1.Why is this cocktail called Penicillin?
▾
This iconic modern cocktail was created by bartender Sam Ross in 2005 at New York City’s legendary Milk & Honey bar. It gets its name because its core ingredients—spicy fresh ginger, soothing raw honey, bright lemon, and warming Scotch—evoke the cozy, cold-fighting comfort of a home remedy, though it has no actual medicinal properties, of course!
2.Can I make the honey-ginger syrup ahead of time?
▾
Absolutely! To make the syrup, simmer equal parts raw honey and water with ½ cup sliced fresh ginger per 2 cups of liquid for 10 minutes, strain, and cool fully. It will keep in a sealed glass jar in your fridge for up to 2 weeks, so you can batch it for quick Penicillins on demand with no last-minute prep required.
3.Do I have to use peaty Islay single malt Scotch for the float?
▾
The peaty Islay float is what gives the Penicillin its signature smoky top note, so I don’t recommend skipping it entirely if you can help it. If you don’t have Islay single malt, use any heavily peated Scotch as a stand-in, but avoid unpeated Scotches here—you’ll miss that distinct campfire-like layer that makes the drink feel special.
4.What’s the best blended Scotch to use for the drink’s base?
▾
You don’t need a pricey premium blended Scotch for the base! Reach for a smooth, approachable blended Scotch like Johnnie Walker Black Label, Monkey Shoulder, or Famous Grouse. Save your high-end, complex single malts for sipping neat—you want the base to be smooth enough to let the honey, ginger, and lemon shine without overpowering them.
5.Can I use bottled lemon juice instead of fresh-squeezed?
▾
I really don’t recommend bottled lemon juice here. Fresh-squeezed lemon juice has that bright, zingy, slightly tart edge that balances sweet honey and spicy ginger perfectly, while bottled juice tastes flat and often has added preservatives that throw the drink’s balance off. It only takes 1 minute to squeeze a fresh lemon half per drink, so it’s worth the tiny extra effort.
6.How do I get that perfect, distinct smoky float on top?
▾
For a clean, smoky float that sits neatly on top instead of mixing fully into the drink, pour the peaty Islay Scotch slowly over the back of a bar spoon held just above the surface of your shaken, strained cocktail. This slows the pour so the smoky whisky spreads evenly across the top for that iconic first smoky sip.
7.Is the Penicillin served up or on the rocks?
▾
The classic Penicillin is served on the rocks in a short, sturdy old fashioned (rocks) glass. I recommend using one large, slow-melting ice cube if you have it, to keep the drink cold without diluting it too quickly as you sip. Skip the martini glass here—this is a cozy, slow-sipping drink meant to be enjoyed over ice.
8.Can I make a non-alcoholic version of the Penicillin?
▾
You absolutely can! Swap the blended Scotch for a non-alcoholic whisky alternative (like Ritual Zero Proof Whiskey or Lyre’s American Malt), skip the peaty float or replace it with a tiny splash of strong lapsang souchong tea for that smoky note, and keep the lemon, honey, and ginger components exactly the same for that same cozy, balanced flavor.
9.How much fresh ginger do I need per drink if I don’t pre-make syrup?
▾
If you don’t want to pre-batch honey-ginger syrup, you can muddle 2 thin slices of peeled fresh ginger (about ¼-inch thick each) in the bottom of your shaker with ¾ ounce of raw honey before adding the rest of your ingredients. Double-strain the drink after shaking to catch stringy ginger bits so you don’t get gritty texture in your glass.
10.Why do people say this drink helps with cold symptoms?
▾
That reputation comes from its familiar cold-soother ingredients: ginger is known for easing nausea and throat irritation, honey coats sore throats, lemon adds a hit of vitamin C, and the small amount of alcohol creates a warming, relaxing effect that eases cold-related discomfort. That said, it’s not a medical treatment—always hydrate with water too if you’re under the weather!
11.Can I batch this cocktail for a party or gathering?
▾
Batching Penicillins for a party is a great call! Mix up a big batch of the blended Scotch, lemon juice, and honey-ginger syrup in a sealed pitcher and keep it chilled in the fridge for up to 3 days. Wait to add ice and the peaty Islay float until right when guests are served, so the drink stays properly balanced and the smoky top note stays bright.
12.What’s the correct ingredient ratio for a single classic serving?
▾
For a perfectly balanced classic Penicillin, use 2 ounces of blended Scotch, ¾ ounce of fresh lemon juice, ¾ ounce of honey-ginger syrup, and ¼ ounce of peaty Islay single malt for the float. Shake the first three ingredients with ice for 12-15 seconds until very cold, strain over fresh ice, then add the smoky float on top.
13.Can I use regular clover honey instead of raw honey?
▾
You can, though raw honey has a richer, more floral, slightly earthy depth that pairs beautifully with ginger and Scotch. If you only have regular processed clover honey, use the same amount, but add a tiny pinch of freshly grated ginger to the syrup to amp up the spice a bit to make up for the less complex honey flavor. Avoid artificial honey substitutes here, as they’ll throw off texture and taste.
14.Do I need fancy bar tools to make this at home?
▾
You don’t need fancy professional bar gear to make a great Penicillin at home! A basic cocktail shaker (even a mason jar with a tight lid works), a fine mesh strainer, a standard jigger or measuring shot glass, and a regular spoon to help with the float are all you need. No specialty muddlers, fancy strainers, or luxury glassware required.
