Peeps Christmas
intro
Cheerful no-bake Christmas treats featuring chewy crispy rice cereal houses, decorated with festive marshmallow Peeps, icing, and candy, perfect for holiday family fun.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Baking Dish
Use 1 teaspoon of the measured unsalted butter to grease the entire interior surface of the 9x9 inch clear glass baking dish, including the 5cm tall sides. Line the bottom with the parchment paper strip so it overhangs two opposite edges by 5cm, to make lifting set treats easy later. Set the prepared dish to the right of the birch cutting board.
Melt Marshmallow Base
Place the 3-quart stainless steel saucepan on low heat. Add the remaining unsalted butter, stirring constantly with the red silicone spatula until fully melted (about 2 minutes). Add the 3 cups of mini marshmallows, stirring continuously for 3-4 minutes until completely smooth, glossy, and free of lumps. Never turn heat above low, as high heat will create hard, crunchy treats.
Fold in Crispy Cereal
Remove the saucepan from heat immediately once the marshmallow is smooth. Pour all 4 cups of crispy rice cereal into the melted marshmallow mixture. Use the red silicone spatula to fold gently, scraping the bottom of the pan repeatedly, until every cereal piece is evenly coated in glossy marshmallow. Avoid over-stirring, as this crushes cereal and creates dense, tough treats.
Press Mixture Evenly
Scrape all the coated cereal mixture into the pre-greased glass baking dish. Lightly grease the blade of the offset metal icing spatula with a tiny dab of butter to prevent sticking, then press the mixture firmly into a flat, uniform 2.5cm thick layer across the entire dish. Let the mixture rest at room temperature for 15 minutes to set fully, until firm to the touch and not sticky when pressed lightly.
Cut House Shapes
Once set, lift the solid treat block out of the baking dish using the parchment paper overhang, and place it flat on the birch cutting board. Use the 8-inch chef knife to cut the block into 6 equal 5cm wide rectangles, then cut a 2cm tall triangular notch out of the top center of each rectangle to create a house roofline. Collect small offcuts in a small pile to snack on as you work.
Add Icing Snow Details
Scoop the ½ cup of white vanilla icing into the 1.5 quart stainless steel mixing bowl. Use the offset metal spatula to spread a 5mm thick line of icing along the sloped roof edges of each house, plus a small dab of icing on the roof peak to act as glue for decorations. The icing should mimic the look of soft, drifted snow along rooflines.
Attach Peeps and Candy
Press one Christmas-themed Peep marshmallow onto the iced peak of each treat house, alternating Santa, snowman, and reindeer shapes across the batch. Sprinkle a pinch of red and green sprinkles over the wet icing on each roof. Break mini candy canes into 2.5cm pieces, and press two pieces into the base of each house to look like tiny fence posts.
Dust Powdered Sugar Snow
Scoop the 2 tablespoons of powdered sugar into the fine-mesh stainless steel sieve. Hold the sieve 15cm above the decorated treat houses, tapping the edge lightly to dust a thin, even layer of powdered sugar over the roofs and Peeps, mimicking fresh fallen snow. Avoid over-dusting, as too much sugar will obscure the Peep shapes and decorations.
Plate and Serve Treats
Arrange three decorated Peeps Christmas houses on the top matte white ceramic dessert plate from the stack, spacing them 2cm apart to look like a tiny holiday village. Add a light extra dusting of powdered sugar to the plate surface around the houses, then serve immediately. Store leftover treats in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days.
Tips
2.Lightly grease your spatula and knife with a tiny dab of butter before pressing or cutting the cereal mixture: this prevents sticky marshmallow from pulling treats out of shape and leaving ragged edges.
3.Wait to add Peeps and sprinkles until the icing is still slightly tacky: if the icing forms a dry crust, decorations will slide off instead of staying securely attached to the treat houses.

OMG these are the cutest Christmas activity I’ve done with my boys all season! Took literally 10 minutes like the recipe said, no fancy ingredients, and they got to decorate each little house with extra sprinkles we had in the pantry. My youngest tried to eat half the Peeps before we even assembled anything lmao. Total hit for our elementary school class holiday party!
Game changer for my annual neighborhood Christmas potluck! I set up a little build-your-own house station with extra candy canes, mini chocolate chips, and green frosting, and both the kids and grown ups were obsessed. So much easier than making full gingerbread houses that take forever and taste like cardboard tbh.
