paper plane cocktail
intro
A perfectly balanced modern classic cocktail with equal parts bourbon, Aperol, Amaro Nonino, and fresh lemon—bright, bitter-sweet, glowing amber, and endlessly sippable.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill the serving glass
Place 1 large ice cube in the clear crystal coupe glass, then top with 30ml cold tap water to fill the bowl halfway. Set the glass aside in its fixed center-right position to chill while you prep ingredients—this ensures the cocktail stays cold longer after straining, with no warm glass diluting the drink prematurely.
Measure core spirits
Remove the cap from the bourbon bottle, setting the cap beside the bottle on the counter. Using the stainless steel jigger, measure exactly 3/4 oz (22ml) of bourbon and pour it into the base of the cocktail shaker. Repeat the measurement for 3/4 oz (22ml) of Aperol and 3/4 oz (22ml) of Amaro Nonino, pouring each directly into the shaker tin. Do not add ice yet, as premature ice melt will over-dilute the cocktail.
Squeeze fresh lemon juice
Take one whole lemon from the maple cutting board, cut it in half using the paring knife. Hold one lemon half cut-side down over the jigger, squeezing gently to extract exactly 3/4 oz (22ml) of fresh juice, taking care to catch any seeds before they fall into the measurement. Pour the measured lemon juice into the cocktail shaker with the spirits, leaving lemon rind scraps on the edge of the cutting board.
Add ice for shaking
Using the stainless steel ice tongs from the ice bucket, add 3-4 large clear ice cubes to the cocktail shaker, filling the tin no more than 2/3 full. Secure the shaker lid tightly, pressing firmly to create a watertight seal so no liquid leaks out during shaking.
Shake until chilled
Hold the sealed cocktail shaker with one hand on the top cap and one hand on the base, shaking hard and fast in a horizontal motion for 12-15 seconds. The shaker should feel frosty and cold to the touch on the outside, indicating the drink has reached the ideal 4°C (39°F) temperature with perfect dilution (roughly 20% water melt from the ice).
Strain into chilled glass
Remove the ice water from the pre-chilled coupe glass, dumping the water into the out-of-frame sink with no spills on the counter. Remove the top cap from the shaker, fit the Hawthorne strainer tightly over the shaker tin opening, and pour the chilled cocktail in a steady stream into the center of the coupe glass. The strainer’s coil will catch any small ice shards or lemon seeds, leaving a perfectly smooth drink.
Add lemon twist garnish
Use the citrus zester to cut a 5cm long, thin strip of lemon peel from the remaining lemon half, taking care to avoid cutting into the bitter white pith. Hold the peel 5cm above the surface of the cocktail, colored side facing down, and squeeze gently to express citrus oils over the drink surface. Rub the peel lightly along the rim of the coupe, then rest it across the edge of the glass as garnish.
Tips
2.Use large, dense craft ice cubes for shaking: small, watery ice from standard freezer trays melts too quickly, leading to over-diluted, watery drinks, while dense large ice chills the drink rapidly with controlled melt during the 12-15 second shake.
3.Avoid cutting into the white lemon pith when making your garnish twist: the pith contains harsh, bitter compounds that will add an unpleasant astringent note to the drink, while the colored outer peel holds bright, aromatic citrus oils that elevate the cocktail’s aroma.

OMG I made this for my girls’ night last night and it was SO good! I was nervous because I’m terrible at making drinks but this was literally so easy, zero cook time? Perfect for someone like me who burns even simple syrup half the time lol. Will absolutely be making this for our next potluck pregame!
Game changer. I’ve been ordering Paper Planes at my local bar for years and never thought to make them at home because I assumed they’d be fussy. This recipe is spot on flavor-wise! I did swap the Aperol for Campari once just to test and it was a little more bitter but still great.
Made a whole batch of these for my backyard BBQ this past weekend and people were asking for the recipe before they even finished their first glass! So much better than the seltzer and beer I usually serve. 10/10
Wait quick question—can I batch make these a few hours before guests come over? I’m hosting a birthday happy hour and don’t want to be stuck shaking drinks the whole time.
Made this for my at-home date night with my partner last week and they said it tasted better than the fancy craft cocktail bar we went to for our anniversary! Who knew such a simple recipe could hit so hard. We paired it with charcuterie and it was chef’s kiss.
I don’t usually love bourbon drinks but this is so balanced—sweet, bitter, citrusy, none of the flavors overpower each other. I’ve already made it three times this week oops. My roommate keeps stealing sips when I’m not looking lmao
Wait I know this is a cocktail but has anyone tried making a non-alcoholic version of this? I’m sober curious but love the flavor profile of amaro-style drinks!
Made these for my rooftop Fourth of July party and they were gone in 45 minutes flat. Only complaint is I didn’t make enough! Next time I’m tripling the recipe for sure.
Brought all the ingredients to make these for our office happy hour last Friday and it was such a hit! My boss even asked me to send the recipe to the whole team. Super easy to shake up one after another when people are lined up for drinks.
Wait, is the lemon juice super prominent here? I hate super tangy, citrus-forward drinks but my friend raved about this recipe so I want to try it.
Just started building out my home bar and this was the first recipe I tested! I was worried I messed up the ratios because I didn’t measure *exactly* but it still turned out incredible. 10/10 for beginners like me.
Served these at my boozy brunch last weekend instead of mimosas for a change and it was such a fun switch up! Paired amazing with French toast and bacon, will definitely be adding these to my regular brunch rotation.
I brought these to my neighborhood potluck last night and so many people said it was the best drink they’d ever had at one of our events! The only note I got was that people wished there was a mocktail version, which I saw someone mentioned earlier so I’ll be trying that next time.