15.What garnish works best for a Penicillin?
▾
The classic garnish is a thin slice of candied ginger or a twist of lemon peel, expressed over the top of the drink to release its bright citrus oils. I love adding a light dusting of freshly grated cinnamon on top for extra warm, cozy depth if I’m making these in fall or winter, but skip over-the-top garnishes—this is a simple, rustic, spirit-forward drink.
16.My finished drink turned out too sweet—how do I fix it?
▾
If your Penicillin tastes too sweet, you either added too much honey-ginger syrup or your lemon juice wasn’t tart enough to balance it. Stir in an extra ¼ ounce of fresh lemon juice, or add a tiny splash more blended Scotch to cut the sweetness. Next time, taste your honey-ginger syrup first—if your honey is extra sweet, cut it with a touch more water when making the batch.
OMG this Penicillin recipe is an absolute game changer! I made a big batch when my whole household came down with a cold last week, and even my super picky 7 year old asked for refills. The balance of honey, ginger, and lemon is perfect, not too sharp at all. I split the batch and added a splash of scotch to the adult portions for our little at-home sick day movie night. SO good, I’m keeping the base syrup in my fridge all winter long!
I brought a big thermos of this (non-alcoholic version) to my kid’s weekend soccer tournament when the weather dropped to 30 degrees, and every parent on the team was begging for the recipe! It warmed everyone right up, and it’s way better than the sugary hot cocoa we usually bring. I added a tiny pinch of cayenne like a friend suggested and it gave the best little kick.
Really solid recipe! I made the alcoholic version for my buddy’s guys’ night last weekend, and everyone was impressed it only took me 30 minutes total to prep. Knocked a star off only because I thought it needed a little extra lemon for my taste, but that’s just personal preference. Will definitely make again.
Game. Changer. I’ve been buying overpriced pre-made wellness shots from the grocery store for months, and this recipe tastes better and costs a fraction of the price. I meal prepped 8 servings on Sunday to have on hand for busy work mornings, and I swear my usual mid-week slump is already gone. 10/10.
Took a thermos of this on our fall day hike last weekend, and it was the perfect pick-me-up when we stopped for lunch at the summit. The ginger gives such a nice warm feeling that sticks with you, even when the wind is blowing. My teen said it tastes like a fancy spa drink, which is high praise coming from him.
Love that this recipe is naturally vegan with zero weird processed ingredients! I swapped regular honey for dandelion honey to keep it fully plant-based, and it turned out absolutely perfect. Served it at my weekly book club meetup and all the girls asked for the link to the recipe.
Made this for our weekly board game night last night, and it was a huge hit! I will say, if you’re making the cocktail version, go easy on the scotch at first— I overdid it on the first batch and it overpowered the ginger and honey flavors. Once I adjusted the ratio it was chef’s kiss.
My kids loved this so much they asked for it instead of hot cocoa after school yesterday! I made a big pot of the non-alcoholic base, added a couple cinnamon sticks while it simmered, and let them add a little extra honey to their own mugs. It’s so easy to throw together even on busy school nights when we’re scrambling to get dinner on the table, I know we’ll be making this all cold and flu season.
Bro this saved me during midterms week. I was starting to feel a cold come on right before my stats final, chugged two mugs of this the night before, and I felt good enough to crush the exam. Way cheaper than ordering delivery soup every time I feel under the weather, and it’s easy enough to make even in my tiny dorm kitchen with zero fancy equipment.
I served this at our annual fall potluck last weekend, and people were coming back for thirds! I set up a little station with add-ins: cinnamon sticks, lemon wedges, extra honey, and a little bottle of bourbon for folks who wanted to spike their cup. It was such a fun, cozy touch for the party.
Really tasty recipe, super straightforward to make. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is that I found the ginger a little too strong when I followed the measurements exactly— I used really fresh homegrown ginger from my garden, so that’s probably why! I dialed it back on the second batch and it was perfect for me.
I’ve been making a version of this for years, but this recipe’s ratio of ingredients is hands down the best I’ve tried. It’s not too sweet, not too tart, and the ginger doesn’t overpower everything else. I made a batch for my neighbor who just had knee surgery, and she texted me saying it was the coziest thing she’d had all recovery.
Just finished making my first batch, and WOW. I was a little skeptical because the name is silly, but this is legit. I added a little extra lemon and a dash of turmeric because I had some lying around, and it’s perfect. Already texted the recipe to my whole family, they’re gonna love it.
Made this for my husband who came home from work with a sore throat today, and he said it’s better than the canned chicken noodle soup his mom used to make him when he was sick! Win for the new wife, right? It was so easy I didn’t even mess it up, which is saying something because I’m still learning my way around the kitchen.
I’ve been making a similar hot toddy recipe for 40 years, and I have to say, this version is top notch. I made a batch for my weekly golf group when we had an early tee time in 40 degree weather last week, and all the guys were raving about it. Used a nice peaty scotch for the adult version, which added such great depth of flavor.
Great recipe! I made it for my office holiday party, and it was a nice change of pace from all the super sweet Christmas punch everyone usually brings. The only thing I’ll do differently next time is make a double batch— we ran out in the first 45 minutes! Definitely a crowd pleaser.