Peanut Butter Stout
intro
Velvety homemade peanut butter stout with deep roasted malt notes, creamy nutty warmth, and subtle chocolate undertones, perfectly balanced for slow sipping on cool autumn evenings.
Ingredients
Steps
Sanitize All Equipment
First, mix no-rinse brewing sanitizer per package directions in the 8-quart stainless steel stock pot. Submerge the fermentation jug, stirring spoon, strainer, siphon, airlock, rubber stopper, and bottles for 60 seconds, then set on a clean section of counter to air dry. Any surface that touches cooled wort must be fully sanitized to prevent off-flavors or bacterial contamination.
Steep Roasted Grains
Pour 2 quarts of cold filtered water into the sanitized stock pot, then set the fine-mesh strainer filled with crushed roasted barley and crushed chocolate malt into the water so grains are fully submerged. Heat water to a steady 155°F (68°C), hold that temperature for 20 minutes, never letting the water reach a boil (boiling extracts harsh, bitter tannins from grains). The water will darken to a deep mahogany brown as roasted malt flavors infuse.
Boil Wort and Hops
Lift the grain-filled strainer from the pot, letting all dark liquid drain back into the pot before discarding spent grains. Bring the infused grain water to a gentle rolling boil, then stir in all light dry malt extract with the long stainless steel stirring spoon until fully dissolved, with no dry clumps remaining. Once boiling resumes, add 0.25oz of Cascade hop pellets, set a timer for 45 minutes, adjusting heat to maintain a steady non-violent boil to avoid boilovers. Add the remaining 0.25oz of Cascade hops during the final 5 minutes of the boil to preserve bright, citrusy aroma.
Stir in Peanut Butter
When the 45-minute boil ends, turn off the heat completely. Scoop all unsweetened smooth peanut butter into the hot wort, stirring vigorously for 2 full minutes with the stainless steel spoon until the peanut butter fully emulsifies into the liquid, with no large oily clumps floating on the surface. Cool the wort as quickly as possible to 70°F (21°C) by setting the pot in an ice water bath in the sink; rapid cooling reduces contamination risk and prevents off-flavors. The finished cooled wort will be opaque deep brown, with a rich, nutty roasted aroma.
Pitch Ale Yeast
Once the wort holds a steady 70°F (21°C), pour it through the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer into the sanitized 1-gallon glass fermentation jug, topping up with remaining cold filtered water to reach the etched 1-gallon volume mark. Sprinkle the entire packet of dry English ale yeast evenly over the wort surface, then seal the jug with the sanitized rubber stopper and 3-piece airlock, filling the airlock halfway with sanitizer solution. Move the jug to a dark, temperature-stable 65-70°F (18-21°C) spot for 7 days of primary fermentation; steady bubbles will rise through the airlock for the first 3-5 days as yeast converts sugar to alcohol.
Bottle with Priming Sugar
After 7 days, when airlock bubbling slows to less than 1 bubble per minute, sanitize eight 12oz glass beer bottles and metal crown caps. Boil the 1oz corn priming sugar with ¼ cup filtered water in the 1.5-quart stainless steel saucepan for 2 minutes to sterilize, then let cool to room temperature and divide evenly between the sanitized bottles. Use the food-grade auto-siphon to transfer stout from the fermentation jug into each bottle, leaving exactly 1 inch of headspace below the bottle neck to allow for carbonation, then crimp caps tightly with the bottle capper. Avoid siphoning the thin layer of tan yeast sediment from the bottom of the jug to prevent cloudy beer.
Carbonate and Chill
Store the tightly capped bottles in the same dark, 65-70°F space for 7 full days to allow natural carbonation: remaining active yeast will consume the priming sugar, producing tiny bubbles and a creamy, long-lasting head. After 7 days of room-temperature conditioning, move all bottles to the refrigerator to chill for a minimum of 48 hours before serving. This chill period lets sediment settle to the bottle bottom and mellows sharp, green beer flavors for a smoother, rounder taste.
Tips
2.Never skip full sanitization of every tool, jug, and bottle that touches cooled wort: even trace amounts of residual bacteria can create sour, vinegary off-flavors or ruin an entire batch, so take 60 seconds to submerge all contact surfaces in no-rinse sanitizer.
