popular whiskey drinks
intro
Three iconic, approachable whiskey drinks—Old Fashioned, Whiskey Sour, Japanese Highball—balanced to please new sippers and seasoned fans alike for casual gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep citrus garnishes
Place the whole lemon and orange on the small oak cutting board. Use the paring knife to cut two 2-inch wide orange peel twists (taking care to avoid cutting into the bitter white pith), two thin 1/8-inch lemon wheel slices, and two 2-inch lemon peel twists. Juice one whole lemon using the beech wood reamer, straining out seeds to collect 30ml (1 fl oz) of fresh lemon juice; pour the collected juice into the empty white ramekin reserved for juice. Set cut peels and wheels on the edge of the cutting board, and scrape all pith and seed scraps into the brass scrap dish.
Chill serving glasses
Pull two DOF glasses and one highball glass from the stacked set at back right. Place one large ice cube in each glass, then top each with 1 tbsp cold tap water to speed chilling. Set the glasses back in their spot at back right for 2 minutes, until faint condensation starts to form on the exterior, indicating the glass is fully chilled. Dump all ice water out of the glasses right before adding drink ingredients.
Mix Old Fashioned base
Add 1 tsp total of granulated sugar (0.5 tsp per chilled, emptied DOF glass) then add 3 dashes of aromatic bitters and 1 tsp cold water to each glass. Use the twisted stainless steel bar spoon to stir the sugar mixture gently for 30 seconds, until the sugar fully dissolves into a smooth, dark syrup with no grit visible at the bottom of the glass. Measure 60ml (2 fl oz) of bourbon with the jigger and pour into each glass, then drop one large 2-inch ice cube into each drink.
Garnish Old Fashioned drinks
Stir each Old Fashioned gently with the bar spoon for 20 seconds to chill the liquid, until the outside of the glass feels uniformly cold. Hold one orange peel twist over each glass, skin side facing the drink, and squeeze gently to release a fine mist of citrus oils over the drink surface. Rub the peel along the outer rim of the glass, then drape it over the edge of the glass. Drop one maraschino cherry into each glass, resting it against the ice cube.
Shake Whiskey Sour base
Separate one egg white, placing the white into the matte black cocktail shaker (discard yolk or save for another use). Add 60ml (2 fl oz) bourbon, 30ml (1 fl oz) fresh lemon juice, 1 tsp granulated sugar, and 2 dashes of aromatic bitters to the shaker. Do not add ice yet: seal the shaker tightly and shake vigorously for 15 seconds to emulsify the egg white into a thick, frothy foam (you will hear the liquid slosh loudly as you shake). Add two large ice cubes to the shaker, seal again, and shake for another 20 seconds until the outside of the shaker feels frosty and ice-cold to the touch.
Strain and garnish Sour
Take the remaining chilled DOF glass, dump out the ice water, and place one large 2-inch ice cube in the bottom. Set the Hawthorne strainer over the top of the cocktail shaker, pressing the coil tight against the shaker edge to catch ice shards. Pour the shaken whiskey sour mixture into the glass over the ice, until the thick frothy foam rises ¼ inch above the liquid line. Drop one maraschino cherry into the drink, and perch half a thin lemon wheel on the glass rim.
Build Japanese Highball
Take the chilled highball glass, dump out the ice water, and refill it to ½ inch below the rim with fresh large ice cubes, stacking them gently to minimize gaps. Measure 60ml (2 fl oz) of bourbon with the jigger and pour over the ice. Hold the sparkling water bottle just above the glass edge and pour 120ml (4 fl oz) of chilled sparkling water slowly down the inside of the glass to preserve fizz. Stir the drink exactly once very gently with the bar spoon to lightly mix the whiskey and water, being careful not to agitate the bubbles.
Arrange and serve drinks
Hold one lemon peel twist over the top of the highball, squeeze gently to release citrus oils over the drink surface, rub the peel along the rim, then tuck it into the ice next to the glass edge. Arrange all four finished drinks (two Old Fashioneds, one Whiskey Sour, one Highball) in a loose cluster on the front center of the counter, ready to serve immediately while cold.
Tips
2.Do the initial 'dry shake' (without ice) for the Whiskey Sour first: this emulsifies the egg white into a thick, velvety, long-lasting foam instead of a thin, watery layer that dissolves quickly.
3.Pour sparkling water slowly down the side of the Highball glass and stir only once: this preserves bright carbonation and avoids over-mixing, resulting in a light, bubbly drink instead of a flat, dull sip.

Made these for our weekend backyard cookout and everyone went crazy! The Old Fashioned recipe is exactly what I’ve been trying to nail for years, no weird fancy ingredients needed. SO good, even my buddy who only drinks beer asked for a second round.
Tried the whiskey sour for my girls’ night in last week and it was a total hit! I did skip the egg white because a couple people are weird about raw eggs, but it still tasted amazing. Super easy to mix up even when you’re juggling hosting duties.
Game changer for my post-hike porch hangs! I’ve been overpaying for these at downtown bars forever, can’t believe how simple they are to throw together. The Manhattan ratio is perfect, not too sweet, just the right amount of vermouth. 10/10.
Just mixed up my first ever Old Fashioned for my husband’s birthday pre-dinner drink and he said it tastes better than the one we got on our honeymoon in Nashville! So easy to follow, no fancy bar tools required even. Obsessed.
Brought a batch of whiskey sours to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! Quick question though—can I pre-batch these a few hours ahead for a party next weekend, or will they get weird if they sit too long?
Recipes are solid overall, but I personally think the Manhattan ratio leans a little too heavy on the sweet vermouth for my taste. Ended up adding an extra half ounce of rye to balance it out for my preference.
Made the Old Fashioned and Manhattan for my at-home date night last night and my partner thought I ordered takeout from the fancy cocktail bar downtown! OMG, I felt like a professional mixologist even though I’ve never made a proper cocktail before in my life.
Tested these out for our college football tailgate last Saturday and they went over so much better than the usual seltzers and beer we usually bring. Only downside is I ran out way faster than I expected, should’ve made double the batch!
Saving this for our annual Thanksgiving family dinner! These look so much nicer than the cheap wine we usually serve with appetizers, and since there’s no heat required I can mix them up while the turkey finishes roasting without extra chaos.
These look amazing! I don’t drink alcohol but my partner loves whiskey, would these work with a non-alcoholic whiskey substitute for when we have friends who don’t drink over?
I run a tiny neighborhood bar upstate and I used these exact ratios to train our new part-time bartender last week! It’s the perfect no-fuss classic recipe that doesn’t overcomplicate things, which is exactly what new staff needs to learn first.
Wait a second, I’ve been paying $14 a pop for these at my local happy hour for YEARS? The total cost per drink here is like $2 max when you already have the liquor at home. Total game changer for my weekend budget, no more wasting money on overpriced bar drinks.
Total newbie question, sorry! I don’t have a fancy cocktail shaker or strainer at home, can I still make the whiskey sour with regular stuff I have in my kitchen? Like a mason jar and a regular mesh strainer?
Made all three of these for our Kentucky Derby watch party last weekend and they were such a hit! I set out little mint sprigs and extra cherries for garnish and everyone said it felt like we were at a fancy lounge instead of my living room. My cousin even brought his fancy bourbon to use for the next round!
Loved all three recipes, but I added a tiny extra splash of simple syrup to the whiskey sour because I have a massive sweet tooth, and it was perfect for me! My roommate who hates sweet drinks thought the original ratio was spot on, so it’s really easy to adjust to taste.