pitboss
intro
Slow-smoked hickory pulled pork cooked low and slow on a Pit Boss pellet grill, with crispy mahogany bark, tender pull-apart texture, and bright tangy vinegar mop, perfect for summer backyard gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Trim Pork Fat Cap
Place the 5lb bone-in pork shoulder on the center of the maple cutting board. Use the 8-inch stainless steel chef's knife to trim the thick fat cap down to an even 1/4-inch thickness, removing any hard, waxy fat deposits or loose silver skin from the meat surface. Leave a thin, even fat layer to keep the meat moist during smoking; the surface should feel smooth with no ragged edges when you run your palm across it.
Combine Dry Rub
Add all measured kosher salt, black pepper, smoked paprika, light brown sugar, garlic powder, onion powder, and cayenne pepper to the stainless steel mixing bowl. Stir thoroughly with the stainless steel whisk until fully combined, breaking up any clumps of brown sugar, until the rub is a uniform deep rust color with an even coarse texture.
Apply Rub to Pork
Pat the trimmed pork shoulder completely dry with the edge of the navy cotton kitchen towel, then spread the 2 tbsp yellow mustard in a thin, even layer across every surface of the pork to act as a binder for the rub. Sprinkle the mixed dry rub generously over all sides of the pork, pressing gently with your palm to adhere the rub to the meat, ensuring full, even coverage with no bare patches. Let the rubbed pork rest at room temperature for 45 minutes while the grill preheats.
Preheat Pellet Grill
Fill the Pit Boss grill hopper with the 2lb of hickory wood pellets, then preheat the grill to 225°F (107°C), keeping the lid closed for 15 minutes until the temperature holds steady. Wait for thin, wispy blue smoke to emerge from the grill chimney; thick white smoke indicates incomplete combustion and will create bitter-tasting meat.
Smoke Pork Low and Slow
Place the rubbed pork shoulder directly on the preheated Pit Boss grill grate, fat-side up. Close the lid and smoke at 225°F for 6 hours, avoiding unnecessary lid openings which drop grill temperature by 25-30°F and add 15 minutes of cook time per opening. After 6 hours, use the digital instant-read thermometer to begin checking internal temperature.
Mop and Wrap Pork
When the pork reaches an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) (approximately 6 hours into cooking), carefully transfer it from the grill back to the maple cutting board. Mix the apple cider vinegar and Worcestershire sauce in the clear glass mason jar, then use the silicone basting brush to mop the vinegar mixture evenly across all surfaces of the pork. Wrap the pork tightly in two layers of heavy-duty aluminum foil, then return it to the grill to finish cooking.
Rest Smoked Pork
Continue cooking the foil-wrapped pork at 225°F until the internal temperature reaches 203°F (95°C), when the thermometer probe slides into the meat with no resistance, like a knife into soft butter (this takes an additional 1.5-2 hours). Remove the pork from the grill, place it back on the maple cutting board, and let it rest, still wrapped in foil, for 1 full hour to allow juices to redistribute through the muscle fibers.
Pull and Plate Pork
Unwrap the rested pork, pouring any collected juices from the foil into a small terracotta ramekin for serving. Use the matte black meat claws to pull the pork into tender, bite-sized shreds, mixing chunks of the dark crispy bark evenly throughout the soft meat shreds. Pile the pulled pork onto the matte terracotta serving platter, drizzle with remaining mop sauce, and tuck dill pickle slices and parsley sprigs around the edges for garnish.
Tips
2.Wait for thin, wispy blue smoke before adding the pork to the grill: thick, white billowing smoke comes from incomplete pellet combustion and will leave a bitter, sooty aftertaste on the finished meat.
3.Never skip the 1-hour rest period after cooking: as the pork rests, relaxed muscle fibers reabsorb rendered juices, ensuring every bite is moist instead of having all juices run out onto the plate when the meat is pulled.

OMG this hickory smoked pulled pork was a total game changer for my weekend cookout! I followed the temp guide exactly and the bark was perfect, not too chewy, just that crisp smoky crust everyone raves about. Served it with coleslaw and pickles on brioche buns and all my neighbors asked for the recipe. SO good.
Made this for our Sunday family dinner last night and my kids LOVED it! Even my super picky 7 year old who turns his nose up at most meat went back for seconds. I was nervous because this is only my third time using my Pit Boss, but the instructions were so clear I didn’t mess it up at all. Only thing I did different was use a little extra brown sugar in the rub. Will absolutely be making this again for our next potluck!
Okay full transparency I’ve burned every single thing I’ve tried to smoke on my new Pit Boss up until this recipe. Cook time was spot on, I didn’t have to guess at temps, and the pulled pork came out juicy enough that I didn’t even douse it in extra sauce (though the sauce recommendation in the recipe slapped too). Already texted this link to all my friends who got smokers for Christmas last year and still haven’t made something edible.
Solid recipe, 4 stars only because I found the cook time ran about 45 minutes longer for my 8 pound shoulder than the recipe stated, probably because it was a little colder outside when I was smoking (it was 40 degrees here in IL). The flavor was unreal though, that hickory smoke didn’t overpower the pork at all, just that perfect balanced smoke taste. I’m planning to use the leftovers for meal prep this week—pulled pork nachos, sliders, loaded baked potatoes, the works.
I brought this pulled pork to my office potluck last week and people were literally coming up to me for the recipe before I even finished setting up my dish! I did a 9 pound shoulder, let it rest for the full hour like the recipe said, and it pulled apart so easily I barely had to use my meat claws. Only heads up is make sure you have enough hickory pellets before you start— I ran out halfway through last time and had to beg my neighbor for a cup of pellets to finish the cook lmao.
This pulled pork is my new go-to Sunday meal prep staple! I make a big batch every other week, portion it out, and it freezes so well for quick weeknight dinners. The hickory flavor holds up even after reheating, which is a big win because a lot of smoked meats get really dry or lose that smoke taste when you microwave them later. 10/10, saves me so much time during the work week.
As someone who’s been smoking brisket and pork for 20+ years I’m pretty picky about my smoked pork recipes, and this one absolutely delivers. The hickory ratio is perfect— not so much that it tastes like you’re eating a campfire, just that deep, rich smoke that makes pulled pork taste like summer. I used a yellow mustard binder per the recipe and it helped the rub stick so much better than my usual oil binder, total convert now.
Made this for my fraternity’s tailgate last weekend and it was a total hit! We fed 25 guys off a 10 pound pork shoulder and there were barely any leftovers. I was worried cooking for that many people would be a disaster but the step by step made it impossible to mess up, even with my beat up hand-me-down Pit Boss. Would recommend to anyone who needs a cheap, crowd-pleasing cook for game day.
Tried this recipe for my husband’s birthday cookout and he said it was better than the pulled pork we had on our trip to Asheville last year! I used a mix of hickory and a little apple wood like the recipe suggested as a variation and it added the perfect little sweet note to the smoke. My only regret is not making more because everyone wanted to take leftovers home.
Smoked this pork before a 3 day backpacking trip and vacuum sealed portions to bring along, it was the best trail meal I’ve ever had. No weird dehydrated food taste, just hearty, smoky pork that gave me enough energy for 10 mile days. The cook time was long but totally hands off so I was able to get all my packing done while it smoked. Will be making this before every big trip from now on.
My grandson came over and helped me make this pulled pork last weekend, it was such a fun project to do together! He loved getting to season the rub and help pull the pork once it was done resting. We had it for our family reunion the next day and all my cousins said it was the best dish there. I’ve been making pulled pork for 40 years and this hickory recipe is going straight into my family recipe box, it’s a keeper.