Paper Airplane Cocktail
intro
A perfectly balanced modern classic cocktail, with equal parts smooth bourbon, bittersweet amaro, zesty Aperol, and bright lemon—tart, warming, and endlessly sippable.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill Coupe Glass
Before prepping any ingredients, set the clear glass coupe in its central serving position and fill it with cold tap water plus 2-3 ice cubes to chill while you mix the drink. A pre-chilled glass keeps the cocktail at the ideal serving temperature (4-7°C / 39-45°F) for 10-15 minutes, rather than warming immediately on contact with room-temperature glass. Set aside until ready to strain the drink.
Prep Lemon and Zest
Place the whole lemon on the white oak cutting board. Use the paring knife to cut the lemon in half crosswise, then cut a 1cm wide strip of zest from one half, taking care to leave as much bitter white pith on the lemon as possible. Set the zest strip aside on the edge of the cutting board for garnish. Use the beech wood citrus reamer to squeeze 3/4 oz (22ml) of fresh lemon juice into the small clear glass juice cup, picking out any seeds that fall into the juice.
Measure All Ingredients
Set the cocktail shaker tin base in the central working area, moving the chilled coupe temporarily to the right of the working space. Use the double-sided stainless steel jigger to measure and pour 3/4 oz (22ml) bourbon, 3/4 oz (22ml) Aperol, and 3/4 oz (22ml) Amaro Nonino into the shaker tin, one ingredient at a time. Follow with 3/4 oz (22ml) of the freshly squeezed lemon juice, pouring slowly to avoid transferring pulp or seeds into the tin.
Add Ice and Seal Shaker
Pour the ice water out of the chilled coupe, shaking firmly to remove all excess water droplets, then return the coupe to its serving position. Add 1 cup of large, cold cubed ice to the shaker tin with the measured liquid ingredients, filling the tin no more than 2/3 full to leave room for aeration during shaking. Press the perforated strainer insert and cap firmly onto the shaker tin to create a watertight seal that will not leak during shaking.
Shake Until Frosty
Grip the sealed shaker with one hand on the tin base and one hand on the cap, applying firm pressure to maintain the watertight seal. Shake hard in a fast, up-and-down motion for 12-15 seconds, until the entire exterior of the shaker is coated in a thin, opaque layer of frost and feels uncomfortably cold to the touch. This chills the drink to approximately 4°C/40°F and adds the ideal amount of dilution from mild ice melt, creating a smooth, light texture.
Double Strain Cocktail
Remove the small cap from the top of the shaker, leaving the built-in perforated strainer insert in place. Hold the Hawthorne strainer over the shaker opening to catch any small ice shards or stray lemon pulp that would make the drink texture gritty. Hold the chilled coupe at a 45-degree angle, and pour the cocktail slowly into the glass until it reaches 3/4 of the way up the coupe bowl, stopping 1cm below the rim to avoid spills when adding garnish.
Add Lemon Twist Garnish
Pick up the reserved lemon zest strip from the cutting board, holding it 2-3cm above the drink surface with the bright yellow zest side facing down toward the cocktail. Squeeze the twist firmly to release a fine mist of bright citrus essential oils across the drink surface, then rub the outer edge of the zest lightly along the coupe rim. Twist the peel gently and rest it on the edge of the glass as garnish, then serve immediately.
Tips
2.Use large, dense ice cubes for shaking: Small crushed or hollow ice cubes melt too quickly during shaking, leading to over-diluted, watery cocktail, while large dense cubes chill the drink rapidly with controlled, consistent dilution over the 12-15 second shake.
3.Trim all white pith from your lemon twist: The soft white pith under the yellow zest has a harsh, bitter flavor that will overpower the drink’s delicate balance if oils from the pith are squeezed onto the drink or rubbed on the glass rim.

OMG, I made this for my girls' night potluck last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe! It’s so perfectly balanced—sweet, tart, just enough bourbon kick without being harsh. Total game changer for my go-to cocktail rotation!
I’ve been messing up whiskey cocktails for years because I always overpour the spirit, but this recipe is so easy to nail even for a dummy like me! Zero fancy tools needed, just shake and pour. SO good, my roommate already asked me to make it again for our football watch party this Sunday.
Made these for my husband’s birthday dinner last night and even my teen who swears she hates “old people drinks” snuck a sip and said it was actually good! Super quick to whip up between courses too, no fuss at all.
Wait, hold on—this says 0 minutes cook time? Does that mean I don’t have to simmer anything or make a simple syrup from scratch? That’s wild, I thought every good cocktail required prep work!
I brought a batch of these to my monthly book club last night and we ended up talking way more about the cocktails than the book 😂 Everyone loved how smooth it is, even the friend who only drinks white wine! Will absolutely be making this again for our next gathering.
Tried this last night after seeing it pop up on my feed and wow, way better than the old fashioned I usually make at home. The Aperol adds such a nice bright, citrusy note that keeps it from feeling too heavy. 10/10, already added the ingredients to my regular shopping list.
Made a big pitcher of these for my patio BBQ over the weekend and they were gone in 45 minutes flat. Only note—next time I’m doubling the batch because people were coming back for thirds!
Tried making this for my pregame last weekend and it was so much cheaper than buying seltzers or pre-made cocktails! Tastes way better too, my friends thought I ordered it from the bar down the street. 10/10, easy enough to make even in a tiny dorm kitchen.
I packed the pre-mixed ingredients in an insulated tumbler for my day hike last weekend and it was the perfect reward at the summit! Light, refreshing, didn’t get sloshed around in my pack. Already planning to bring it on my next camping trip.
Made this for my at-home date night with my partner and they said it was better than the $18 cocktails we got on our last anniversary dinner out! I even messed up the measurements a tiny bit (poured a little extra lemon) and it still tasted amazing.
I’ve been making Paper Airplanes for years and this is the best ratio I’ve ever tried! A lot of recipes go too heavy on the Aperol and make it too bitter, but this equal parts split is absolutely perfect. Tastes just like the version they serve at my favorite speakeasy.
I added a tiny dash of cayenne on the rim for a little kick and it was chef’s kiss! The warm spice pairs so well with the citrus and bourbon, I can’t recommend that little hack enough if you like a little heat in your drinks.