3.Leave the last ¼ inch of beer in each bottle when pouring: this avoids disturbing the thin layer of settled yeast sediment at the bottle bottom, resulting in a clearer, smoother pour with a creamier, longer-lasting head.

OMG, this peanut butter stout is an absolute game changer! I brewed a batch for our annual fall potluck and everyone was begging for the recipe. The peanut butter notes are so smooth, no weird artificial aftertaste at all, and it pairs perfectly with chocolate brownies. 10/10 will be making this every fall from now on!
Really solid recipe! My only note is that I wish it had a little more roasted peanut depth, mine came out a touch more chocolate-forward than I expected. Still SO good though, my partner drank half the batch in two days 😂
I’ve been homebrewing for 8 years and this is easily one of the best stout recipes I’ve ever tried. The 1 hour 15 minute cook time is totally manageable even for weeknight brew sessions, and the final ABV hit exactly what the recipe predicted. Brought a growler to my buddy’s game night and everyone thought I bought it from a local craft brewery!
First time ever brewing beer and I picked this recipe because I’m obsessed with peanut butter stouts! I was so worried I’d mess it up since the difficulty is medium, but the steps were super straightforward. Can’t wait for it to carbonate so I can try it!
Made this for our neighborhood block party and it was the hit of the whole event! Even people who say they don’t like dark beer were coming back for seconds. The peanut butter flavor is so cozy, it tastes like a grown up version of a peanut butter cup. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular brew rotation!
Great base recipe! I tweaked it a little by adding a hint of vanilla bean in secondary and it took the flavor over the top. Cook time was spot on, no weird hiccups during the boil, and the gravity readings lined up perfectly with the recipe notes. Solid pick for anyone who loves creamy, rich stouts
Tasted great, but I had to swap out a few ingredients to make it vegan, and I wish the recipe noted which components aren’t plant-based friendly. I figured it out, but it would have saved me a trip to the homebrew supply store mid-boil!
Brewed a double batch of this for our college football tailgate and it was gone before halftime. People were mixing it with a little vanilla ice cream for impromptu beer floats and losing their minds over how good it was. Absolute tailgate staple from now on!
I was skeptical about peanut butter in beer at first, but my buddy kept raving about this recipe so I gave it a shot. Let me tell you, it’s perfect after a long day of skiing, so rich and warming, not overly sweet at all. I’ve already recommended it to three people in my homebrew club
I followed the recipe exactly but my first batch came out way too bitter, I think I messed up the hop addition timing? I’m pretty new to this so I’m sure it’s user error, just a little bummed because I was really looking forward to it
SO good! I don’t even homebrew that often but this recipe was easy to follow, and the finished stout tastes exactly like the fancy expensive peanut butter stout I buy at the liquor store, but for a fraction of the cost. My roommates are already begging me to make another batch before the first one is even gone
Brought this to our monthly homebrew club meetup and it got second place in the stout category! Only reason I’m not giving it 5 stars is I wish the recipe included notes on how to adjust the body for people who prefer a thicker, creamier mouthfeel. Still amazing, will make again!
Made this as holiday gifts for my coworkers last year and everyone still asks me when I’m making more! The flavor holds up really well in the bottles for a couple months, so it’s perfect for gifting. I tied little custom labels on each bottle and it was such a hit
I’ve tried like four different peanut butter stout recipes online and this is by far the best one. No weird oily film on top, no stuck fermentation, the peanut butter flavor is present but not overpowering, and the roast level of the malt is perfectly balanced. Total game changer, I’m never using another recipe for this style
My partner and I did this as a fun at home date night activity and it was so much fun! The directions were easy to follow even for us total newbies, and we had a great time going through the steps together. Already planning our next brew day to make a hazy IPA now!
Paired this stout with my famous smoked brisket at our last family BBQ and it was a match made in heaven. The roasty, nutty notes cut through the smoky brisket perfectly, and even my 72 year old dad who only drinks light beer was a fan. 10/10, will make for every BBQ going forward