Paper Plane Cocktails
intro
A perfectly balanced modern classic cocktail with equal parts bourbon, bitter liqueurs, and fresh lemon—bright, bittersweet, and smooth, made for slow sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Chill Coupe Glasses
Place the two clear crystal coupe glasses on the center of the counter, filling each to the brim with cubed ice from the back-right ice bucket to pre-chill for 5 minutes while you prep ingredients. Chilled glassware prevents the finished cocktail from warming too quickly and reduces excess dilution as the drink sits. Retrieve the small acacia wood cutting board, paring knife, and handheld citrus juicer, setting them neatly to the left of the glasses without moving any fixed background props.
Squeeze Fresh Lemon Juice
Retrieve one whole lemon from the cream ceramic dish, placing it on the acacia cutting board. Use the paring knife to slice the lemon in half crosswise. Hold the cut lemon half in the handheld citrus juicer, squeezing firmly over the jigger to collect 45ml (1.5 fl oz) of fresh, seed-free juice, picking out any seeds that fall into the jigger. Leave the squeezed lemon rinds on the edge of the cutting board for the remainder of the recipe as a natural, lived-in detail. Bottled lemon juice will not work here—bright, fresh acidity is critical to balance the sweet, bitter liqueurs.
Measure All Ingredients
Dump the ice from the now-chilled coupe glasses (just out of frame), shaking out any remaining melted water, and set the glasses back on the counter to the right. Use the matte black double jigger to measure exactly 45ml (1.5 fl oz) each of bourbon, Aperol, Amaro Nonino, and fresh lemon juice, pouring each measured ingredient directly into the larger weighted tin of the Boston shaker. Precision is non-negotiable here: the Paper Plane’s signature perfectly balanced flavor relies on equal parts of all four components, so never free-pour.
Shake Vigorously with Ice
Add 2 cups of cubed clear ice from the back-right ice bucket to the shaker tin holding the measured ingredients. Seal the Boston shaker firmly by tapping the smaller tin onto the larger tin at a slight angle to create a tight seal. Hold the shaker with one hand on each tin, shaking hard and fast for 12-15 seconds, until the outside of the metal tins feels frosty and ice-cold to the touch. This chills the drink to approximately 4°C (40°F) and adds just the right amount of water dilution to soften the bold spirit and liqueur flavors.
Double Strain Cocktails
Break the shaker seal by tapping the raised seam between the two tins firmly with the heel of your hand. Fit the Hawthorne strainer snugly over the top of the shaker tin holding the mixed cocktail, and hold the fine mesh conical strainer 2cm above the first chilled coupe. Pour the cocktail slowly through both strainers, dividing the amber liquid evenly between the two coupes, filling each glass about 2/3 full. Double straining catches small ice shards and lemon pulp for a silky, perfectly smooth drink texture.
Garnish with Lemon Twist
Use the paring knife to cut two 5cm long, 1cm wide strips of lemon peel from the remaining fresh lemon, trimming away any thick white pith from the back of the peel to avoid bitter flavor. Hold each peel strip 5cm above the drink surface, skin side facing down, and squeeze gently to express a fine mist of citrus oil over the cocktail, then rub the peel lightly along the glass rim before resting it on the edge of the coupe. Serve immediately, while the drink is perfectly cold.
Tips
2.Use very cold, fresh ice for shaking: warm, partially melted ice will dilute the drink too quickly before it chills properly, leading to a watery, flat-tasting cocktail.
3.Trim all white pith from your lemon twist garnish: the soft white layer under the yellow peel is intensely bitter, and expressing oils from pith will add unpleasant harsh notes to the finished drink.

OMG I made these for my girls' night last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe! It’s perfectly balanced, not too sweet, not too harsh even though it packs a punch. SO good, I’ll be making these for every potluck from now on. Total game changer for my go-to cocktail list!
Was looking for an easy, no-fuss cocktail to make for my wife’s birthday dinner and this hit so hard. Zero cook time? Yes please, I didn’t have to mess with making simple syrups or muddling anything, just measured, shook, poured. We both loved the bright, citrusy notes paired with the bourbon. 10/10.
Tried this last night when we had our neighbors over for a backyard cookout. Even my friend who swears she only drinks beer tried a sip and ended up having two! Super easy to whip up a big batch too, I just pre-measured everything into a pitcher ahead of time so I didn’t miss out on hanging out. Only knocked a star off because I wish I’d bought extra Aperol, I ran out halfway through the night oops. Perfect for summer gatherings.
Wait, do I have to use bourbon for this? I only have rye whiskey at home right now, will that throw the flavor off too much?
Made these for my family dinner last Sunday and even my dad who only drinks old fashioneds was obsessed! Who knew equal parts of everything could be so dang tasty? No fancy measuring mess, easy peasy.
I don’t have a cocktail shaker at home — can I just stir this with ice in a cup and strain it with a regular kitchen strainer? Don’t wanna buy extra gear just for one cocktail.
Wait, is this supposed to be served up or on the rocks? I made it last night and poured it over crushed ice because I didn’t have coupe glasses, and it was so refreshing! Hope that’s not sacrilege lol.
I made these for my potluck last Saturday and they were gone in 20 minutes! Only problem is I used a cheaper amaro and it was a little too bitter for some of my friends. Any tips for picking a good bottle without spending a ton?
My partner and I have been making these every Friday night for our at-home date night and it’s become our new favorite ritual! It’s easy enough that even he can make it without messing up (bless, he can barely make coffee without burning it lol).