prepare the noodle dough: whisk 360 grams all-purpose flour and remaining 1 teaspoon (6g) kosher salt in a large mixing bowl. Make a well in the center of the flour, add 1 whole large egg and 60 ml whole milk, then stir with a wooden spoon until a shaggy, stiff dough forms. Knead for 3 minutes on a lightly floured surface until smooth, then wrap in plastic wrap and rest for 15 minutes at room temperature.
Prep cooked chicken
After 30 minutes of simmering, use metal tongs to transfer cooked chicken thighs to a clean cutting board. Let cool for 10 minutes until safe to handle, then remove and discard skin and bones, shredding the chicken into 2.5cm (1-inch) bite-sized pieces. Set shredded chicken aside, leaving the broth and onion mixture in the Dutch oven over low heat.
Roll and cut noodles
Unwrap the rested dough, roll it out on a lightly floured surface to an even 3mm (1/8-inch) thick sheet. Use a sharp knife or pizza cutter to cut the dough into 2.5cm (1-inch) square noodles, tossing the cut squares lightly in a small pinch of flour to prevent them from sticking together.
Cook vegetables and noodles
Increase heat under the Dutch oven to medium to bring the broth back to a steady simmer. Add sliced carrots, sliced celery, and cubed Yukon gold potatoes, cook uncovered for 10 minutes until vegetables are just starting to soften. Drop the cut noodle squares into the simmering broth one by one to prevent sticking, stir gently, and cook for 12 minutes until noodles are tender and chewy with no raw flour taste remaining.
Finish and serve stew
Stir the shredded chicken, 28 grams unsalted butter, 1 teaspoon ground black pepper, and 1 tablespoon dried parsley flakes into the pot. Simmer for 3 more minutes over low heat until butter is fully melted and chicken is heated through, then taste and adjust salt if needed before serving hot in shallow bowls.
Tips
2.Use bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs instead of lean chicken breast for this recipe; dark meat stays juicy during long simmering and adds rich, savory depth to the broth that lean breast cannot match.
3.Roll noodle dough to an even 1/8-inch thickness: noodles rolled too thick will remain raw and doughy in the center, while noodles rolled too thin will dissolve into the broth during cooking.

OMG this tastes exactly like my memaw’s PA Dutch pot pie I grew up eating at church suppers! I was so worried I’d never get the noodle texture right after moving out of state, but these square dumplings came out perfect, not too doughy at all. My whole family cleaned their bowls, even my super picky 7 year old. Total game changer for our Sunday dinner rotation!
Made this for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! I added a little extra thyme because I grow it in my garden, and it paired so well with the savory chicken and broth. Only note is it took me a little longer than 1hr15 because I prepped the broth from scratch, but totally worth it. SO good.
Tried this as my first ever from-scratch dinner for my roommates and they thought I was a professional chef! The instructions were super easy to follow even for someone who burns toast half the time. Will definitely be making this again now that the weather is cooling down.
Wait a second, this isn’t the chicken pot pie I know! Where’s the flaky crust and the veggie filling you bake in the oven? I followed all the steps and ended up with something that looks like chicken noodle soup with thick squares. Did I do something wrong?
Meal prepped this for the week and it held up sooooo well! I portioned it out into 5 containers and the noodles didn’t get mushy at all when I reheated them in the microwave, which is usually my biggest issue with soup/stew recipes. 10/10, will be a regular in my weekly prep rotation.
Made this after a long cold hike last Saturday and it hit the spot. Hearty, filling, not too heavy, and the flavor was spot on. I used bone-in chicken thighs instead of breast because I prefer the richer flavor, worked like a charm.
My kids loved it!!! I was convinced they’d turn their noses up at the ‘weird noodles’ but they both asked for seconds, and my 4 year old even asked if we could have it for his birthday dinner. I skipped the celery because my oldest hates it, and it still tasted amazing.
I’ve been making PA Dutch pot pie for over 60 years and this recipe is almost identical to the one my mother passed down to me! The only thing I do different is add a pinch of saffron to the broth for that classic golden color, but the noodle recipe here is perfect. Takes me right back to Sunday dinners at my grandma’s farm.
Solid base recipe! I added a dash of hot sauce and a sprinkle of smoked paprika to my bowl for a little kick, and it slapped. Would make again for a quick weeknight comfort food meal, especially when it’s rainy out.
Wait, has anyone tried making this with gluten free flour for the noodles? I have celiac and have been craving this pot pie so bad since I had it at a friend’s house a few months ago, but I don’t want to waste ingredients if the GF flour doesn’t work for the dough.
Brought this to our church potluck last Sunday and the crockpot was scraped clean before I even got through the first line for food! Everyone kept saying it was the best comfort food they’d had all fall. I did cook the chicken ahead of time to save time the day of, which made assembly so much easier.
Made this for my wife after we brought our new baby home last week and she said it was better than the pot pie her own mom makes! Let’s be real, I almost cried when she said that. Super straightforward recipe, even with a newborn attached to my chest half the time I was cooking.
This is so affordable to make! I already had most of the ingredients in my pantry and fridge, only had to pick up a whole chicken for like $6, and it fed me and my roommate for 3 full dinners. Way better than spending money on takeout on cold nights.
Stopped at a little diner in Lancaster last fall and had PA Dutch pot pie for the first time, and I’ve been chasing that flavor ever since. This recipe is dead on! I can’t believe I made it at home and it tasted exactly like what I had on that trip. 10/10, no notes.
I added extra carrots and some frozen peas to this to bulk up the veggies, and it was fantastic! I was worried it would throw off the broth flavor but it was still so savory and cozy. Great base recipe that you can tweak to whatever veggies you have on hand.
Okay full transparency, I messed up the noodles the first time I rolled them out too thick, but I just re-rolled them thinner and they turned out great! Don’t get discouraged if your first batch of dough feels weird, it’s super forgiving. The end result is so worth it, even for messy cooks like me.
This is officially our new go-to Sunday family dinner recipe! We had my parents and my in-laws over last weekend and everyone raved about it. My father-in-law is super picky about PA Dutch food since his family is from Lebanon County, and he went back for thirds. That’s the best review I could ever get!
Has anyone tried making this in the slow cooker? I work 9 hour days and would love to throw everything in the crockpot before I leave so it’s ready when I get home, but I don’t want the noodles to turn to mush.