Peanut Butter Pizza
intro
A nostalgic, shareable American dessert: chewy sugar cookie crust slathered with creamy peanut butter, topped with toasted marshmallows, chocolate drizzle, and salty peanuts for the perfect sweet-salty bite.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Pan and Oven
Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C), with the rack positioned in the center for even baking. Lightly grease the surface of the 12-inch matte aluminum pizza pan with a thin swipe of butter or non-stick spray to prevent the cookie crust from sticking during baking.
Press Cookie Crust
Place the unwrapped sugar cookie dough in the center of the greased pizza pan. Use the stainless steel offset spatula (or clean, lightly floured fingers) to press the dough into an even ¼-inch thick layer across the entire pan, extending all the way to the raised rim. Smooth out any lumps, cracks, or thin spots to ensure the crust bakes evenly with no hard, crispy thin edges.
Bake and Cool Crust
Place the pan with pressed crust on the center oven rack and bake for 10-12 minutes, until the crust is light golden brown at the edges and set across the top; it will puff slightly as it bakes. Once baked, carefully remove the pan from the oven and set it directly on the chrome wire cooling rack on the counter. Let the crust cool completely for 10 minutes before adding any toppings to prevent peanut butter from melting and sliding off.
Spread Peanut Butter Layer
Scoop the full ¾ cup (180g) of creamy no-stir peanut butter into the center of the cooled cookie crust. Use the matte tangerine silicone spatula to spread the peanut butter into an even ⅛-inch thick layer, leaving a ½-inch bare golden crust border around the edge to mimic a traditional pizza rim. Spread slowly to avoid tearing the soft cooled cookie base.
Toast Marshmallow Topping
Sprinkle the ½ cup of mini marshmallows evenly across the peanut butter layer, distributing them so every slice will have 4-5 marshmallows. Switch the oven to high broil, and place the pan on the top oven rack, 6 inches from the broiler element. Broil for 30-60 seconds, watching constantly, until marshmallow tops are deep golden brown with slightly charred tips. Remove immediately to avoid burning.
Drizzle Melted Chocolate
Take the prep bowl holding chocolate chips and canola oil, microwave in 20-second bursts, stirring between each, until chocolate is fully smooth and liquid (about 40 seconds total). Use the small stainless steel teaspoon to drizzle the melted chocolate in loose zig-zag lines across the top of the warm marshmallow layer.
Add Final Garnishes
Sprinkle the chopped roasted salted peanuts evenly across the chocolate drizzle, then pinch the flaky sea salt between your fingers and scatter it lightly over the entire pizza. The salt will cut through the rich sweetness of the peanut butter, chocolate, and marshmallows for a balanced sweet-salty flavor. Let the pizza rest for 5 minutes to let the chocolate set slightly before slicing.
Slice and Plate Pizza
Use the stainless steel pizza cutter to slice the peanut butter pizza into 8 even triangular slices. Carefully transfer the slices to the round cream ceramic pizza platter, fanning them slightly to show the layered cross-section of crust, peanut butter, and toppings. Serve at room temperature.
Tips
2.Watch the marshmallows constantly while broiling: broiler elements heat extremely fast, and marshmallows can go from perfectly golden to burnt black in as little as 10 seconds, so do not step away from the oven during this step.
3.Let the cookie crust cool completely before adding peanut butter: even slightly warm crust will melt the peanut butter, causing it to slide off the crust and make toppings runny instead of staying in neat, even layers.

OMG y’all, this peanut butter pizza was an absolute game changer for our Friday family movie night! 13 minutes in the oven and I had all three boys begging for seconds before the first batch even cooled. I added a handful of mini chocolate chips and sliced banana on top, chef’s kiss. Who knew something this easy could hit so hard?
No fancy equipment, no weird ingredients, 13 minute cook time? This was made for people like me who only have a tiny toaster oven in their dorm. I skipped the fancy toppings and just used crunchy peanut butter with a sprinkle of cinnamon, and my roommate ate half the pan before I could even grab a second slice. SO good.
Made this for a post-hike snack last weekend and it was the perfect pick-me-up! I used whole grain crust to make it a little more filling, added a drizzle of honey and some crushed peanuts for crunch. Held up great in the cooler on the drive up to the trailhead, will absolutely be making this again for our next trip.
I brought this to my office potluck yesterday and people were literally asking me for the recipe before I even set the platter down! I did a marshmallow fluff drizzle and crushed pretzel pieces on top for that sweet-salty vibe, and the whole thing was gone in 10 minutes. 10/10, easiest crowd pleaser I’ve ever made.
