Potato Salad
intro
Creamy, tangy, hearty classic potato salad with tender spuds, crisp veggies, and a rich mayo-mustard dressing, ideal for warm-weather gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Boil potatoes and eggs
Place peeled, 2.5cm cubed russet potatoes and 2 large eggs in a large stockpot, cover with 2L cold water, and stir in 1 teaspoon of kosher salt. Bring to a rolling boil over medium-high heat, then reduce to medium heat to maintain a gentle boil; cook 12 minutes total, then use a slotted spoon to remove the eggs and plunge them into a bowl of ice water to stop cooking. Continue cooking potatoes for 2-3 more minutes (14-15 minutes total boil time) until fork-tender (a fork pierces the center with light pressure, no mushy crumbing). Drain potatoes fully, then spread in a single layer on a rimmed baking sheet to cool for 7 minutes. Peel cooled eggs once they are safe to handle.
Mix the creamy dressing
In a large glass mixing bowl, combine 120ml full-fat mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard, 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar, 1 tablespoon reserved dill pickle brine, remaining 0.5 teaspoon kosher salt, and 0.5 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper. Whisk steadily for 30 seconds until the mixture is completely smooth, pale creamy yellow, with no streaks of unincorporated mustard.
Prep salad mix-ins
While potatoes cool, cut celery, red onion, and dill pickles into uniform 0.5cm dice; chop peeled hard-boiled eggs into 1cm chunks, and chop 2 tablespoons of fresh dill. Pat diced pickles lightly with a paper towel to remove excess brine that would thin the dressing.
Toss all ingredients gently
Add the slightly warm (40C/104F, not piping hot) cooled potato cubes, prepped diced vegetables, chopped eggs, and fresh dill to the bowl of dressing. Use a flexible rubber spatula to gently fold the mixture for 1-2 minutes, taking care not to mash potato cubes, until every piece is evenly coated in creamy dressing.
Chill to meld flavors
Cover the mixing bowl tightly with plastic wrap, then refrigerate for a minimum of 10 minutes (up to 24 hours for deeper, more developed flavor) until the salad reaches a chilled 4C/40F serving temperature.
Garnish and serve chilled
Remove chilled potato salad from the refrigerator, give it one light, gentle stir to redistribute any settled dressing, top with extra fresh dill sprigs and a light crack of black pepper, then serve in a chilled ceramic serving bowl.
Tips
2.Wait until potatoes cool to slightly warm (not piping hot) before tossing with dressing: high heat will cause mayonnaise to split and turn greasy, ruining the creamy texture.
3.Store leftover potato salad in a sealed airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days; do not leave it at room temperature for more than 2 hours to avoid food safety risks.

OMG this potato salad was the star of our Memorial Day cookout! Everyone kept asking for the recipe, I lost count of how many people went back for seconds. The balance of creamy dressing, crunchy celery, and a little tang from the pickles is *chef’s kiss* SO good.
Took this to my office potluck yesterday and my coworkers practically licked the bowl clean! Only tweak I made was adding a handful of crumbled bacon because, well, bacon makes everything better. 10/10 will make again all summer.
Super easy even for someone who burns toast half the time! Made this for my roommate’s birthday cookout and he said it tasted just like his grandma’s. Win in my book, no fancy ingredients needed either.
Wait, do you leave the potato skins on or peel them? I’ve had it both ways and never know which is more authentic for classic American potato salad! Planning to make this for our 4th of July block party next weekend.
Perfect for weekly meal prep! I made a big batch on Sunday and it held up so well all week for quick lunch sides, the dressing didn’t get soggy at all even after 5 days in the fridge. Will be on regular rotation for sure.
This is good, but I felt like it was missing a little zing! Any ideas for what I can add next time to give it a little kick without overpowering that classic creamy flavor?
I’ve been making potato salad for 50 years and I tried this recipe last week for my grandkids’ visit and they all loved it! I swapped the sweet pickles for dill like I always do and it turned out perfect. Sometimes you can teach an old dog new tricks!
Made this as a side for our post-hike picnic last weekend and it traveled so well! Didn’t get watery even sitting in the cooler for a few hours, everyone in our group raved about it. So easy to throw together after a busy Saturday morning too.
Wait, how long do you boil the potatoes for? I always either undercook them so they’re crunchy or overcook them so they turn to mush when I mix in the dressing 😭 I really want to get this right for my boyfriend’s family dinner!
Has anyone tried making this with Greek yogurt instead of mayo to lighten it up? I have a few family members coming to our BBQ who don’t eat mayo and I don’t want to make a whole separate dish if I don’t have to!
SO good. Made this for the football watch party last Sunday and it was gone by the end of the first quarter. Even my buddy who swears he ‘hates potato salad’ had two helpings. Absolute game changer for side dishes.
I added extra dill pickles and a little splash of the pickle brine like the recipe suggested and oh my gosh, that’s the secret! I could eat this straight out of the bowl no joke. My kid asked for thirds at dinner last night, which never happens.
Wait, is this supposed to be served cold or warm? I grew up eating warm German potato salad so I never know for the creamy American version! Making this for a brunch potluck tomorrow.
How many servings does this make? I’ve got 12 people coming over for Father’s Day dinner and I want to make sure I make enough, don’t want anyone going without potato salad!
My husband said this is better than his mom’s potato salad… but don’t tell her I said that 😂 It was so easy to make for our first summer BBQ as a married couple, we’ll be making this every year for sure. The egg addition is chef’s kiss, I never thought to add chopped hard boiled egg before!
Love that this only takes 45 minutes total! I’m so used to potato salad recipes requiring a million steps and hours of chill time, but this came together so fast on a weeknight to go with our grilled burgers. Total weeknight win.