Super easy recipe, I swapped in gluten-free crispy rice cereal for my kid with celiac and it worked perfectly! Only knock is I wish the recipe came with a simple template for cutting the house shapes, I freehanded it and a couple of my walls were wonky. Still tasted amazing though!
Made these for my dorm floor holiday hang and people were begging for the recipe! No oven needed, super cheap to make with stuff from the campus grocery store, and they look way fancier than they are. 10/10 would make again even when it’s not Christmas tbh.
My kids loved it!! We made these after we picked out our Christmas tree last weekend, and we even used the little Peeps snowmen as the 'residents' of each house. We added tiny pretzel stick fences around each one and they looked so cute I almost didn’t want to eat them. Almost 😂
Taste was great, but I tried to make these a day ahead for my book club holiday meeting and the Peeps got a little stale and crunchy on the edges. Still edible, just not as soft and squishy as I expected.
Full disclosure, I’m terrible at baking. Like, burn toast level bad. But these were SO easy even I didn’t mess them up! My daughter thought I was a culinary genius when I pulled these out for our family dinner pre-Christmas movie night. Winning at dad points this week.
Used vegan marshmallows, dairy-free butter, and vegan Peeps to make these for my vegan friend group and they turned out chef’s kiss! The only reason it’s not 5 stars is I had to cook the marshmallow base a tiny bit longer than the recipe said to get the right sticky consistency, but that’s probably just because of the vegan swap. Will absolutely make again!
Made these with my 2nd grade class for our holiday party Friday and it was the perfect activity! No messy dough to roll out, no long bake times, every kid got to take their own little house home. I sent the recipe link to all the parents in my class newsletter because so many asked for it!
I made these with my grandbabies when they came to visit over the weekend and we had the best time! I remember making traditional crispy rice treats with my own kids back in the day, and adding the little Peeps houses makes it feel so festive for the holidays. So simple, so tasty.
Just whipped these up for a last-minute holiday work potluck and they’re going fast! The combo of the buttery crispy rice treat and the sweet Peeps is unbeatable, people are coming back for seconds (and thirds). So glad I found this last minute recipe!
These were great! Only heads up for other parents: if you’re making these with toddlers, skip the extra hard candy decorations I almost added, the Peeps and crispy rice are soft enough for little kids to chew easily. My 2 year old was shoveling bites faster than I could plate them!
I run a little home bakery out of my kitchen and I added these to my holiday treat box lineup this year! My customers are going crazy for them, they’re such a fun nostalgic twist on regular crispy rice treats and they look so cute tucked in next to cookies and fudge. Total bestseller!
I was so excited for these, but I think I messed up the marshmallow to cereal ratio? My treats came out super crumbly and wouldn’t hold the house shape at all, I ended up just tossing all the crumbs in a bowl and eating them like regular crispy rice treats. Bummed they didn’t turn out like the photos!
I added a little extra vanilla extract to the marshmallow base and it made these taste next level! They’re definitely a sweet treat, but portioned out as little houses they’re the perfect size for a small holiday indulgence without going overboard. Super fun to make too!
Made these as the grand prize for my annual ugly Christmas sweater party contest and they were a massive hit! The winner posted a pic of her house on Instagram and I had three people text me for the recipe. Way better than a boring gift card prize tbh.
I wasn’t sure if these would feel too 'kid focused' for my annual adult holiday cocktail party, but I set them out on the dessert platter and they were gone in 10 minutes! Everyone was commenting on how fun and nostalgic they are, it brought back so many memories of making crispy rice treats as kids.
Just made these by myself for my family’s Christmas Eve pre-dinner snacks and my parents were so impressed! I’m 14 and just started learning to cook, this was so easy to follow I didn’t even have to ask my mom for help. The recipe directions were super clear!
We got 8 inches of snow today so we were stuck inside, and making these was the perfect snow day activity! We had a blast putting little marshmallow snow drifts around the houses and making a whole little Peeps village on our kitchen counter. Best snow day ever!
Total win for anyone on a tight holiday budget! I already had most of the ingredients in my pantry, only had to grab a pack of Christmas Peeps from the dollar store, and I got 8 whole little houses out of one batch. Way cheaper than buying a gingerbread house kit that falls apart in 2 seconds!