Wait, has anyone tried prepping this ahead for the week? I’m always looking for quick grab-and-go snacks for my kids’ after school activities, and this looks like it would be way better than the processed granola bars I usually buy. Knocked a star off because I wish there were make-ahead tips in the actual recipe post!
Okay I’m literally the worst at baking, I burn toast half the time, and this turned out perfect first try! The 13 minute cook time was spot on for my oven, no burnt edges, perfectly melted peanut butter, I felt like a real chef. Even my partner who hates peanut butter went back for a second slice.
Super easy to swap for vegan ingredients! I used a vegan pre-made pizza crust, natural no-sugar-added peanut butter, and dairy free chocolate chips, and you couldn’t even tell the difference. Made it for my vegan friend’s birthday get together and everyone (even the non-vegans) raved about it.
Wait why did I never think of this before? Peanut butter on pizza crust? It’s like a giant, warm peanut butter cookie but way less work. I topped mine with Reese’s Pieces because I have zero self control, and I’m not even sorry. My only complaint is that I ate 3 slices for dinner and now I’m in a food coma, worth it though.
Made this with my granddaughter when she came to visit last weekend, and we had the best time! It’s so easy even a 7 year old can help spread the peanut butter and add toppings. We did rainbow sprinkles per her request, and it was the silliest, tastiest dessert we’ve made in ages. Will be a staple for our grandma-granddaughter days from now on.
I was skeptical at first because I’m usually a savory pizza only guy, but my partner begged me to make this and I’m so glad I did. I added a tiny sprinkle of cayenne pepper with the peanut butter for a little kick, and the sweet-spicy combo was unreal. Don’t knock it till you try it, even savory pizza stans will love this. Only knock is I wish the recipe suggested savory mix-ins earlier, I had to dig through my spice cabinet on a whim!
So happy this works with gluten free pizza crust! I’ve been looking for quick dessert recipes that don’t require a million weird GF flours, and this was perfect. The texture was amazing, no weird gritty aftertaste like some GF desserts have. My whole family ate it and didn’t even notice it was gluten free.
Threw this together for our football tailgate last Sunday and it was a total touchdown. I cut it into little bite sized squares, added a drizzle of Nutella and some crushed potato chips on top for crunch, and people were coming back for thirds. Way easier to make than the usual cookies and brownies people bring, will be a regular in my tailgate rotation.
Made this at 1am after a night out with friends and it was the best decision I’ve made all month. Only took 13 minutes, used whatever I had in the pantry—crunchy peanut butter, leftover Halloween candy, a little marshmallow fluff—and it hit so much better than the usual fast food run. 10/10, perfect late night snack.
I made this for a neighbor who just had a new baby, and she texted me saying it was the best thing anyone had brought over! It’s easy to transport, not too messy, and both her toddler and husband loved it too. Way better than the usual casseroles people bring, it’s nice to have a sweet treat that’s not a ton of work.
Okay hear me out, I thought this was going to be a total abomination. Peanut butter on pizza? Blasphemy. But my kids begged me to make it so I caved, and…I actually liked it? Don’t tell my pizza club friends I said that. The salty crust with the creamy peanut butter and a little chocolate is actually a banger. I’m never going to admit this publicly, though. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish I’d thought to add bacon the first time around, total missed opportunity on my part.
Made this with my cabin of 10 year olds at summer camp last week, and it was the most popular cooking activity we did all session! All the kids got to add their own toppings—sprinkles, chocolate chips, crushed Oreos, you name it—and every single one of them cleaned their plates. It’s easy enough for kids to help with, minimal mess, and super fun. Will be bringing this back every summer.
I made this with no added sugar natural peanut butter, a whole wheat crust, and topped it with fresh strawberries and a tiny drizzle of maple syrup, and it satisfied my sweet tooth without making me feel like I ate a ton of junk. Perfect for when you want a treat but don’t want a total sugar crash. The cook time was exactly right, no adjustments needed.
Just moved into my first apartment and hosted my first ever friend get together last night, and this was the star of the show! I was so nervous because I’m still learning to cook, but it was so easy, no fancy skills needed, and all my friends thought I was a baking genius. I did a mix of toppings so people could pick their favorite slices: chocolate banana, marshmallow pretzel, and cinnamon honey. 10/10, will be making this for every gathering from now on.